Judicial data via CourtListener (Free Law Project). Social links via Wikidata.
Decision levers
AI-measured from their own opinions — each lever cites its cases
PurposivismTextualism
Applies the six-month statutory window in Section 16(b) by strictly following the established measurement rule without expanding or narrowing based on policy goals. COLONIAL REALTY CORPORATION v. M… ↗
Willing to revisit precedentStrong stare decisis
Declines to revisit a decades-old interpretation of the statutory period because of its longevity, practical workability, and settled reliance interests. COLONIAL REALTY CORPORATION v. M… ↗
Deference to government powerSkepticism of government power
Refuses to create a compensation remedy in Chapter XI proceedings absent express statutory authorization and leaves policy choices about creditor reimbursement to Congress. In Re FAS International, Inc. ↗
Affiliations
Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit — appointed by Richard Nixon
District Court, S.D. New York — appointed by Richard Nixon
This case involved antitrust claims by International Railways of Central America (IRCA) against United Brands (formerly United Fruit) and its subsidiary, alleging violations of Sherman Act Sections 1 and 2 and Clayton Act Section 7 from 1961 onward. IRCA claimed that United Fruit used its prior control over the railroad to suppress competing banana shippers, limit its own shipments, dispose of plantations, and maintain an unlawful acquisition of control. After a bench trial on liability, the court ruled for the defendants, finding that the evidence did not establish the alleged anticompetitive conduct or effects in the relevant markets. The decision rested on detailed factual findings that the challenged actions were not shown to have violated the statutes during the applicable recovery periods.
The case concerned a state prisoner's habeas corpus petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2254 challenging his 1972 conviction for promoting gambling and possessing bookmaking instruments, on grounds that the search warrant lacked probable cause due to a vague or perjurious affidavit and that the state trial court improperly denied a pre-trial suppression hearing. The federal court had initially dismissed the petition for failure to exhaust state remedies; after the state court denied post-conviction relief under C.P.L. § 440.10(2)(c), the federal court reinstated the petition, conducted its own hearing, and considered the claims on the merits. The court determined that the affidavit supporting the warrant met constitutional standards, that the petitioner failed to prove any material falsehoods or lack of probable cause, and that any error in denying the state suppression hearing was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. Accordingly, the petition was dismissed.
In this case, international record carriers ITT and RCA sought a preliminary injunction against the New York Telephone Company to prevent it from replacing their direct-current teletypewriter-grade local distribution facilities with alternating-current voice-grade carrier systems, a switch that would require expensive modem installations and potential service interruptions for thousands of customers. The plaintiffs asserted claims under Sections 214 and 406 of the Federal Communications Act, while the Telephone Company moved to dismiss for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction and failure to state a claim. The court reviewed the history of tariff filings, objections, and related FCC proceedings on whether the proposed change constituted a discontinuance or impairment of service requiring prior approval, and it based its ruling on Section 214 while noting the role of primary jurisdiction.
In this Chapter XI bankruptcy proceeding involving FAS International, Inc., the indenture trustee for subordinated convertible debentures and its counsel sought allowances for fees and expenses after helping negotiate a plan that gave debenture holders a 20% equity stake, despite their initially disenfranchised status and the subordinated nature of their claims. The Bankruptcy Judge denied the applications, holding that the Bankruptcy Act provided no statutory authority for such compensation to unofficial creditors' representatives in a Chapter XI arrangement and that equitable powers could not expand the statute. On review, the District Court confirmed the denial, relying on circuit precedent that compensation is unavailable absent express statutory authorization and emphasizing that policy questions about who qualifies for reimbursement in reorganization cases are for Congress to resolve.
This case is a shareholder derivative action brought on behalf of Colonial Realty Corporation against two officers of Colonial Penn Group under Section 16(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, seeking recovery of profits from alleged short-swing trades in company stock. The defendants moved to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6), contending that the sales in December 1972 and purchases in June 1973 fell outside the statutory period of less than six months. The court granted the motion and dismissed the complaint, applying the interpretation established in Stella v. Graham-Paige Motors Corp. that measures the period by excluding the corresponding date six months after the initial transaction. The ruling follows stare decisis due to the precedent's longevity, practical workability, and investors' reliance interests, without finding the rule clearly erroneous or unworkable.
This case involves two customers suing their stock broker for failing to forward notice or certificates of a two-for-one stock split in Camin Industries shares held in street name and for sending inaccurate monthly account statements showing fewer shares than actually owned, which allegedly prevented them from realizing gains as the stock value rose. The plaintiffs asserted claims under Section 17(a) of the 1933 Securities Act and Sections 10(b) and 20(a) plus Rule 10b-5 of the 1934 Act, breach of NASD Rules of Fair Practice, and pendent state-law claims for fraud and negligence, with no diversity of citizenship alleged. The court granted the broker's Rule 12(b)(6) motion and dismissed the complaint in full, reasoning that a stock split is not a "sale" under the statutes so no federal securities claim was stated, that NASD rule violations do not imply a private federal cause of action, and that the state claims therefore lacked a jurisdictional anchor.