In this diversity case, Kamco Industrial Sales, a commissioned sales representative, sued Lovejoy, a manufacturer, for breach of contract and violation of the Pennsylvania Commissioned Sales Representative Act after Lovejoy redefined nearly all of Kamco's accounts as non-commission House Accounts during the 2009 recession. The court granted Lovejoy's motion for summary judgment in part and denied it in part. It granted summary judgment on the PCSRA claim because Kamco did not qualify as a sales representative under the statute's definition. It denied summary judgment on the breach claim, finding a genuine issue of material fact as to whether Lovejoy's redefinition of accounts violated the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing under the contract, given the parties' prior limited course of dealing and the contract's termination provisions.
In this case, pro se plaintiff Marc Draper alleged that the impoundment of his vehicle by Darby Township police violated the Pennsylvania Vehicle Code's notice requirements and deprived him of property without due process, seeking its return or value plus damages under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and state law. The court dismissed the complaint against all defendants, including PennDOT on Eleventh Amendment grounds, the deceased state judge on judicial immunity, and others for failure to state a plausible claim or comply with an order to amend the complaint. The core reasoning was that the allegations did not plausibly establish a constitutional violation, that federal courts lacked jurisdiction over state agencies, and that the plaintiff had not adequately responded to motions or clarified claims against private towing defendants. Plaintiff was granted leave to file an amended complaint only against Officer Sweeney.
This case concerned a dispute between Tinicum Township and Delaware County and the City of Philadelphia over the city's proposed expansion of Philadelphia International Airport under the FAA's Capacity Enhancement Plan, specifically whether the township could withhold consent under Pennsylvania statute 53 P.S. § 14161 to the purchase of local land needed to relocate a UPS facility. The plaintiffs sought a declaratory judgment affirming their right to block the land acquisition, while the defendant argued that federal aviation law preempted the state consent requirement. The court denied the plaintiffs' motion for judgment on the pleadings and granted the defendant's cross-motion. The core reasoning was that federal law under the Federal Aviation Act occupies the field of aviation safety and airport capacity enhancement at congested airports, thereby preempting the state statute, with additional analysis of conflict preemption due to the FAA's directives on reducing delays.
The case involves plaintiff Brian Warshaw suing his former employer TEKsystems and Allegis for disability discrimination and retaliation under the ADA and PHRA after a positive drug test result (due to his prescribed ADHD medication) led to his termination from a short-term assignment and failure to be placed in further jobs, along with a negligence claim against Concentra Health Services for mishandling and reporting the test results. The court addressed cross-motions for summary judgment on the discrimination, retaliation, and negligence claims, as well as related procedural matters. It applied the summary judgment standard under Fed. R. Civ. P. 56, analyzed whether Warshaw was actually disabled or regarded as disabled, assessed evidence of pretext or mixed motives in the termination and non-placement decisions, evaluated retaliation based on the filing of a PHRA charge, and determined that Concentra owed a duty of care under Pennsylvania tort law regarding the processing and reporting of the drug test.
In this diversity case removed from state court, plaintiff Forcine Concrete sued MES & S, its president and employees, and two other defendants for alleged fraud, civil conspiracy, violations of Pennsylvania's Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law, breach of an oral contract, and conversion arising from an attempted sale of a laser screed machine. After MES & S entered Chapter 7 bankruptcy, Forcine moved for relief from the automatic stay to proceed against the non-debtor defendants. The court granted the motion, holding that the stay under 11 U.S.C. § 362(a) applies only to the debtor and does not extend to the other defendants because no unusual circumstances existed, such as a sufficient identity of interest or indemnity obligations that would make a judgment against them equivalent to one against MES & S. The court noted that Somero and Hillock had no legal relationship to the debtor, while the individual defendants' potential indemnity claims did not qualify under the governing Third Circuit standards for extending the stay.
The case involved the Federal Trade Commission pursuing recovery of consumer funds allegedly obtained through a telemarketing scheme selling health benefit plans, after the court had appointed a receiver over the defendant entities. The receiver sought turnover of funds held by Teledraft, a non-party payment processor that had handled transactions for the defendants via remote checks and ACH transfers. The court granted the FTC's motion to compel Teledraft to turn over the funds. The core reasoning was that summary proceedings were appropriate to determine possession of the funds without adjudicating Teledraft's own potential wrongdoing, and that Teledraft's contractual agreements allowed deductions for returns or unauthorized charges even after settlement periods.