Democrats’ Decision to Televise Trump Impeachment Hearings Could Prove Politically Perilous

Joshua Roberts/Reuters

Democrats in the U.S. Congress took a major step toward impeaching President Donald Trump this week when they agreed on the rules for publicly televised hearings after weeks of testimony behind closed doors. But it is also a step onto more politically perilous terrain for a party seeking to persuade Americans that their cause to remove Republican Trump, who they accuse of abusing his power, is just.

Leaders of the Democratic-run U.S. House of Representatives believe that putting the main witnesses on TV will convince independent voters and other doubters that Trump was wrong in asking the Ukrainian government to dig up dirt on a political rival, Democrat Joe Biden, who hopes to be the candidate to oust Trump in the 2020 election.

While Republicans and the president face great political risk in the hearings, so do Democrats. They must present themselves as sober and trustworthy investigators, former congressional aides and analysts said.

“The allegations – and what the president has admitted to – are serious enough. They don’t need embellishment. They just need explanation,” said Mieke Eoyang, a former aide to the House Intelligence Committee who works for the Democratic think tank Third Way.

Lawmakers will have to avoid the urge to grandstand before a TV audience of millions, Eoyang said. “The hardest thing for members in an open hearing is to remember they are not the star of the thing.”

Republicans have painted the Democratic-led inquiry as a purely partisan exercise and will seek to present a different picture of Trump to the masses of viewers.

Trump has denied wrongdoing, and the expectation is that Trump would not be convicted at any trial in the Senate because it is controlled by his fellow Republicans, even if a House majority voted to impeach, similar to being indicted.

The hearings likely will be a ratings bonanza for television networks as Democratic President Bill Clinton’s impeachment case was in the 1990s.


The public phase of the hearings is expected to begin when the House resumes session later in November. News executives are preparing wall-to-wall coverage on cable news and digital news networks, networks told Reuters.

Representative Adam Schiff, chairman of the House Intelligence Committee and the Democratic point man for the probe, told PBS this week that the move to public hearings will allow “the American people to hear firsthand from those that were eyewitnesses to this kind of abuse of power.”

The inquiry focuses on a July 25 telephone call in which Trump asked Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy to investigate Biden, a former U.S. vice president, and his son Hunter, who had served as a director for Ukrainian energy company Burisma. The Bidens deny wrongdoing.

One pivotal segment of voters are political independents, who according to Reuters/Ipsos polling, have remained more reserved about the impeachment inquiry even as Democrats and Republicans have largely made up their minds.

An October poll found that less than half of independents surveyed believe Trump should be impeached. And while 61% of independents disapprove of the president and 59% support the congressional inquiry, the poll suggested that they may be turned off if the hearings devolve into a hyper-partisan spectacle that diverts lawmakers’ attention from other business.

When asked about how Congress should prioritize the impeachment hearings, 54% of independents agreed that lawmakers “should focus on fixing important problems facing Americans, rather than focusing on investigating President Trump,” while 34% disagreed.

With Trump up for re-election next year, that is the prime danger Democrats face, said Columbia University political scientist Donald Green.

“Nobody really expects Trump to be convicted,” Green said. “The question is whether Democrats have the grounds to say that, ‘We didn’t get a conviction, but there deserves to be one.’”


Rodell Mollineau, a Democratic strategist who was a longtime aide to former Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, said it will be difficult for House leaders to prevent the hearings from becoming a “circus.”

“There are certain things out of their control,” he said.

Up until now, Democrats have largely controlled the narrative emerging from closed hearings, publicizing the testimony of former and current administration officials who have said that Trump did indeed seek to pressure Ukraine to investigate Biden.

But in the public hearings, Republicans will have a very public platform, arguing that what Trump did does not justify his removal from office.

“I think they (Republicans) will show up to play,” said Representative Tom Cole, a member of the House Republican leadership. “Most of our members have read the transcript (of the Trump-Zelenskiy call). They do not believe this is an impeachable offense.”

Democratic members will also seek their time in the spotlight as the media looks for “bombshell” moments, analysts said.

Ahead of the hearings, organizations including AT&T’s CNN and Comcast’s NBC News and cable news channels have already launched new features such as podcasts to cover the historic event.

Tim Miller, a Republican and former communications director for Jeb Bush’s 2016 presidential campaign, said Democrats should conduct the hearings quickly to combat what he termed “impeachment fatigue” that may be setting in among voters who feel “frustrated” or “that the whole thing is a charade.”

That may be of particular importance to the first-term Democrats who last year helped the party take control of the House for the first time in almost a decade. Those Democrats focused more on issues such as healthcare and less on Trump’s conduct since he took office in January 2017.

(Reporting by James Oliphant, Chris Kahn and Ken Li; Additional reporting by Susan Cornwell, Richard Cowan, David Morgan and Patricia Zengerle; Editing by Ross Colvin and Grant McCool)

What do you think?

21 pledges
Upvote Downvote


newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Phyllis Softa

Charles, the founding fathers put the impeachment amendment in the Constitution to prevent coups. They put the emoluments clauses in to prevent foreign interference in the American government. I must ask..Did you miss civics class in school or do you have selective memory of what was taught?

General Confusion

“You Liberal/Democrat pukes don’t want justice, you want a coup. You want to reverse the results of an election through lies and deceit. You and your cohorts have been calling for impeachment since before he took office. Lying, cheating, corrupt Democrats.” Charles You are an obvious FOX channel viewer because that is the source of this “coup” nonsense. Nobody wants a coup. In fact, even if it was true that the DNC leadership were trying to do one, a coup in a democracy wouldn’t be worth all of the hassles that would cause. It would be counterproductive and not worth… Read more »

Qaz Wiz

only power he wielded was his power to prevent a cheating political from stealing the presidency after stuffing the polity vote. every recount found thousands of new votes as they kept “finding” more votes


From MSN: “The House Intelligence Committee will hold public hearings and Republicans will need approval from at least some Democrats to call witnesses or to otherwise issue subpoenas.” So, the Democrats have stacked the Kangaroo Court against President Trump. Democrats get to call anyone and everyone they want, but Republicans have to get permission to call witnesses or subpoenas information helpful to the President. That’s the way the British ran courts in the 1770s. That’s one of the reasons for the Revolution and the Bill of Rights in the Constitution. Democrats are just like the British, wanting to subjugate the… Read more »

General Confusion

“it’s called acceptance.” Morte206

So we have one hand up for quietly sitting in a corner. O.K., thanks.

“What will you do if he’s not: Cry and scream hysterically a la 2016?”

Who cares about 2016? It seems only King Donald The Loser and his Cult-45 do. I, on the other hand, will continue to fight for ALL us as a nation, whether y’all like it or not, not just for certain ones of us, and fight for justice.

#outnow “”

Tom Bodine

The Coup de Grace of the Demo-rat party on live TV for all to see=PRICELESS


This all collapses when Comey and the rest of his coup commrads start going before grand juries. All I want for Christmas is the traitors in prisons!


William, For decades the Dims have NOT had American interests at heart, the working class, or reining in corporate power. Now their agenda is victimhood, who will pay for more “free” shit they promise, and that America sucks. It’s about power to push their agenda. They are frustrated fantasists and the mentally-ill who cannot deal with their 2016 loss. One might ask about the rationality of a party driven more by “feelings” than actual thoughts. So the country is a far second to their bitter quest for power and our money. They will literally do anything. Were there a pagan… Read more »





Trump Says Homeland Security Official Chad Wolf Will Be New Acting DHS Secretary

Democratic White House Candidates Make Their Pitch at Iowa Dinner