Recruitment
Despite Hines-Allen leading New Jersey in sacks as a senior, he was still very much under the recruiting radar. Four highly rated recruits who went on to become NFL players—Jabrill Peppers, Quenton Nelson, David Njoku, and Mike Gesicki—were fellow high school seniors in New Jersey. The recruiting website 247Sports rated Hines-Allen as a two-star prospect (out of a possible five), and ranked more than 2,000 players in the 2015 recruiting class ahead of him. John Fiore, at the time head coach at Montclair High, actively tried to get Rutgers to evaluate him, but the coaching staff there showed no interest. In a 2019 ESPN story on Hines-Allen, Fiore said about Rutgers' lack of interest, "Some people just couldn't see the potential in him. Kentucky did, and they won big. I told Rutgers, 'You guys are going to look foolish when he's drafted in the first round.'" In fact, when Hines-Allen made his verbal commitment to Monmouth, no Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS) school had offered him a scholarship, and no other NCAA Division I school, whether FBS or FCS, had made him an offer.
Hines-Allen's journey to Kentucky began with West Orange High School head coach Jim Matsakis, whose team had faced Montclair High in his senior year. Matsakis made a phone call to his brother Louie, who was then on the Wildcats coaching staff. Louie first contacted D. J. Eliot, then Kentucky's outside linebackers coach, who in turn contacted the then-defensive backs coach Derrick Ansley while the latter was on a recruiting trip in the Washington metropolitan area. Eliot told Ansley to detour to New Jersey to meet with Hines-Allen and arrange for an immediate campus visit if he was at least 6'4". While he had verbally committed to Monmouth, Hines-Allen was still available for recruitment because he had yet to sign a letter of intent. Hines-Allen visited Kentucky and signed with the Wildcats three days later.