Judicial data via CourtListener (Free Law Project). Social links via Wikidata.
Affiliations
District Court, D. Massachusetts — appointed by William Jefferson Clinton
Party: Democratic →B.A., Barnard CollegeM.A., Yale UniversityJ.D., Yale University
Decision levers
AI-measured from their own opinions — each lever cites its cases
Living constitutionalismOriginalism
In cases such as United States v. Janvier and Drumgold v. Callahan, the court applied Fourth and Fifth Amendment precedents to constrain police investigations, and in Chao v. Ballista it extended Eighth Amendment standards to prison sexual abuse, favoring expansive individual-lib United States v. Janvier ↗ Drumgold v. Callahan ↗ Chao v. Ballista ↗ Chao v. Ballista ↗
The court applied Terry v. Ohio without modification in United States v. Janvier, Brady principles in Drumgold v. Callahan, and the ACCA framework in United States v. Oliveira, demonstrating consistent adherence to established case law. Drumgold v. Callahan ↗ United States v. Janvier ↗ United States v. Oliveira ↗
Deference to government powerSkepticism of government power
The case concerned Shawn Drumgold's civil rights lawsuit against Boston police detective Timothy Callahan under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging that Callahan withheld exculpatory evidence about cash, meals, and housing provided to a key prosecution witness, contributing to Drumgold's wrongful murder conviction and 14 years of imprisonment. A jury in the second trial found that Callahan had intentionally or recklessly withheld material evidence regarding the witness benefits, that this caused the conviction, and awarded Drumgold $14 million in damages. In ruling on post-trial motions, the court denied judgment as a matter of law, holding that the evidence was material under Brady v. Maryland in light of the witness's circumstances and the jury's findings, that qualified immunity did not apply, and that the trial scope and instructions were proper.
This case involved a former inmate, Cristina Chao, who sued a prison guard, Moisés Ballista, and supervisory officials at the South Middlesex Correctional Center after engaging in repeated sexual encounters with the guard over more than a year while incarcerated. Chao brought claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 alleging Eighth Amendment violations for failure to protect, along with state claims including intentional infliction of emotional distress under the Massachusetts Civil Rights Act. After a jury trial, the jury found Ballista liable on multiple claims and Superintendent Kelly Ryan liable for the Eighth Amendment violation, awarding damages, while finding Commissioner Dennehy not liable. The court denied the defendants' renewed motions for judgment as a matter of law or a new trial, concluding that the evidence supported findings of sufficiently serious harm and deliberate indifference by the officials, and that qualified immunity did not apply because the right to protection from sexual abuse by guards was clearly established.
In United States v. Janvier, the defendant moved to suppress a firearm and ammunition seized after police conducted a Terry stop based on an anonymous 911 call reporting a man with a gun on Gleason Street in Boston. The court granted the motion to suppress. The core reasoning was that the caller's description did not match Janvier in significant respects including weight and clothing, the reported location spanned multiple addresses rather than pinpointing his home, and his act of turning to enter his residence upon seeing the police provided no additional basis for reasonable suspicion under Terry v. Ohio.
The case involved the sentencing of Anthony Oliveira, who pled guilty to being a felon in possession of a firearm under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1). The court addressed whether Oliveira qualified for a mandatory minimum sentence under the Armed Career Criminal Act based on prior convictions including larceny from a person and assault and battery, whether uncharged gun and drug transactions should be considered as relevant conduct under the Sentencing Guidelines, and the impact of imperfect entrapment by a government informant. The court determined that the ACCA did not apply because Massachusetts larceny from a person is a stealth crime without the requisite violence or risk of injury to qualify as a predicate offense. It further held that the uncharged conduct must be evaluated under the preponderance standard but would be assessed in light of the informant's role in encouraging the transactions, resulting in a sentence of 100 months' imprisonment.
In Chao v. Ballista, an inmate brought a 42 U.S.C. § 1983 action against a prison guard and supervisory officials, claiming the guard violated her Eighth Amendment rights through a year-long sexual relationship during her incarceration and that the officials failed to protect her from this harm. The defendants moved for summary judgment, contending there was no objectively serious harm because the encounters were consensual and that they were not deliberately indifferent to any risk. The court denied the motions, holding that the power imbalance between inmates and guards raises factual questions about consent and coercion that cannot be resolved on summary judgment, and that whether the relationship caused constitutionally cognizable harm or whether each defendant was sufficiently aware of the risk are matters for trial.
The case concerns whether a debt from an unliquidated personal injury claim arising from a domestic assault by Alex Hermosilla against his former spouse Cristina is exempt from discharge in Alex's Chapter 7 bankruptcy under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(6). The Bankruptcy Court held that the claim was nondischargeable, and Alex appealed, raising arguments about jurisdiction, the statute of limitations, waiver via divorce stipulation, res judicata, and disputed facts precluding summary judgment. The District Court dismissed the appeal as procedurally barred for failure to comply with the timely filing requirements of Bankruptcy Rule 8009, granted sanctions for the frivolous appeal, and addressed the merits in connection with the sanctions motion, rejecting Alex's substantive claims including tolling under the Bankruptcy Code.