Plot
College senior Danielle and her sugar daddy Max have sex before she hurries to a shiva observance with her parents, Joel and Debbie. Before the shiva, at her aunt Sheila's house, Danielle is schooled by her mother on how to respond to questions about her disorganized life and reveals that Dani's ex-girlfriend Maya will be there. Within the house, members of the local extended Jewish community compare her to Maya, who is adored by the neighbors and heading to law school. She has trouble eating the food there and goes from piling it on her plate to scraping it off.
Max, who is a former colleague of Joel's, arrives, and Debbie insists on introducing him to Danielle in the hopes that one of Max's relatives will hire her. After the conversation, Debbie warns Dani that he's off limits because Max is married to a non-Jewish woman named Kim. Because of their baby-sitter's last minute cancellation, Kim arrives late to the gathering with their baby Rose.
Dani accidentally hurts her leg and retreats to the bathroom to clean it, where she takes a topless photo and sends it to Max. However downstairs, she is unable to look away from Max and his family, and offers to clean vomit from an adjacent room in order to escape. Maya comes to help and begins flirting with Dani, who rebukes her advances. Debbie pulls her away and reprimands her for flirting with Maya.
Debbie drags Dani to meet Kim and asks her for a job on Dani's behalf. During the conversation, it is revealed that Dani has been getting deposits once a month and telling her parents it is from baby-sitting. It is also revealed that Kim is the breadwinner of the family and therefore unknowingly funding Max's arrangement with Danielle. Kim grows suspicious when she notices Danielle wearing the same expensive bracelet that Max had given to her. Max suddenly receives all the photos that Dani sent, and ends up dropping his phone, then spilling coffee on Danielle. Her mom takes her to wash off and calm her nerves.
Maya later finds her at the food table, but Max interrupts the two; annoyed, Maya loudly reveals details of her and Danielle's past relationship, including when two went to prom together and were intimate together afterwards. Maya gets called away, and Max asks for reassurance that everything is "good" and Dani says yes. Later in the day, Max separates from his wife to go to the bathroom upstairs. Dani follows him into the bathroom and positions herself to fellate him, but he decides against it and leaves.
Upset, Danielle goes outside, finding Maya smoking by the side of the house. The two admit that they miss each other and passionately kiss. Dani finally can eat again, and goes to join Max and Kim, having a measured conversation in which she asks probing questions about Kim and Max's relationship and hints that Max uses the couple's vacant SoHo apartment as a bachelor pad. Elsewhere, Maya finds Danielle's phone in the bathroom and reads notifications from the sugar baby app. Dani realizes her phone is missing, and runs to Maya for help finding it, who is back downstairs by the food table. Angry, Maya taunts Danielle about her lifestyle and tells her that her phone is unlocked somewhere in the house, sending her into a panic so all she can focus on are people shoving food into their mouths.
The guests then gather to say Kaddish, with Rose screaming until Kim takes her away. Max follows Danielle into the kitchen afterwards, where she replies that ending the relationship is good so that Kim won't lose all her money. Kim then appears and tells Max they should go home.
Kim approaches Dani to return her phone, and forces her to hold Rose, insisting she must be able to as a baby-sitter. Max arrives and tries to take the baby from Dani against Kim's demands, which knocks her back and causes a vase and some sacred books to the floor. Danielle attempts to clean up the mess but has a breakdown on the floor in front of the guests and is comforted by her mother and Maya. Debbie suggests they use helping an elderly attendee to her car as an excuse to leave, and Maya and Danielle reconnect as they carry food outside. Kim, Max, Maya, and Maya's mom are persuaded to ride home in Joel's now overpacked van, with Rose shrieking as Joel struggles to find his keys. Maya and Danielle affectionately hold hands in the back and smile at each other.
