Judicial data via CourtListener (Free Law Project). Social links via Wikidata.
Born 1927 · Breckenridge, MN
Lippman v. Sholom Home, Inc.
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1996-11-20 · cited 5×
In Lippman v. Sholom Home, Inc., a former employee of a nonprofit senior care facility sued his employer under the Americans with Disabilities Act, claiming his termination resulted from disability discrimination after he disclosed attention deficit disorder. The district court granted the employer's motion for summary judgment and denied the employee's cross-motion. The court held that the employee failed to show he had a qualifying disability under the ADA, as his condition did not substantially limit a major life activity. The court further reasoned that the employer had documented legitimate performance issues, including tardiness and attendance problems dating back years before any disclosure of a disability, and the employee presented no evidence that these reasons were pretextual.
labor & employmentcivil rights
Ford Motor Credit Co. v. Lee (In Re Lee)
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-12-21 · cited 28×
The case concerned Ford Motor Credit Company's appeal of a bankruptcy court's order confirming debtors' Chapter 13 plan for a car loan. The plan included a provision allowing the vehicle to vest in the debtors free and clear of liens once the secured portion of FMCC's claim was paid, even before the full plan was completed, despite FMCC's objection and a second lienholder's claim. The district court affirmed the confirmation after reviewing the undisputed facts and applicable law de novo. It reasoned that sections 506, 1322, and 1327 of the Bankruptcy Code, along with supporting precedent like Dewsnup v. Timm and In re Neiman, permit early vesting of collateral upon payment of the allowed secured claim while the estate continues to exist. Policy concerns raised by the creditor were deemed insufficient to override the statutory provisions.
propertyprocedurebusiness & regulatory
Tower Ins. Co., Inc. v. Judge
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-12-17 · cited 18×
This case involves insurance coverage disputes arising from a 1992 incident in which four young men, including John Judge and Richard Balster, attempted to wake their unconscious friend by attaching speaker wire to his body and a light switch, resulting in his electrocution and death. The men's parents' homeowner insurers, Tower Insurance and Secura Insurance, filed declaratory judgment actions seeking to avoid defending or indemnifying their insureds in a related wrongful death suit, arguing that the death was not an "occurrence" under the policies and fell under exclusions for expected or intended injuries or criminal acts. The court denied the insurers' summary judgment motions and granted summary judgment to the defendants, ordering the insurers to provide coverage. It reasoned that the policies covered accidental bodily injury, the defendants did not intend or expect the death (believing the low-voltage shocks would be harmless), the wiring error rendered the outcome accidental, and any criminal act exclusions were either inapplicable, undisclosed, or not triggered by the deferred criminal pleas.
torts & liabilitycriminal law
Burlington Northern Railroad v. Soo Line Railroad
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-12-13 · cited 3×
This case involves a dispute between Burlington Northern Railroad and Soo Line Railroad over rights to use jointly operated tracks between St. Paul and St. Croix Junction under a 1902 agreement originally between their predecessor railroads. The agreement included an easement for railway uses, a prohibition on assignment without consent, and a clause requiring arbitration of disputes while maintaining the status quo during arbitration. After the Milwaukee Railroad's bankruptcy, Soo Line acquired its operations with court approval that included assignment of contracts, leading Burlington Northern to challenge Soo Line's rights and seek to block arbitration. The court granted Soo Line partial summary judgment, ruling that the dispute must proceed to arbitration under the agreement's terms, and issued a preliminary injunction to restore operations to the pre-dispute status until the arbitrators decide.
business & regulatoryprocedure
United States v. Napco International, Inc.
