Notifications

I Was In Charge Of The Yucca Mountain Project - Until Obama Shut Us Down. Let's Bring It Back.


Proposed Radioactive Waste Site in Nevada
Getty - David McNew
 IJR Opinion is an opinion platform and any opinions or information put forth by contributors are exclusive to them and do not represent the views of IJR.

As one of the former directors of the Department of Energy’s program charged with disposing of spent nuclear fuel and Defense high-level radioactive waste, we had high hopes for the Yucca Mountain project.

And then the Obama Administration, for political reasons, suddenly shut us down.

Over 85,000 metric tons of civilian spent nuclear fuel and Defense high-level radioactive waste are currently stranded in 35 States around this nation. That’s enough nuclear waste to cover a football field 15 yards deep.

Unshielded, these materials would provide a lethal radiation dose to a nearby person in minutes. All of this waste currently sits in cooling pools or in storage facilities at over 70 sites. With the ending of the Obama Administration, the nation has an opportunity to finally address its longstanding commitment to dispose of these materials.

Prior to President Obama, the nation had followed through on a well-constructed plan to find a long-term geologic repository for all of our nuclear waste, as directed in the Nuclear Waste Policy Act of 1982.

In 1987, for primarily fiscal reasons, the original Act was amended to focus scientific studies on the highest rated and safest geologic repository site – Yucca Mountain, Nevada.

The vote in the U.S. Senate at that time to select the Yucca Mountain site for further study was 98-2.  The U.S. House vote was also overwhelming.

The Yucca Mountain site was exhaustively studied for over 20 years, during which time over eight billion dollars was expended on its evaluation. The Department of Energy submitted the Yucca Mountain license application to Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) in June 2008.

That application was under review by the NRC when the Obama Administration took office in January 2009 and a decision on the safety of the site, by law, would have been rendered in 2012 – over four years ago.

However, during the 2008 Presidential campaign, a backroom political deal was reached between then Senator Barack Obama and Senator Harry Reid. Simply put, if Reid moved up the Democratic Party Nevada Caucuses several weeks to allow Obama an early primary victory then, if Obama were elected, he would stop the Yucca Mountain Project.

The Obama/Reid political arrangement has been discussed publicly in various Congressional Hearings and is a matter of public record.

After President Obama’s election, the program was subsequently starved of funds and the remaining 850 Federal employees and contractor staff were either fired or dispositioned elsewhere. The records for the program were mothballed and sent to a Federal records graveyard in West Virginia with their retrievability questionable.

The sheer hubris of the Executive Branch unilaterally terminating a program that had been legally progressing to a conclusion was virtually unnoticed in the press due to the 2008-9 financial crisis.

To attempt to fill the void it had just created, the Obama Administration directed the Secretary of Energy to establish a “Blue Ribbon Commission” to look at other options for high–level waste disposal.  After two years of monotonous droning of public hearings and meetings, the Commission came up with the pre-programmed conclusion that the current path (disposal at Yucca Mountain) was not workable.

That Commission then recommended that the nation should effectively start over looking for geologic repository sites - setting back progress in this area nearly 30 years.

With the completion of that report in 2012, exactly no progress has been made on alternatives. In addition, no serious attempt has been made at new legislation on this issue or the pursuit of another policy path, since the Obama Administration’s political objective of satisfying Senator Reid had been accommodated.

That accommodation, however, was done at the expense of the rest of the United States.

As I testified before Congress, the Obama Administration’s decision to shut down the Yucca Mountain Project is troubling because Yucca Mountain has not failed any technical or regulatory test. The thousands of our brightest scientists and engineers that worked on this massive undertaking believe, as I believe, that the site would meet the stringent regulations of the Environmental Protection Agency and the NRC and assure the long term safety of the public from these materials, thereby protecting future generations and the environment.

Given the substantial investment we've made in the Yucca Mountain site and in the policy that has been supported by every prior Administration since 1982, the nation deserves a final and definitive answer on the Yucca Mountain site from the NRC licensing process – an answer that the American public was robbed of under the Obama Administration.

View Comments(5 comments)
RubyNevada as been used by the government since silver and gold was discovered. That's why they own 80 percent of the state. Nevada has done it's share for nuclear discovery. Scientist claimed low level radiation would do no harm and made nuclear testing a tourist attraction. Had live test dummies in the ditches while testing. Then went oh-ooh-oh when these men and women developed cancer. Now they want to make Nevada a permanent waste site. Doesn't matter there are earthquakes . Why should Nevada be the dumping ground for 36 states?  They don't want the beauty of their land marred by nuclear pools or dripping into their water table, so take it to the ugly desert. If Godzilla doesn't exist, the government will create it by contaminating our landscape and water. Desert animals and insects will be gone or changed, and with them humans. In this case Harry Reid was right. We should not have this butden. 
AnonymousIt is unbelievable that the seriously excellent science and technical works on a project required by law was "trumped" by political agenda.  Example of such political trumping was the flip-flopping of Steven Chu, a once-respected Nobel laureate and a National Lab Director, who changed his assessment of the Yucca Mountain Project (YMP) as a technically and scientifically sound and "safe" project to an "unworkable" solution once he was sweared-in as DOE secretary.  Another apparent example was the crowning of the NRC chairpersons with Harry Reid's croonies (Jaczko and McFarlane) to stop the review of the YMP License Application (LA) even when the NRC technical staff mostly agreed that the LA is technically sound and would meet the requirements. Other obstructions of the YMP LA review were put up by the continued assaults by the Obama administration and Harry Reid, but thwarted by the court that forced the review to continue as required by law.  Hopefully, now, with the change in the administration, the project can now be resurrected to complete its mission as required by law.
Bob PetersWhat is REALLY unbelievable to most Nevadans is the fact that Anonymous can write an opinon without knowing the history of the selection of Yucca Mountain.  Please do forget to add how the "Screw Nevada Bill" became law.   I know it is so easy to lay all the blame on Reid and Obama but with just a small amount of research you can find that there were several locations in the Country that actually were better sites but since Nevada had no political clout at the time it was just shoved down our throats.Screw you Yucca Mountain will never be built!!!!!