Democrat Harris Puts Her Hand Down on Banning Private Health Insurance

Scott Morgan/File Photo/Reuters

Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris on Friday again had to clarify her position on private health insurance after a standout debate performance that her campaign said drew a surge of financial contributions.

Harris and her U.S. Senate colleague Bernie Sanders were the only two candidates to raise their hands during Thursday night’s second Democratic debate when asked, “Who here would abolish their private health insurance in favor of a government-run plan?”

However, Harris told reporters afterwards she interpreted the question as referring to a personal choice and said she did not support eliminating private insurance completely.

“The question was would you give up YOUR private insurance for that option and I said yes,” the senator from California said in an interview with MSNBC on Friday.

“I am proponent of Medicare for All. Private insurance will exist for supplemental coverage,” she added.

Harris dominated her nine Democratic rivals on Thursday night’s debate stage, confronting front-runner Joe Biden on race and calling his remarks about working with segregationist senators hurtful.

Campaign spokeswoman Lily Adams said the debate marked the third-largest fundraising day of Harris’ campaign. “So we’re feeling very good, especially about the response that we’re seeing from the early states,” she told CNN.

Democrats see healthcare as central to their efforts to win back the White House and build on gains in congressional races in 2020 after Republican President Donald Trump chipped away at his Democratic predecessor Barack Obama‘s signature Affordable Care Act.

It was not the first time Harris has had to clarify her position on private health insurance. At a town hall in January, she said she would be willing to eliminate private health insurance.

Harris later told CNN she was referring to the wasteful bureaucracy of Medicare, not the insurance industry and her campaign said she would be open to more moderate approaches.

Like the 10 candidates in the first Democratic debate on Wednesday night, the contenders on Thursday disagreed over the best way to boost access to healthcare insurance coverage. On Wednesday night, U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren and New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio were the only two candidates to raise their hand when asked if they would scrap private insurance.

Harris has backed Sanders’ Medicare-For-All bill that would largely eliminate private insurance and shift all Americans into a government-run healthcare plan that Republicans have criticized as too costly.

The bill has 14 Democratic co-sponsors in the Senate, including four of his presidential rivals – Harris, Warren, Kirsten Gillibrand and Cory Booker. The other White House contender in the Senate, Amy Klobuchar, supports universal healthcare and expanding Medicare but has not committed to plans that would eliminate private insurance.

Trump and his supporters have labeled the Democrats who support Medicare for All as radical socialists who would take away Americans’ health care choices.

Traveling in Asia for a G20 summit, Trump knocked the Democratic presidential hopefuls on Thursday for pledging to cover healthcare for immigrants who live in the United States after coming to the country illegally.

“All Democrats just raised their hands for giving millions of illegal aliens unlimited healthcare. How about taking care of American Citizens first!? That’s the end of that race!” he said on Twitter.

(Reporting by Doina Chiacu; Editing by Susan Thomas)

What do you think?


newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Phyllis Softa

Kamala’s post debate response would have been more credible if she had not been asked a few months ago by the moderator at her CNN townhall event if she would eliminate commercial insurance companies. Her answer was a flat out YES. She later walked that back but being the second time the question was asked, would she not have listened more carefully when the same question was posed by a moderator???


I find harris’ perpetual smug expression to be offensive.
She’s just another lying bimbo who ***ed her way up the political ladder.


How is she going to help the country when she can’t even help her own state. La has 50000 homeless, sf has people cleaning up shit from the streets. The state is running in the red. So now you want to this to the whole country
No thanks


The Dumbocrats appear to be complete idiots in all regards. I realize their venue was limited, but there are twenty-plus of those lefty morons in play and not one of them delivered a cogent policy at any point in time.
Talking points, dodged or not, proves that none of them realize that Americans are tired of the hoopla and want solutions to the problems facing our nation.
That is obviously beyond the grasp of the Dumbos.
Oh….But there’s always Climate Change.


“Harris dominated her nine Democratic rivals”. Fortunately for her that wasn’t difficult.
Having worked for over 30 years as an independent contractor paying ALL my social security and health insurance I looked forward to Medicare and getting at least some of the SS back. How dare these chuckleheads hand it out as an entitlement for those here illegally. As a woman I am not opposed to a woman as President just not ANY of these women….or men for that matter. Talk about a group of misfits all jockeying for a position they are incapable of handling.

Roy Scott Swagger
Roy Scott Swagger

I’m sure she’s been in many positions.

Tom Bodine

Horizontal Harris changes direction like the wind and blows hard, too bad Willie Brown isn’t around to verify that fact.


That is one VILE and FOUL woman………….period.





Harris Takes Heat for Backtracking on Nixing Private Insurance Again After Idea Isn’t Popular During Debate

Cruz Knocks ‘Scary’ 2020 Dem Debate as a ‘Clown Car’ That’s ‘Broken’ and ‘Only Steers to the Left’