• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Business
  • Lifestyle
Trump Calls on ‘All Americans To Help Ease Tensions and Calm Tempers’ Amid Concerns of Future Violence

Explainer: Is Trump’s Post-Presidency Impeachment Trial Constitutional?

February 2, 2021
2 Firefighters Dead, Law Enforcement Facing Active Shooter In Idaho Wildfire Attack

2 Firefighters Dead, Law Enforcement Facing Active Shooter In Idaho Wildfire Attack

June 29, 2025
Senate GOP Slashes Spending In ‘Big, Beautiful’ Bill As Fiscal Hawks Push For More Cuts

Senate GOP Slashes Spending In ‘Big, Beautiful’ Bill As Fiscal Hawks Push For More Cuts

June 29, 2025
NORMAN R. SEIP And DANIEL CHRISTMAN: Fair Use Or Failure: The Future Of Us-Led AI

NORMAN R. SEIP And DANIEL CHRISTMAN: Fair Use Or Failure: The Future Of Us-Led AI

June 29, 2025
Dem Senator Can’t Bring Himself To Give Trump Any Credit For Record-Low Border Numbers

Dem Senator Can’t Bring Himself To Give Trump Any Credit For Record-Low Border Numbers

June 29, 2025
Thom Tillis Announces Retirement Hours After Trump Threatened To Field Primary Challenger

Thom Tillis Announces Retirement Hours After Trump Threatened To Field Primary Challenger

June 29, 2025
STEVE MILLOY: John Thune Needs To Do Something About Obama-Era Parliamentarian Kneecapping Trump’s Megabill

STEVE MILLOY: John Thune Needs To Do Something About Obama-Era Parliamentarian Kneecapping Trump’s Megabill

June 29, 2025
Dems’ NYC Socialist Nominee Ducks And Weaves When Asked To Condemn Term Calling For Killing Jews

Dems’ NYC Socialist Nominee Ducks And Weaves When Asked To Condemn Term Calling For Killing Jews

June 29, 2025
‘A Radical Left Lunatic’: Trump Has Warning For NYC If Dems’ Socialist Nominee Pulls Any Stunts

‘A Radical Left Lunatic’: Trump Has Warning For NYC If Dems’ Socialist Nominee Pulls Any Stunts

June 29, 2025
EXCLUSIVE: Ted Cruz Fears Attempt To Scrap Provision In Trump’s Megabill Would Hand ‘Gift’ To China

EXCLUSIVE: Ted Cruz Fears Attempt To Scrap Provision In Trump’s Megabill Would Hand ‘Gift’ To China

June 29, 2025
NPR Caught Straight Up Misquoting DOGE Staffer

NPR Caught Straight Up Misquoting DOGE Staffer

June 29, 2025
Two GOP Senators Vote ‘No’ As Trump’s Megabill Clears Critical Hurdle

Two GOP Senators Vote ‘No’ As Trump’s Megabill Clears Critical Hurdle

June 28, 2025
‘Outright Massacre’: Senate GOP Takes Sledgehammer To Biden’s Green Energy Subsidies

‘Outright Massacre’: Senate GOP Takes Sledgehammer To Biden’s Green Energy Subsidies

June 28, 2025
  • Donald Trump
  • State of the Union
  • Elon Musk
  • Tariffs
  • Congress
  • Faith
  • Immigration
Sunday, June 29, 2025
  • Login
IJR
  • Politics
  • US News
  • Commentary
  • World News
  • Faith
  • Latest Polls
No Result
View All Result
IJR
No Result
View All Result
Home News

Explainer: Is Trump’s Post-Presidency Impeachment Trial Constitutional?

by Reuters
February 2, 2021 at 7:22 am
in News
250 2
6
Trump Calls on ‘All Americans To Help Ease Tensions and Calm Tempers’ Amid Concerns of Future Violence

FILE PHOTO: U.S. President Donald Trump boards Air Force One at Valley International Airport after visiting the U.S.-Mexico border wall, in Harlingen, Texas, U.S., January 12, 2021. (Carlos Barria/Reuters)

491
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The upcoming second impeachment trial of former President Donald Trump, focusing on a charge of inciting the deadly Jan. 6 storming of the U.S. Capitol by his followers, has prompted a debate over whether the proceeding is constitutional.

