Thicker than Water

Thicker than Water is a 2005 American made-for-television drama film starring Melissa Gilbert and Lindsay Wagner. It premiered on Hallmark Channel on March 12, 2005. Plot summary After the death of her father, Natalie Travers discovers he was married to a rodeo star before he married Natalie's mother. Upset that her father kept part of his life a secret from her and bewildered over how a prominent judge could fall for a cowgirl, she sets out to find Maggie Mae Jarrett. But Natalie meets Maggie's daughter Jessie Mae Jarrett, who is struggling to keep the wild horses on her land alive and safe. Cast Melissa Gilbert as Natalie Travers Lindsay Wagner as Jess Jarrett Brian Wimmer as Sam Nelson Lindy Newton as Lulu Nichols Robert Mailhouse as Larry Gorman Grainger Hines as Tom Grove Nan Martin as Abygail Jordan Sondra Currie as Sally References