U.S. Panel Eyes Sanctions for Indian Minister Over Citizenship Curb for Muslims

REUTERS/Jayanta Dey

 A federal panel on religion has urged the United States to weigh sanctions against India’s Home Minister Amit Shah if the south Asian nation adopts legislation to exclude Muslims from a path to citizenship for religious minorities from its neighbors.

Shah is a close associate of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, whose Hindu nationalist-led government is seen by critics as pushing an agenda that undermines the secular foundations of India’s democracy.

On Tuesday, parliament’s lower house approved the measure covering citizenship for non-Muslim minorities, specifically Buddhists, Christians, Hindus, Jains, Parsis and Sikhs, who fled Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan before 2015.

The bill has prompted criticism at home and abroad, as it marks the first time India is weighing religion in granting citizenship, although it must first pass the upper house of parliament, where Modi’s party lacks a majority.

The measure goes against India’s constitution, which guarantees legal equality to people of all faiths, the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom said.

“If the CAB passes in both houses of parliament, the United States government should consider sanctions against the Home Minister and other principal leadership,” the panel said in a statement, referring to the Citizenship Amendment Bill (CAB).

The panel is a bipartisan body that makes foreign policy recommendations to the U.S. leadership.

India’s foreign ministry called the panel’s statement inaccurate, saying the bill sought to help persecuted religious minorities already in the country.

“It seeks to address their current difficulties and meet their basic human rights,” said ministry spokesman Raveesh Kumar.

Hindus in Bangladesh, Christians in Pakistan and Sikhs in Afghanistan, all Muslim-majority nations, have faced violence in recent years, but India’s opposition parties, minority groups and academics have said the bill discriminates against Muslims.

During Monday’s parliament debate, opposition politician Asaduddin Owaisi ripped up a copy of the bill, calling it a move by the Modi government to render Muslims “stateless”.

But Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which promised the measure in an election campaign that swept it to power in May, says the law is needed to help persecuted minority individuals in its neighbors.

“If minorities in our neighboring countries are being persecuted, then India cannot stay a silent spectator,” Shah told parliament.

The bill is the third key election promise Modi’s government has delivered since August.

The scrapping of autonomy for the disputed Himalayan region of Kashmir and permission from India’s top court for moves to build a Hindu temple at a disputed religious site have bolstered right-wing supporters, and diverted attention from a slowing economy.

Now the BJP must win support from smaller regional groups to push the bill through the upper house of parliament this week.

(Additional reporting by Zarir Hussain in GUWAHATI; Editing by Sanjeev Miglani and Clarence Fernandez)

What do you think?


newest oldest most voted
Notify of

Until India elects an ambidextrous, polyamorous, paraplegic with native speaker fluency in at least two ancient and three modern languages, every other country in the world (the US included) aught to butt out.

william jackson

USA needs to butt out—-USA needs to get it’s own government under control before trying to screw up another country. India is trying to protect it’s sovereignty—-try it USA—-DA, liberal, open border, globalist, socialist, left wing D-RATs are despicable.

William Conley

All I can think about is how this lady reminds me of jabba the Hutt with her tongue all out like that. Just waiting for a little creature to perch itself on her shoulder.

Nancy Assaf

So, the U.S. gives money to India and then thinks it can influence the Indian govt. Great.

Millie Tyler

This is a lose-lose for the US. In any discussion about islam as a ‘religion’ people now are aware of and must discuss it as a governmental entity in and of itself as well. That’s a convoluted way of saying that islam isn’t just a religion and the folks in India understand that even if our government does not. The US needs to stay out of this one.


So its not just Muslims who are being targeted, although given that we are talking about a religion, Islam, that butts heads with every religion it encounters and given the hostility that has existed between Muslims and Hindus, especially in political terms since Indian independence, is this really a surprise? I think the U.S. should reserve its intermeddling with India to matters more important such as India cleaning up its environmental mess.





Top Hotels Sued for ‘Industry-Wide Failures’ to Prevent U.S. Sex Trafficking

House Democrats Expected to Unveil Formal Charges in Trump Impeachment