Planned Parenthood Opts out of U.S. Subsidies in Fight Over Abortion Referrals

Planned Parenthood said on Monday it was withdrawing from a federal program subsidizing reproductive healthcare for low-income women after the Trump administration banned participants in the program from referring women to abortion providers.

Planned Parenthood, the largest abortion provider in the United States, said its move was spurred by a federal appeals court decision last month clearing the administration’s way to restrict Title X grants under a new policy critics have branded a “gag rule.”

In addition to barring recipients from making abortion referrals, the policy requires financial and physical separation between facilities funded by Title X and those where actual abortions are performed.

The rule, imposed by the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), is part of a broad effort by the Republican president, his allies in Congress and numerous Republican-dominated state legislatures to curtail abortion access in recent years.

Planned Parenthood, accounting for about one-fifth of all Title X funds granted, had vowed to cease accepting money from the program months ago, when HHS said it would start enforcing the new restrictions. The group said it would rely instead on private donations and emergency funds to make up the difference as best it could.

Monday’s move marked a formal Title X withdrawal, to remain permanent unless Congress acts to overturn the restriction or legal challenges prevail in court.

“Due to an unethical and dangerous gag rule, the Trump administration has forced Planned Parenthood grantees out of Title 10,” Alexis McGill, acting president and CEO of Planned Parenthood, told journalists on a conference call.

STATES FOLLOWING SUIT

Planned Parenthood is not alone. Legislatures in Maryland and Massachusetts preemptively adopted measures to opt out of Title X and provide state funding in its place if the new rule took effect. And governors of five other states – Hawaii, Illinois, New York, Oregon and Washington – have said they would do the same. So has Maine Family Planning, a nonprofit, sole recipient of Title X funds in that state.

Congress appropriated $286 million in Title X grants in 2017 to Planned Parenthood and other health centers to provide birth control, disease screening and other reproductive health and counseling services to poor women.

That funding already was prohibited from being used to pay for abortions, but abortion opponents have long complained that the money in effect subsidized Planned Parenthood as a whole, including its abortion services.

The organization had been providing healthcare to about 40% of the 4 million people who rely on Title X funding annually, with 600 of its clinics receiving money from the program.

Critics said Planned Parenthood’s action showed it was primarily focused on abortion.

“In withdrawing from Title X, Planned Parenthood has made it crystal clear that abortion is its number one priority,” said Ashley McGuire, a senior fellow with the Catholic Association.

Abortion has remained one of the most contentious issues in U.S. politics since the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark 1973 Roe v. Wade decision affirming a woman’s constitutional right to terminate her pregnancy.

Opponents cite religious beliefs in decrying abortion as immoral, while the other side casts abortion restrictions as infringing on women’s private medical choices and control over their own bodies.

Federal judges in Washington state, California and Oregon, among nearly two dozen states challenging the administration’s rule in court, issued preliminary injunctions against its enforcement earlier this year.

But the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on June 20 lifted those injunctions, and the same court rejected emergency bids to overturn that decision in July. That allowed the restrictions to take effect while court cases proceed.

The rule largely restored a restriction created in 1988 and upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1991, only to be suspended by the Clinton administration in 1993.

(Reporting by Brendan O’Brien in Chicago; Additional reporting by Steve Gorman in Los Angeles; Editing by Matthew Lewis)

Responses

  1. Before anyone donates to United Way, check to see if their local U.W. chapter provides money to Planned Parenthood. If they do, take your money elsewhere.

  2. “..pro-life advocates note that PP will still receive a big chunk of federal funding via Medicaid. Last year, it received half a billion dollars. Researchers say those Medicaid dollars encourage low-income women to get abortions. Dr Michael New of Catholic University said, “‘Essentially when the price of abortion goes down the incidence increases, and if low-income women can get abortion subsidized through Medicaid programs they’re more likely to get abortions.”” CBN news reports.
    “Pro-lifers also believe the loss of the $60 million in Title X funding… can now go to medical providers that actually do provide women’s healthcare.” also from CBN.

  3. I don’t believe them but it’s a good thing if US tax dollars are not being used murder innocent children in the womb of their mothers. If you are really interested on Women’s health issue stop referring abortion as a sick form of government paid for birth control?

  4. So if murdering that’s exactly what it is let’s not mince words your baby is just women’s health and their body their right by that same regard shouldn’t the baby get to be born and wait until it can speak. So we can ask it are you okay with your mother deciding she would rather murder you than take responsibility for the life she created. By that same reasoning shouldn’t they check the gender of it’s a female aren’t they crapping all over their entire argument of a woman’s right to her body? Or does that body only matter when it’s a grown irresponsible excuse for a woman who likely leans as far left as you can and obviously is a Democrat. They are the party of slavery and segregation so I guess baby murder fits right in with the rest of their ideology.

  5. Planned Parenthood lies!! The title X money is absolutely used to fund abortions. They just shift the money around within the corp. They claim that abortions accounts for only 3% of their procedures, but there is a vast difference between $20 for a pregnancy test/productive health test and $1500 for an abortion. It’s against the law for these type funds to be used for abortion, but how can you track the money once it’s in the account. $268 million from these funds alone, much more through Medicaid. The last time I looked at their finances, the total government money was $550 million. How can they say they don’t use federal funds for abortion? PP and their referral clinic are an abortion machine, killing over 321,384 in 2017. Meanwhile, their CEO gets $550,000 a year for killing babies. They claim to have a huge nationwide lobby and movement. Perhaps Warren and other democrats, that complain about the NRA, should look into the real sponsor of death – Planned Parenthood.

  6. PP should never be given public monies. They not only subsidize their abortions with it, but also spend it on donations to politicraps who support them, mostly DIMMrats.

    1. On what evidence are you basing your assertion on subsidizing abortions?

      1. Without federal monies, PP couldn’t afford to operate and perform over 320,000 abortions a year. Their CEO would have to take a massive pay cut down from $550,000 a year. They get a total of over $550 million a year from the federal gov. Where is Warren, who complains about the NRA and other pro gun advocates. Gun deaths pale in comparison to the over 320,000 abortions performed by PP a year, over 630,000 total abortions in US. There’s something Democrats should complain about.

  7. Has anyone yet determined HOW and WHY “murder” by Planned Butcherhood is considered to be a woman’s “healthcare” issue? [Getting sick and tired of getting pregnant every 9 months is not an excuse or a reason.]

    1. James, I realize your wife is deceased, but do you not recall her going for annual gyne exam even after she was beyond her childbearing years? All women should have a yearly pelvic exam for testing for cervical cancer. It is called a PAP smear. Her ovaries are palpated to rule out ovarian cyst and tumors–if the exam findings and/or patient’s complaints warrant, an ultrasound of the ovaries is ordered to rule out ovarian cancer. A breast exam is performed to rule out breast cancer. A mammogram is ordered on a timeline that is appropriate for the woman’s personal & family history of cancer. Just like men, women have a multitude of female medical issue that need to be addressed by a gynecologist. —fertility, menstrual cramps, missed periods, menopause, etc……

      1. Join the discussion…Planned Parenthood? is not in the business of pelvic examinations syphilis. It is in the business of killing children. Now it is being floated out there to allow murder after the child is born. A woman’s right is only to say no or use a contraceptive not kill a living being. Try being honest for a change.

Comments are closed.