Fresh off a historic November loss and plunged into an identity crisis, the Democratic Party now finds itself struggling to cobble together a plan to oppose President Donald Trump’s sweeping agenda.
Trump’s win in both the Electoral College and the popular vote, Democrats have split over the reasons behind their loss with voters. In a recent report, The New York Times revealed that after more than 50 interviews with Democrats, the party is divided on how to mount a successful defense to Trump’s policies, and still doesn’t know what its platform should actually be about.
Democratic National Committee (DNC) members gathered Saturday to finalize their selection of the new DNC chair, choosing Minnesota Democratic-Farmer-Labor (DFL) Party Chairman Ken Martin. In an interview with the NYT after his win, Martin stated that the issue wasn’t the policies themselves but rather a “messaging” and “brand problem.”
“The policies that we support and the message that we have is not wrong,” Martin said. “It is a messaging problem and a brand problem. Those voters are not connecting our policies with their lives.”
Martin, who has served as DFL chairman for several terms, said after his win that he would conduct a post-election review, focusing mainly on tactics and messaging. While he did not define the parameters of the review, the one issue Martin will avoid is questioning whether Biden should have run for re-election, according to the NYT.
Martin’s sentiments mirror those of Democratic Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, who, in a Jan. 5 NBC interview, said that while his party had some issues to address ahead of the upcoming election, voters were unaware of how much the party had done and cared for them.
“But all too often we talked about the mechanics of the legislation and the details of the legislation and we really didn’t show the kind of empathy and concern to average or show enough of it to average working families who didn’t realize how much we had done and how much we care for them,” Schumer said.
While many Democrats are urging that widespread opposition be launched against the entirety of Trump’s agenda, the Senate minority leader has diverged from such an approach, telling the NYT that “we’re not going to go after every single issue.” Half a dozen Democratic governors have already pressured Schumer to be more aggressive in challenging the White House.
While many Democrats are urging that widespread opposition be launched against the entirety of Trump’s agenda, the Senate minority leader has diverged such an approach, telling the NYT that “we’re not going to go after every single issue.” Schumer had already been pressured by half a dozen Democratic governors to be more aggressive in challenging the presidents policies.
Despite the confusion over who or what to blame, Americans have consistently made clear that they’re on the other side of key Democratic policy priorities and were largely unhappy with the Biden administration. Heading into the polls, voters held chief concerns over the administration’s unbridled illegal immigration, economy and rampant inflation.
A March 2024 survey by The Harris Poll for Harvard University’s Center for American Political Studies (CAPS) found 36% of respondents ranked immigration as their top concern, with 33% listing inflation and the cost of living. In the same month, another survey by the Immigration Hub and Global Strategy Group found that even a majority of Democratic voters had become concerned with the Biden administration’s border crisis, with nearly 43% of voters saying immigration was among their top issues.
While Biden attempted to shift blame for the border crisis onto Trump in 2024, Democrats also tried to downplay the economic concerns many Americans had under his administration. Biden told CNN in May 2024 that the data about his economy had been “wrong all along” and claimed that people were “personally in good shape,” despite inflation peaking at 9.1% in June 2022 and impacting both businesses and consumers.
Post-election polls show 50% of voters believe America’s best days are ahead, with 44% saying they think Trump will bring down food and grocery prices and 57% supporting his program to deport all illegal immigrants currently living in the U.S. However, some Democratic Party members are still questioning whether the party should continue focusing on “traditional concerns” like abortion rights, LGBT issues and climate change.
Democratic Texas Rep. Jasmine Crockett told the NYT that the party has “no coherent message,” adding that “everything that underlines” Trump “is white supremacy and hate.”
Social justice and climate change have not been top priorities for voters, with a majority in 2022 stating they didn’t believe systemic racism exists. In an October Center Square Voters’ Voice Poll conducted by Noble Predictive Insights, 59% supported a federal ban on sex-change procedures, including puberty blockers and gender reassignment surgeries for minors — despite most Democrats advocating for transgender individuals to have access to such procedures.
All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact [email protected].
