Sharpie-Gate Continued: Trump Doubles Down on Dorian’s Aim for Alabama

Jonathan Ernst/Reuters

President Donald Trump, not someone who easily lets things go, doubled down on Thursday on his insistence that Alabama could have been hit by Hurricane Dorian and enlisted his top homeland security adviser to back him up.

On Wednesday, the president displayed a map of the storm’s projected path that appeared to have been altered with a Sharpie pen to include the state of Alabama, following his remarks on Sunday in which he said it could be affected by the storm.

In fact, the National Hurricane Center’s advisory on Sunday morning did not include the state, and the National Weather Service denied that Alabama would be affected after Trump suggested initial projections showed the storm heading toward the Gulf of Mexico, where Alabama has a coastline.

“Alabama will NOT see any impacts from #Dorian. We repeat, no impacts from Hurricane #Dorian will be felt across Alabama. The system will remain too far east,” the National Weather Service in Alabama tweeted.

News reports about the discrepancies and about the apparently Sharpie-edited map exploded on social media – the term #SharpiePresident was trending on Twitter – prompting Trump to fire back.

“Just as I said, Alabama was originally projected to be hit. The Fake News denies it!” Trump, using his preferred pejorative for the media, tweeted along with a collection of maps on Thursday afternoon. “I was with you all the way Alabama. The Fake News Media was not!”

Alabama is a largely conservative state that supported the Republican Trump in the 2016 election.

Later in the day, after Trump declined to answer a question from a reporter in the Oval Office about his focus on the issue, the White House released a statement from Rear Admiral Peter Brown, the president’s homeland security and counterterrorism adviser, who said he had briefed Trump about the potential path of the storm using the NHC forecast and other models.


Brown said Trump’s comments to the press on Sunday, when he discussed Alabama during a visit to the Federal Emergency Management Agency headquarters, were based on that morning’s Hurricane Dorian briefing, which included “the possibility of tropical storm force winds in southeastern Alabama.”

“In fact, from the evening of Tuesday, August 27, until the morning of Monday, September 2, forecasts from the National Hurricane Center showed the possibility of tropical storm force winds hitting parts of Alabama,” Brown wrote.

Brown noted that the forecast track “changed substantially over time” and areas that were originally seen as targets such as Puerto Rico, South Florida and the Gulf Coast experienced “minimal to no impact from Hurricane Dorian.”

Early NHS models of the hurricane last week showed roughly a dozen or so trajectories, including one that took it into the Gulf. But by Sunday, when the president discussed Alabama, the trajectories clearly showed the storm going to the Atlantic and not the Gulf of Mexico.

Representative Eddie Bernice Johnson, a Democrat from Texas who chairs the House of Representatives Committee on Science, Space and Technology, expressed concern about Trump’s actions in a letter to him on Thursday.

“In times of emergency, the American public need to have confidence in the information being provided by the White House, and misrepresentation of National Weather Service (NWS) forecasts is especially disturbing when it concerns an ongoing natural disaster that has already killed twenty people,” she wrote.

(Reporting by Jeff Mason; Additional reporting by Eric Beech in Washington and Bill Tarrant in Los Angeles; Editing by Peter Cooney)

What do you think?


newest oldest most voted
Notify of

There is vid of the original presser on YouTube. Reuters should act like real journalists and go view it. Trump says “We thought we’d give you an update on the hurricane. We got lucky in FL, very, very lucky indeed. We had actually, our ORIGINAL chart, was that it was going to be hitting FL directly, maybe I can just see that Kevin (pulls out chart with #SharpieGate marking that reflects the original prediction), it was going to be hitting directly and would have effected a lot of other states, but that was the ORIGINAL chart. You see, it was… Read more »


Bob, I’ve crapped better turds than “Generally Confused Over His Privates “.

The Confused General doesn’t know not to piss into the wind let alone know WHERE it will blow next. Although I’m pretty sure he knows WHO he’ll blow next.

General Confusion

“Is this the best you can do for news?” Bob As I’ve said before, you are confused. I want to know if our president is OBSESSED over his inauguration attendance number. I want to know if this administration is running around in circles try to keep up with the lunacy of our King (promising the middle class a 10% tax break created out of whole cloth, just to get reelected). I want to know if King Donald The Loser is breaking national weather reporting laws AND is OBSESSED with making his false forecast LOOK accurate and true. This guy is… Read more »

General Confusion

“This story filled more space than Starbucks Schultz dropping out.” Cherl

You seem confused about the Director, King Donald The Loser.

It was HE and his Sharpie who kept his mapmaking skills in the headlines.

General Confusion

“It’s a hurricane. It could have moved anywhere.” Don Snyder

You are confused by forecasts.

Dorian could not have gone to where King Donald The Loser suggested it would because there was a high pressure area to the west of it that blocked the hurricane from going in that direction.

In fact, there was a second high pressure area to the east of the hurricane, too. Combined, the two high pressure areas controlled how the hurricane moved. The King seems to be unaware of this.

Don Snyder

It’s a hurricane. It could have moved anywhere. Better to warn the people then have them crushed by this thing because you weren’t prepared. If Obama had said this, the people would have cheered. Mainstream media needs to get on board, you’re missing a great Presidency.


The first trajectory showed Alabama as a possible hit and the liberal FAKE news misleads and hammers a false message as usual. CNN the Constant Negative Nonsense joke of a source along with MSNBC and the Washington Post LA Times along with the rest of the HATE America liberal media have lost any legitimate credibility.


And on and on it goes. Yes Trump should let it go. But so should Johnson from Texas and Reuters. This story filled more space than Starbucks Schultz dropping out. Alabama dodged the storm no matter what the map showed. Be grateful.





U.S. Interior Department Illegally Used Fees to Keep National Parks Open During Shutdown: GAO

Lawyers for Ex-Trump Aide Manafort Seek Dismissal of New York Case