Trump Proposes Wall-for-DACA in Bid to End Shutdown

Last updated 1/19/2019 at 5:56 p.m. ET.

U.S. President Donald Trump proposed an immigration deal on Saturday in a bid to end a 29-day partial government shutdown, including temporary protections for “Dreamers” and other immigrants, but Democrats immediately dismissed it.

Giving no ground on his demand for $5.7 billion to fund a U.S.-Mexico border barrier as part of any bill to fully reopen the government, Trump’s package sought to pile pressure on Democrats by appealing to immigrants they have tried to help.

In a speech from the White House, Trump offered three years of protections for the young undocumented immigrants known as “Dreamers,” as well as for holders of temporary protected status (TPS), another class of immigrants to the United States.

Decrying what he called a “badly broken” U.S. immigration system, Trump said, “I am here today to break the logjam and provide Congress with a path forward to end the government shutdown and solve the crisis along the southern border.”

But the protections he proposed fell far short of the path to citizenship for Dreamers that Democrats and some Republicans in Congress have been urging for years.

In a statement after Trump’s speech, Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell called the president’s plan a “bold solution to reopen the government, secure the border, and take bipartisan steps toward addressing current immigration issues.”

A spokesman for McConnell said he would seek Senate passage of the president’s proposal next week.

Democrats insisted talks on border security occur only after the government is reopened. Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer said, “It was the president who singled-handedly took away DACA and TPS protections in the first place. Offering some protections back in exchange for the wall is not a compromise but more hostage taking.”

Even before Trump spoke, House of Representatives Speaker Nancy Pelosi said his offer as reported in advance was “unacceptable,” did not “represent a good-faith effort to restore certainty to people’s lives,” and was unlikely to gain the votes needed to pass the House or the Senate.

About a quarter of the U.S. government has been partially shut down since Dec. 22 due to a lack of funding that expired for reasons mostly unrelated to the border or immigration.


Some 800,000 federal workers have been staying home on furlough or working without pay.

The president has refused to consider legislation needed to fully reopen the government unless it includes $5.7 billion that he wants to help pay for a border wall or other barrier, which he says is needed to keep out illegal immigrants and drugs.

The full cost of such a barrier could eventually top $24 billion, according to some government estimates.

Trump also asked Congress for $782 million to hire an additional 2,750 border agents, law enforcement officers and staff, and another $563 million to hire 75 new immigration judge teams to reduce a backlog in immigration courts.

The Dreamers, mostly young Latinos, are protected from deportation under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, which protects certain people who illegally entered the United States as children. It provides about 700,000 immigrants with work permits, but no path to citizenship.

Former Democratic President Barack Obama put DACA in place in 2012 through an executive order. Most Democrats since then have sought more lasting and stronger protection for the Dreamers. The Trump administration said in September 2017 it would rescind DACA, but it remains in effect under court order.

Temporary Protected Status (TPS) is given to nationals from designated countries affected by armed conflict, natural disaster, or other strife. TPS holders are permitted to work and live in the United States for limited times.

The Trump administration has shown a deep skepticism toward the TPS program and has moved to revoke the special status for immigrants from El Salvador, Haiti, Honduras and other nations.

Polls showed Americans increasingly blame Trump for the shutdown, the 19th to occur since the mid-1970s. Most past shutdowns have been brief. The current one has had no impact on three-quarters of the government, including the Department of Defense, which has secure funding.

(Additional reporting by Richard Cowan and Pete Schrodeder; Editing by Leslie Adler, David Gregorio and Daniel Wallis)

Published in News


  1. At first i was excited because i thought this would be a perfect compromise that actually got put back on the table.

    Hopefully this is a stepping stone to a better offer for DACA. Three years protection just means they will be back where they started in three years. It wouldn’t be a solution for them.

  2. “She’s under total control of the radical left. I think that’s a very bad thing for her. I think it’s a very bad thing for the Democrats.”

    The Democrats can’t give up because they know that Trump would be much more likely to do something similar again, just to get his way, at any time in the future. That is not being “under total control of the radical left”.

    Trump can’t give up because his base and Anne Coulter will yell at him.

    What is a President to do?

    1. The solution is right in front of him. Declare a national emergency, have it struck down in the courts and tell his cult that the US courts are the enemy. “Build the wall & US taxpayers will pay for it” can be his 2020 campaign slogan. OR declare a national emergency followed by a declaration that the wall is built! Hey, they believed Mexico was going to pay, a wall would stop smuggling of drugs & migrants thru legal ports of entry. & prevent visa overstays.They will buy anything.

    2. The President ran on securing the border, and it is now worse than it was when he ran on it. He’s doing what he promised, and what needs to be done. He realizes that if he gives on this, then it will never get done. Pelosi only sees this as a political issue. If she allows the President to “win”, then she and the party pay a political price–they may lose votes from their base.

      1. You want political? Trump made sure that “the wall” was a political issue based on the reaction of his cult at his earliest rallies. That’s how it got the prominence in his platform, otherwise, he couldn’t careless about the wall. He heard the crowd’s reaction and knew that he found a gold mine.

Comments are closed.