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-09-30 · cited 8×
The case involved the United States suing Napco International under the False Claims Act and related theories for allegedly submitting false claims and certifications when supplying US-origin military parts to Turkey through the Foreign Military Sales program; Napco had obtained the parts from foreign surplus stockpiles in Israel and Canada rather than new US manufacture. The court granted Napco's motion for summary judgment on all four counts as to the four purchase agreements at issue. The core reasoning was that the Arms Export Control Act and DSAA guidelines did not clearly prohibit Napco's sourcing of originally US-manufactured parts from foreign inventories, that Napco's contractor certifications were accurate and truthful under the regulations, and that the government therefore could not establish falsity or violation as a matter of law.
criminal lawbusiness & regulatory
Wilkes Ex Rel. Yellow v. Steffen
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-08-25 · cited 5×
The case involved plaintiffs, caretakers of children receiving AFDC benefits in Minnesota, challenging a state rule that required combining separate filing units into a single assistance unit when caretakers lived together, which reduced the total AFDC grant. The court granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs and enjoined the state from consolidating units without determining that income from non-legally responsible relatives was actually available. The reasoning was that federal law requires considering only income that is actually available to the assistance unit, and the Minnesota rule improperly deemed income available without such a determination, violating federal regulations.
federal powerfamily law
Barry v. Barry
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-06-15 · cited 6×
This case involves a dispute over whether former corporate officers and directors, the Swartzes, are entitled to an advance of legal expenses from TCF and Charles Barry under a 1991 purchase and loan agreement that incorporates Minnesota Statutes Section 302A.521. The Swartzes sought the advance after being sued by plaintiff Barry, who alleged fraud and breach related to a prior stock redemption agreement and corporate restructuring; they provided the required good-faith undertaking to repay if not ultimately entitled to indemnification. The court granted the motion, holding that the claims were brought at least in part by reason of the Swartzes' official corporate capacities, that the statute's requirements were met, and that the contract therefore obligated advances for reasonable expenses incurred in defense.
business & regulatory
Mousel v. Knutson Mortgage Corp.
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-06-15 · cited 8×
This case involves a dispute over a residential mortgage foreclosure in Minnesota, where pro se plaintiff Brett Mousel challenged Knutson Mortgage Corp.'s foreclosure proceedings on grounds of improper notice, lack of state court jurisdiction, and alleged fraud in the loan amount. After multiple state court actions and dismissals, Mousel filed a federal complaint seeking to vacate state orders and void the mortgage, and he also removed an unlawful detainer eviction action to federal court. The court dismissed the original federal action for lack of subject matter jurisdiction, as it presented only state-law claims with no federal question or diversity jurisdiction, and remanded the removed action to state court on the same grounds. The court denied Knutson's requests for Rule 11 sanctions and an injunction against further filings, finding Mousel's conduct did not meet the standards for such measures in federal court.
propertyprocedure
Schwenn v. Sears, Roebuck & Co.
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-06-08 · cited 11×
This case involved claims by former Sears supervisors against the company, their supervisor Londa Kerby, and her supervisor Bruce Pence for sexual harassment and related torts under the Minnesota Human Rights Act and whistleblower statute, alleging that Kerby created a hostile work environment and that Pence and Sears failed to remedy it after complaints, leading to the plaintiffs' demotions. The defendants removed the action to federal court on diversity grounds, asserting that Pence, a Minnesota resident like the plaintiffs, had been fraudulently joined to defeat jurisdiction. The court held that it lacked subject matter jurisdiction and remanded the case to Minnesota state court, reasoning that defendants failed to show the claims against Pence had no possibility of success, as the record left open the possibility that Pence could be held individually liable under the MHRA for inadequate response to the complaints.
civil rightslabor & employmentproceduretorts & liability
Central National Insurance Co. of Omaha v. Tri-County State Bank
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-06-04
This case concerned a dispute between surety Central National Insurance Company of Omaha (CNIC), which issued Miller Act performance and payment bonds for a federal channel-clearing project, and Tri-County State Bank, which financed the contractor and received an assignment of progress payments from the United States. After the bank applied some payments to unrelated loans and retained an erroneous final payment made after it had released its assignment, CNIC sued to recover those amounts following its own payment of bond claims and receipt of an assignment of the government's recovery rights. The court granted CNIC's motion for summary judgment and denied the bank's, ordering the bank to return $95,554.31. It reasoned that the diverted payments had increased CNIC's bond exposure, that the government had a valid claim to recover the mistaken payment which it validly assigned, and that laches did not bar the suit.
