EXCLUSIVE: Hawaii Courts Refuse To Release Log Of Judges’ Emails Sought By Watchdog Probing Climate Group, Lawsuit Says
Hawaii's courts will not hand over a log of judges' emails withheld from a watchdog probing a climate education group, a lawsuit says.
Hawaii’s courts will not hand over a log of judges’ emails withheld from a watchdog probing a climate education group, a lawsuit says.
The Patriots Foundation is suing Hawaii’s judicial branch under the state’s public records law. In an Oct. 30 motion obtained by the Daily Caller News Foundation, the group says the Judiciary’s lawyer told its attorneys a log of withheld records lists about 250 emails and that she was barred from handing it over.
The Iowa-based group says in the motion that the Judiciary had not answered any of the 16 written questions it sent across its two related suits, even though the deadline was extended twice. The Judiciary filed its own motion the same day asking for more time to answer the questions in one of the two cases, the court’s docket shows. A hearing in that case is set for 9:15 a.m. Hawaii time Dec. 2.
“We have heard nothing further from the Hawaii Judiciary on the log since the court filing,” Jason Torchinsky, a lawyer for the foundation, said in a statement to the DCNF.
The foundation’s requests, filed in August 2025 and January 2026, seek four Hawaii jurists’ communications with the Environmental Law Institute: former Chief Justice Mark Recktenwald, former Associate Justice Michael Wilson, retired Circuit Judge Jeffrey Crabtree and Maui Circuit Judge Peter Cahill. The request on Wilson also asks for his communications with Sher Edling, a law firm that has represented Honolulu in its climate suit against oil companies.
“While we were not aware of these legal actions in Hawaii, we know that for more than a year, the Patriots Foundation has issued extensive public records requests about our Climate Judiciary Project (CJP),” the Environmental Law Institute said in a statement to the DCNF.
“These requests are part of a broader pattern, in which advocates, politicians, and segments of the media have repeatedly advanced false allegations about our work without substantiating them,” the institute said.
The Hawaii State Judiciary and Sher Edling did not respond to requests for comment.
“Judicial education is a longstanding and essential part of our legal system, particularly as courts confront increasingly complex scientific questions,” the institute said. “Our program provides judges with evidence-based education—not advocacy, litigation support, or advice on how to rule. We stand by our work and welcome fair scrutiny grounded in facts.”
The institute’s Climate Judiciary Project says it has worked with at least 2,000 judges and “does not advise judges on how they should rule on any issue or in any case.”
Torchinsky said Hawaii’s judiciary “has been one of the places where we have not received the same cooperation we have gotten elsewhere about documents we are seeking.”
The foundation and other nonprofit groups have posted records they obtained about the Climate Judiciary Project on a website, CJPFiles, its home page says.
“The Patriots Foundation believes that transparency is important and has worked hard to collect and catalog these files and make them publicly available,” Torchinsky said.
For three of the judges, the Judiciary turned over only travel and fiscal records, and it produced nothing in response to the Wilson request, the foundation says in the filing. In withholding the rest, the Judiciary cited two sections of the public records law, the motion says. One excludes the courts’ nonadministrative functions from the law’s coverage and the other lists exceptions to disclosure.
A lawyer for the court system estimated at a July hearing that it was holding back “a few hundred emails for the judges” along with roughly 100 pages of non-email records, the motion says. John T. Hyatt, one of the foundation’s attorneys, stated in a sworn declaration that the Judiciary’s lawyer had described every record on the log as an email.
The log lists only emails, the motion says, with the non-email records described in court “seemingly having vanished.”
The foundation’s attorneys wrote that the Judiciary’s lawyer suggested during an Oct. 28 videoconference that the dispute between her and her client centered on its unwillingness to share the log. The attorneys also wrote that she made clear the Judiciary had decided to end her representation. The foundation served the motion on Tiffany Chang, a lawyer in the state attorney general’s office whose declaration accompanies the Judiciary’s request for more time, the docket shows.
Recktenwald disclosed in May 2023, while Honolulu’s suit was pending before the Hawaii Supreme Court, that he had been a presenter in a remote course the National Judicial College offered “in collaboration with the Environmental Law Institute” for judges. He went on to write the unanimous opinion the court issued in October 2023, which held that the suit “does not seek to regulate emissions” and allowed it to proceed.
“The Hawaii Judiciary’s entanglement with the Climate Judiciary Project should alarm anyone who values impartial courts and energy affordability,” Mike Toth, research director at the University of Texas at Austin’s Civitas Institute, said in a statement to the DCNF.
“CJP’s judicial training operation was built to encourage outcomes that drive up energy costs. Hawaii’s former chief justice presented at those trainings, then handed down a decision that jeopardizes energy affordability across the country,” Toth said. “Consumers are entitled to transparency and impartiality from our courts — Hawaii’s included.”
The U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments Oct. 5 in Suncor Energy v. Boulder County, where the justices could decide whether federal law bars local governments’ state-law suits against energy companies over climate change.
All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact licensing@dailycallernewsfoundation.org.