Schumer Claims Red Flag Laws Are a GOP ‘Cop Out’: Here Are 5 Gun Control Proposals Dems Would Rather See

Alex Wong/Getty Images

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) is tired of “cop-out” Republican gun control measures and wants to see much more significant changes to gun laws in the United States.

Following the two mass shootings in Dayton, Ohio and El Paso, Texas, Schumer took to Twitter to condemn Republicans for being closed off to many gun control measures. As IJR reported earlier, Senator Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) and President Donald Trump both announced their support for state-level Red Flag laws, but Schumer sees this as nothing but an “ineffective cop-out.”

With Schumer calling the one Republican-approved anti-gun violence plan a cop-out, it’s clear that Democrats have much bigger gun control plans in mind.

Here are five anti-gun violence policies leading Democrats are floating.

Federally Required Red Flag Laws

As IJR recently explained, Red Flag laws — sometimes called Extream Risk Protection Orders ERPOs — allow law enforcement to remove weapons from someone if they are flagged by a family member to be a threat to themselves or others. The family must petition the court to grant authorities the right to confiscate the guns temporarily. Despite concerns that Red Flag laws violate due process by not allowing the gun owner to defend themselves in court prior to their guns being taken, Republicans seem supportive of the measure.

Because 17 states have already implemented such laws, Graham proposed a bill that would incentivize other states to do the same.

Schumer, however, says it’s not enough to let the states decide. He wants Red Flag laws nationwide.

“The proposal Republicans are pursuing would not mandate states to institute ERPO laws,” wrote Schumer. “Instead, it would just provide grant incentives for states to implement laws of their own, with runs the risk of during more harm than good in the long run if states decide to take up weaker laws.”

Schumer demanded that ERPO laws be married to stronger background checks.

Universal Background Checks

While the majority of gun purchases require a background check, Schumer argued that there are still many loopholes that allow people to legally transfer a gun without a background check.

He argued that “gun show and online sale loopholes exist” and allow criminals to access weapons “far too easily.” Although the “gun show loophole” is a common talking point, it doesn’t legally exist. Instead, federally licensed firearms dealers may not correctly enforce the laws, allowing people to purchase the weapon without a check — an enforcement issue Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.) has vowed to take on if she becomes president.

There are also weapons exchanges between two not licensed firearms dealers, such as a sale between neighbors, that do not currently require a background check.

Universal background checks would require any exchange of a weapon to be checked.

Assault Weapons Ban

As IJR Blue reported, former President Bill Clinton signed into law an assault weapons ban that expired in 2004. He recently made a call for that ban to be reinstated.

Clinton’s bill prevented the manufacturing of new semi-automatic firearms and large-capacity ammunition magazines, though it did not ban existing weapons.

In the wake of recent shootings, many have made calls for this legislation to be reimplemented.

Gun Confiscations and Mandatory Buybacks

Some of the more extreme calls have come from Democrats like Rep. Eric Swalwell (D-Calif.) who called for outlawing “weapons of war” and forcing those gun owners into a mandatory gun buyback program.

2020 candidate Beto O’Rourke (D-Texas) said he would be “open” to a mandatory buyback program, similar to the one implemented in New Zealand earlier this year.

It remains unclear how proponents of mandatory gun buybacks would fair before the courts, as previous rulings make it likely such a step would be found in violation of the Second Amendment.

Gun Licenses

One issue that has built up steam on the campaign trail is the issue of gun licenses. Senator Cory Booker (D-N.J.) has proposed a measure that would force gun owners to have a license to own a firearm.

Booker’s plan would require gun owners “submit fingerprints, provide basic background information, and demonstrate completion of a certified gun safety course” before getting a license. The FBI would check that information before the license is granted.

For now, it remains unclear what the next steps will be following the shootings. The most likely legislation would be the Red Flag law incentives backed by Trump and other Republicans, but there is no guarantee that Schumer and his fellow Democrats will settle for that policy.

What do you think?

-8 pledges
Upvote Downvote


newest oldest most voted
Notify of

Sadly, evil knows no bounds. Murder is illegal.


First off, you can’t get anything done when you are in session because your all to damn busy fighting this President instead of doing your jobs. You sit in far to many meetings,hearings, press conferences doing nothing more than bashing this President and trying to find ways to impeach him. You haven’t done any real work since he was elected, so lets be wont get anything done until you have a democratic President. And.probably not even then, as you’ll be to busy slamming what Trump did and telling us all you are going to change it all back,, and… Read more »

Robert Stephens
Robert Stephens

Hey Chucky, let me remind you. This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding. Want me to get some crayons and draw pictures and explain it to you? Bottom line. You will not get the guns. You will be labeled as an enemy to… Read more »

Phyllis Softa

Hey, Chuck, get a grip. The Senate could NOT pass Manchin/Toomey after TWENTY 1st graders were gunned down in cold blood. 22 adult Hispanics, including 8 Mexican nationals that crossed the border to shop, being gunned down in a white supremacist fit of fear and anger is not going to move Republicans to act. Two separate members of Congress have been seriously wounded by gunfire. NO action. Talk is cheap. Trump claimed the same support for action after 14 Parkland students & 3 staff were killed. Congressional action on gun violence is a fantasy. You sound like Bernie.





‘We Will Not Tolerate It’: Senate Republicans to Curb Ad Spending on Twitter After McConnell Locked Out

U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi listens to U.S. Ambassador to Guatemala Luis Arreaga upon her arrival at the Guatemalan Air Force base in Guatemala City, Guatemala August 8, 2019. REUTERS/Stringer

House Speaker Pelosi in Central America as Trump Seeks Asylum Deals