Meta’s $25 Billion Court Fine Could Pave Way For Rogue AGs To Rule America
The Constitution delegated Congress the authority to pass legislation and policy for the country, but that didn't stop an attorney general and judge from opening the door to a slippery slope in American litigation, experts say.
The Constitution delegated Congress the authority to pass legislation and policy for the country, but that didn’t stop an attorney general from opening the door to a slippery slope in American litigation, experts say.
New Mexico District Court Judge Francis J. Mathew in October ordered Meta to pay a $25 billion fine after a jury found the tech giant misled consumers about its privacy policies in a case launched by Democratic New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez. Free speech advocates have already decried the ruling, and the company is planning to appeal it.
“The lawmakers we elect are supposed to make the laws that govern us. And few of us had the opportunity to vote for the Attorney General of New Mexico,” Casey Mattox, a constitutional attorney and vice president of legal strategy for Stand Together, told the DCNF. “When one politician is able to use the courts to regulate speech online across the globe it’s hard to see it as anything other than a usurpation of our constitutional system.”
A top Meta attorney issued a similar warning in mid-November, highlighting how the case unleashes a dangerous new trend.
“Clearly, what we are seeing here is not just run-of-the-mill litigation. What we are seeing is usurpation by litigation,” Meta Chief Legal Officer C.J. said during a Federalist Society panel on Nov. 13.
“The Attorney General of New Mexico has said that this is the first of many suits he intends to bring against large corporations in this country. He’s bragged that he’s funded education in the state for another 50 years,” Mahoney said of Torrez.
A Meta spokesperson referred the Daily Caller News Foundation to Mahoney’s comments. Torrez’s office did not respond to a request for comment.
‘Just The Beginning’
Torrez sued Meta, accusing the company of lying after a whistleblower revealed that Facebook collected and shared millions of users’ information without their consent with the political consulting firm Cambridge Analytica, according to the court’s ruling.
“The message should be received in Silicon Valley that this is not the end, it’s just the beginning,” Torrez told Politico in late October after his landmark victory.
Some experts are raising questions about how much power attorneys general should have, while others argue there is much more work needed to address privacy in the absence of a federal standard.
“I would submit to you that any state attorney general, any plaintiff’s lawyer, is more powerful today than the European Commission, the DOJ, the FTC, and the SEC combined,” Mahoney remarked. “Talk about swarms of officials. So, what’s to stop other attorneys general, perhaps blue states, turbocharged by the plaintiffs’ bar from suing Fox News over its slogan ‘Fair and Balanced,’ or red states from suing the New York Times over its claim to publish all the news that’s fit to print.”
“I definitely see the arguments behind it,” Kathleen Farley, vice president of litigation for the Chamber of Progress, told the DCNF about Mahoney’s contention that the New Mexico Meta ruling amounts to “usurpation by litigation.” “I have litigated not this exactly, but I’ve been in a situation where you’re in a smaller state, and the precedent isn’t as well developed. And, under the precedent that exists, it’s a violation. I have to wonder where the problem with the reason people are saying it should be done legislatively is with judge-made law in these kind of situations, you need like five or six cases to kind of hash things out.”
“New Mexico didn’t have as much developed precedent to shape the settlement around,” the Chamber of Progress vice president said, noting that the United States does not have a federal privacy standard like the European Union has. “Did they have the ideal law? No, but that was the hand that they had.”
Free speech advocates believe the historic fine against Meta may stifle free speech against companies that do not sufficiently police so-called hate speech and misinformation.
“This decision is a major threat to free speech. It would allow a few lawyers in a few states to regulate speech online in violation of federal law and the First Amendment. I hope Meta sticks to its guns and appeals this decision to protect not only its own rights, but everyone’s,” Mattox told the DCNF in a statement in October.
Facebook “made promises regarding the prevalence and nature of misinformation and hate speech on the platform and assured the public that the users on the platform would, no matter who they were, be treated equally. The jury found those statements to be false as well,” the court’s judgment states.
The ruling has even drawn commentary from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.
“Strong consumer protections matter. Consumers deserve clear rights, meaningful safeguards, and accountable enforcement when companies fail to meet their obligations. Businesses also need clear rules of the road so they can comply, innovate, and continue delivering products and services that consumers value,” Sean Heather, senior vice president of international affairs and antitrust at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, wrote in late October.
“The Meta decision showcases a system where excessive and overlapping penalties undermine credible enforcement. A balanced approach better protects consumers while giving businesses the certainty they need to comply and responsibly support continued innovation,” Heather wrote.
Other critics believe that punitive fines against companies such as Meta force courts to become product designers.
“Imposing enormous damages awards may incentivize some defendant companies to voluntarily redesign litigation-spawning products and services. If changing some design elements can prevent plaintiff victories without compromising the quality, value, and consumer appeal of the goods in question, then why not implement them? It’s akin to the theory that punitive damages awards will ‘deter similar acts in the future,'” Clay Calvert, a nonresident senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, wrote in a blog post in October.
All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact licensing@dailycallernewsfoundation.org.