business & regulatoryfederal powerprocedure
C.R.S. Ex Rel. D.B.S. v. United States
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-05-05 · cited 4×
This case involves a family suing the United States under the Federal Tort Claims Act, claiming they contracted HIV from a 1983 blood transfusion given to D.B.S. at a military hospital due to negligence in screening blood donors during the early AIDS crisis. The court granted summary judgment to the defendant, dismissing the claims. The core reasoning is that the military's decisions regarding blood collection standards and policies for notifying recipients were discretionary functions grounded in policy considerations, which are protected from judicial review under the discretionary function exception to the FTCA.
federal powertorts & liabilityhealthcare
McMaster v. State of Minn.
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-04-29 · cited 20×
This case is a class action lawsuit brought by current and former inmates of Minnesota correctional facilities against the state, the Commissioner of the Department of Corrections, and other officials. The plaintiffs challenged the low wages (50-75 cents per hour) paid for work in prison industries under the FLSA, alleged violations of RICO and constitutional rights, claimed that loss of good time for refusing work assignments was improper punishment, and raised related statutory claims under 18 U.S.C. § 1761. The court granted the defendants' motion to dismiss the majority of the claims and for partial summary judgment. It reasoned that the Eleventh Amendment bars suits against the state and officials in their official capacities on most claims, that inmates working in state-run prison industries are not covered employees under the FLSA based on precedent such as Vanskike v. Peters, and that other claims failed as a matter of law because the prison industries are not private enterprises and no private right of action exists under the cited statutes.
criminal lawlabor & employmentfederal power
Christians v. Crystal Evangelical Free Church (In Re Young)
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-04-14 · cited 29×
The case involved a bankruptcy trustee seeking to recover $13,450 in contributions made by insolvent debtors to Crystal Evangelical Free Church within one year before their Chapter 7 filing, claiming the transfers were fraudulent under 11 U.S.C. § 548 because the debtors received less than reasonably equivalent value in exchange. The district court affirmed the bankruptcy court's grant of summary judgment to the trustee, finding that the contributions qualified as avoidable transfers based on the statutory requirements of insolvency and lack of equivalent value. The court rejected the church's constitutional challenges, holding that the statute's application did not violate the Free Exercise Clause by burdening religious practice or the Establishment Clause by creating excessive entanglement, as the law was neutral in purpose and effect and enforcement did not require inquiry into religious doctrine.
religious libertyproperty
Greiner v. City of Champlin
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-03-09 · cited 15×
This case involves six consolidated lawsuits brought by homeowners and guests at a private party against the City of Champlin, its police chief, and individual officers, alleging civil rights violations arising from police responses to noise complaints that led to citations, orders to disperse, physical interactions, and a warrantless entry into the home. The district court addressed the plaintiff's motion for partial summary judgment and the defendants' motions for summary judgment. The court dismissed claims under 42 U.S.C. §§ 1981 and 1985 as abandoned and unsupported by allegations of racial or class-based animus, granted qualified immunity to the officers on § 1983 claims where the conduct did not violate clearly established rights or where probable cause supported actions, and held the city not liable under § 1983 due to the absence of an unconstitutional policy or custom, while also applying official and sovereign immunity to state-law claims.
civil rightsprocedurecriminal law
FSC Securities Corp. v. Freel
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1993-01-15 · cited 7×
This case involved plaintiffs, including a securities firm and financial planner, seeking to vacate an NASD arbitration award in favor of defendants who lost approximately $81,000 on investments recommended by the planner. The defendants alleged unsuitable investments and sought recovery including losses, interest, and punitive damages; the arbitrators denied repeated motions to dismiss based on the six-year eligibility bar in NASD Code §15 and ultimately awarded the defendants over $122,000. The court confirmed the award under the Federal Arbitration Act. The core reasoning was that judicial review of arbitration awards is extremely limited, the arbitrators were empowered by NASD rules to interpret §15 and determine their own jurisdiction over the claims, and plaintiffs failed to show the arbitrators exceeded their powers or acted in manifest disregard of the law.
