IJROpen on IJR
Reporting

Spanberger Wants Power Giants To Pay Customers $6.5 Billion Before They Can Merge

Democratic Virginia Gov. Abigail Spanberger wants two utility giants to pay customers the equivalent of their merger's breakup fee if regulators approve the deal.

Simon August · · 6 min read

Democratic Virginia Gov. Abigail Spanberger wants two utility giants to pay customers the equivalent of their merger’s breakup fee if regulators approve the deal.

The State Corporation Commission opens its evidentiary hearing Tuesday on NextEra’s purchase of Dominion Energy, which the companies say would create “the world’s largest regulated electric utility business by market capitalization.” Testimony filed for Spanberger asks the commission to require a $6.52 billion customer rebate, a six-year freeze on residential base rates and a separate zero-carbon power company built for data centers.

“Without enforceable commitments that meaningfully prioritize ratepayers, lower energy costs, protect Virginia’s utility workforce, and advance Virginia’s energy goals, the State Corporation Commission should reject this merger,” Spanbergersaid in an Oct. 19 release.

The rebate matches the $6.52 billion termination fee NextEra Energy would owe Dominion in certain circumstances if the deal falls apart, energy consultant Richard McCann wrote in testimony for the governor’s office. He proposed paying it out as a residential credit of $29 a month for four years, close to triple the $10 monthly credit the companies have promised Virginia residential customers.

McCann’s own table puts Virginia’s share of the rebate at $5.17 billion. Dominion Chair and CEO Robert Blue testified Nov. 2 that the governor’s office wants the Virginia credit “tripled, to over $5 billion.”

“Customers will not pay one cent for this combination,” the two companies said in a Nov. 3 release.

The release said the companies had accepted 101 of 117 conditions sought by commission staff and the attorney general’s Division of Consumer Counsel, plus 13 more with changes.

Spanberger’s office, NextEra and Dominion did not respond to the Daily Caller News Foundation’s requests for comment.

The governor’s rate freeze would block residential base-rate increases during the first three of Dominion’s every-other-year rate reviews after closing, McCann wrote. A witness for the Consumer Counsel also recommended a residential base-rate freeze, according to Dominion’s rebuttal.

Dominion argued that rate questions do not belong in a merger case.

“Each of these proposals tries to fit ratemaking issues into a proceeding that does not set rates,” J. Scott Gaskill, Dominion Energy Virginia’s vice president for regulatory affairs, testified.

Jordan Nader, a resident senior fellow for energy and environment at the free-market R Street Institute, said charges billed outside base rates, such as fuel and energy efficiency, could still change during a freeze.

“Dominion could be incentivized to push costs for new generation into riders rather than base rates which could cause problems down the road especially as Dominion needs to build significant generation to cover their current load growth,” Nader said in a statement to the DCNF.

“After six years, and considering all the inflation that occurs during the interim, base rates would likely increase, perhaps significantly,” he said.

The governor’s filing goes beyond bills. McCann asked for a new subsidiary, headquartered in Virginia, “for building zero-carbon energy generation to serve large data centers that is financially walled off from the rest of customers.”

The structure would “shield current ratepayers from generation cost overruns historically associated with nuclear power,” McCann wrote.

The Dominion zone of the regional grid “is home to the largest concentration of data centers in the world,” Blue testified in July.

“Because Virginia exists in the PJM market, the creation of a separate generation company walled off from residential customers might not insulate customers as much as expected,” Nader said.

Customers would still share some costs on Dominion’s transmission and distribution lines, he said.

McCann also called for raising the debt share of Dominion’s capital structure from 48 percent to 60 percent to lower the company’s rate of return. Gaskill countered that the idea “would have significant negative impacts for customers.”

The governor also wants a “decarbonization incentive rate” for heat pumps and electric vehicles, according to her office’s summary of the filing. The filing asks the commission to recommend that state lawmakers create an energy efficiency utility and lift the cap on rooftop solar net metering.

Commission staff also opposes the deal as proposed.

“Staff concludes that the Merger as proposed in the Joint Petition should be denied by the Commission,” Carol Myers, a deputy director in the commission’s Division of Utility Accounting and Finance, testified Oct. 19.

Staff would not oppose the deal if the companies accept its added conditions, which include an independent board for Dominion’s Virginia utility and limits on the dividends it pays, Myers wrote.

The independent market monitor for PJM Interconnection, the regional grid operator that includes Dominion’s territory, urged rejection in a Nov. 4 letter to the commission. “No behavioral remedies are sufficient to mitigate the market power created by the merger,” the monitor wrote.

PJM serves about 67 million people over 13 states east of the Mississippi River as well as Washington, D.C., according to its website.

The monitor argued that pulling capacity out of the PJM market to serve data centers “would be directly counter to” the White House Ratepayer Protection Pledge. The letter says the pledge, along with principles from the administration’s National Energy Dominance Council and PJM’s governors, calls for data centers to be powered by newly built plants.

Democratic Reps. Don Beyer, Jennifer McClellan, Suhas Subramanyam, Eugene Vindman and James Walkinshaw of Virginia asked the commission in a Nov. 12 letter to reject the merger “in its current form, as recommended by Commission staff.”

The companies announced the all-stock deal May 18. Dominion shareholders would receive 0.8138 NextEra shares for each share they hold and own about 25.5 percent of the combined company, the release said.

The governor’s office calls it a $67 billion merger. Utility boards in North and South Carolina and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission must also approve the deal. So must the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, and the companies expect it to close in the back half of 2027.

The commission extended its review by the maximum 120 days that Virginia law allows, its July 21 order states, setting a deadline 180 days after the companies’ July 15 filing.

All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact licensing@dailycallernewsfoundation.org.

Open on IJR →