Some legal experts have said it is appropriate to hold the trial after Trump has left office, but there is no clear answer in the U.S. Constitution and no court has ruled on the issue. Many Senate Republicans have said they would vote to acquit Trump on that basis. Democrats note that the House of Representatives voted to impeach Trump a week before he left office.

Here is an overview of the once-academic debate that has taken on new importance.

Is there a consensus on whether Trump’s post-presidency trial is legal?

No, but the majority of experts say it is constitutional to have an impeachment trial after an official has left office, said Brian Kalt, a law professor at Michigan State University and a leading impeachment scholar.

Kalt was part of a bipartisan group of roughly 150 lawyers who signed a letter arguing that Trump can still be convicted in an impeachment trial.

Signatories of the letter included the co-founder and other members of the Federalist Society, a legal group that wields influence in conservative politics.

“We differ from one another in our politics, and we also differ from one another on issues of constitutional interpretation,” said the Jan. 21 letter. “But despite our differences, our carefully considered views of the law lead all of us to agree that the Constitution permits the impeachment, conviction, and disqualification of former officers, including presidents.”

Other scholars disagree, however, including J. Michael Luttig, a prominent lawyer and former federal appeals court judge, and Jonathan Turley, a George Washington University law professor.

What does the Constitution say?

Under the Constitution, the president “shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.”

In a separate clause, the Constitution says conviction can lead to “removal from Office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any Office of honor, Trust or Profit under the United States.”

Removing an official requires a “conviction” by a two-thirds Senate majority under the Constitution. Under precedent, only a simple majority is needed for disqualification. Historically, that vote only happens after a conviction.

What is the main argument for “late impeachment”?

Many experts believe that presidents who commit misconduct late in their terms should not be immune from the very process the Constitution created for holding them accountable.

Since the Constitution makes clear that impeachment proceedings can result in disqualification from holding future office, there is a live issue for the Senate to resolve even though Trump is no longer president, those scholars argue.

What is the argument against holding the trial now?

Luttig has said that the text and purpose of the Constitution make clear that the Senate’s power is limited to convicting a sitting president.

Historical texts indicate that the nation’s founders saw impeachment as a way to remove officials from their jobs so they do not further harm the country, those lawyers argue.

Is there historical precedent?

There are two instances in which the Senate held impeachment trials for officials after they had left office — Senator William Blount in 1797 and Secretary of War William Belknap in 1876. Blount’s trial was halted before the Senate could decide its verdict and Belknap was acquitted.

Luttig has argued that Congress’ earlier interpretation of its power is just one factor to consider and does not have the same significance as a court decision.

(Reporting by Jan Wolfe; Editing by Noeleen Walder and Peter Cooney)

Tags: Donald TrumpImpeachment
Share196Tweet123
Reuters

Reuters

Reuters is an international news organization.

Advertisements

Top Stories June 10th
Top Stories June 7th
Top Stories June 6th
Top Stories June 3rd
Top Stories May 30th
Top Stories May 29th
Top Stories May 24th
Top Stories May 23rd
Top Stories May 21st
Top Stories May 17th

Join Over 6M Subscribers

We’re organizing an online community to elevate trusted voices on all sides so that you can be fully informed.





IJR

    Copyright © 2024 IJR

Trusted Voices On All Sides

  • About Us
  • GDPR Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Editorial Standards & Corrections Policy
  • Subscribe to IJR

Follow Us

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
  • US News
  • Commentary
  • World News
  • Faith
  • Latest Polls

    Copyright © 2024 IJR

Top Stories June 10th Top Stories June 7th Top Stories June 6th Top Stories June 3rd Top Stories May 30th Top Stories May 29th Top Stories May 24th Top Stories May 23rd Top Stories May 21st Top Stories May 17th