business & regulatoryprocedure
Richards v. Union Labor Life Insurance
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1992-10-30 · cited 10×
This case involves two actions brought by an ERISA-governed employee retirement plan and its individual trustees against Union Labor Life Insurance Company and its in-house actuary, alleging professional malpractice and breach of contract based on negligent actuarial valuations that created an illusion of overfunding, prompted improper benefit increases, and later revealed severe underfunding exceeding $3 million. The defendants removed the cases from state court and moved to dismiss on the ground that ERISA preempts the state-law claims. The court denied the motions, reasoning that ERISA's broad preemption clause does not displace run-of-the-mill state professional malpractice claims against non-fiduciary service providers because such claims relate to the plan only peripherally and Congress did not intend to federalize standards for these services.
labor & employmentfederal powertorts & liability
Tikkanen v. Citibank (South Dakota) N.A.
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1992-10-29 · cited 21×
In this case, Minnesota residents who held credit cards from out-of-state national banks sued the banks in state court, alleging that late fees and overlimit fees violated Minnesota statutes and constituted unfair practices under state law, even though the fees were allowed by the banks' home states. The banks removed the actions to federal court and moved for summary judgment, while the plaintiffs sought to dismiss the cases without prejudice due to unsettled law on preemption. The court denied the motions to dismiss or stay and granted summary judgment to the defendants. It held that 12 U.S.C. § 85, which permits national banks to charge interest rates allowed by their home states, treats late and overlimit fees as interest, thereby preempting contrary Minnesota law.
business & regulatoryfederal power
Wolff v. City of Monticello
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1992-10-20 · cited 23×
The case concerned video rental store owners in Monticello, Minnesota, who challenged city ordinances regulating adult-oriented businesses through zoning restrictions, licensing requirements, and a ban on internal and external advertising of adult materials. The court granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs and enjoined enforcement of the advertising restriction in Ordinance Amendment No. 217 and the entirety of the licensing Ordinance Amendment No. 219. It reasoned that the ordinances regulated protected First Amendment speech, as the adult videotapes were not obscene, and that the city had not shown the advertising ban was narrowly tailored to a substantial government interest or that the licensing scheme provided adequate procedural protections against prior restraint under precedents such as Renton and FW/PBS.
free speechbusiness & regulatory
Shakopee Mdewakanton Sioux Community v. Hope
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1992-08-11 · cited 4×
The case concerned two federally recognized Indian tribes and a tribally owned corporation challenging regulations issued by the National Indian Gaming Commission that classified the game of keno as a Class III game under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act. Class III games require a tribal-state compact to be offered on tribal lands, unlike Class II games such as bingo, which tribes may offer without such compacts. The court granted the defendants' motions for summary judgment and denied the plaintiffs' cross-motions, upholding the regulations. The core reasoning was that keno is not similar to bingo because players select their own numbers rather than covering pre-printed cards and that the commission's classification was permissible, with keno also qualifying as a house-banked casino game.
federal powerbusiness & regulatory
Soo Line Railroad Ex Rel. Minnesota v. B.J. Carney & Co.
District Court, D. Minnesota · 1992-06-23 · cited 35×
This case involves claims by Soo Line Railroad against a dissolved Nevada corporation (B.J. Carney & Co.), its statutory trustees, a successor limited partnership, partners, and related individuals for alleged releases of hazardous substances that contaminated a leased property in Minneapolis known as the Humboldt Yard site and adjacent areas, posing risks to groundwater and municipal water supplies. The complaint asserted ten counts, including violations of CERCLA, MERLA, and MERA, as well as breach of lease, strict liability for abnormally dangerous activities, negligence, trespass, nuisance, and claims for indemnity or contribution. The defendants moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim, raising issues such as successor liability after corporate dissolution without notice, the applicability of liability rules to partnerships, and related state law defenses. The court denied the motion, finding that the allegations sufficiently stated claims under the environmental statutes and common law theories, that successor liability exceptions applied to the limited partnership and other defendants, and that federal environmental law considerations were not barred by the cited state law or procedural arguments.
environmentbusiness & regulatorytorts & liabilityprocedure