Judicial data via CourtListener (Free Law Project). Social links via Wikidata.
Born 1946 · New York, NY
Drumgold v. Callahan
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2011-08-24 · cited 5×
The case concerned Shawn Drumgold's civil rights lawsuit against Boston police detective Timothy Callahan under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging that Callahan withheld exculpatory evidence about cash, meals, and housing provided to a key prosecution witness, contributing to Drumgold's wrongful murder conviction and 14 years of imprisonment. A jury in the second trial found that Callahan had intentionally or recklessly withheld material evidence regarding the witness benefits, that this caused the conviction, and awarded Drumgold $14 million in damages. In ruling on post-trial motions, the court denied judgment as a matter of law, holding that the evidence was material under Brady v. Maryland in light of the witness's circumstances and the jury's findings, that qualified immunity did not apply, and that the trial scope and instructions were proper.
criminal lawcivil rightsprocedure
Chao v. Ballista
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2011-07-28 · cited 6×
This case involved a former inmate, Cristina Chao, who sued a prison guard, Moisés Ballista, and supervisory officials at the South Middlesex Correctional Center after engaging in repeated sexual encounters with the guard over more than a year while incarcerated. Chao brought claims under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 alleging Eighth Amendment violations for failure to protect, along with state claims including intentional infliction of emotional distress under the Massachusetts Civil Rights Act. After a jury trial, the jury found Ballista liable on multiple claims and Superintendent Kelly Ryan liable for the Eighth Amendment violation, awarding damages, while finding Commissioner Dennehy not liable. The court denied the defendants' renewed motions for judgment as a matter of law or a new trial, concluding that the evidence supported findings of sufficiently serious harm and deliberate indifference by the officials, and that qualified immunity did not apply because the right to protection from sexual abuse by guards was clearly established.
civil rightsproceduretorts & liability
United States v. Janvier
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2011-07-26
In United States v. Janvier, the defendant moved to suppress a firearm and ammunition seized after police conducted a Terry stop based on an anonymous 911 call reporting a man with a gun on Gleason Street in Boston. The court granted the motion to suppress. The core reasoning was that the caller's description did not match Janvier in significant respects including weight and clothing, the reported location spanned multiple addresses rather than pinpointing his home, and his act of turning to enter his residence upon seeing the police provided no additional basis for reasonable suspicion under Terry v. Ohio.
criminal lawgunscivil rights
United States v. Oliveira
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2011-07-21 · cited 1×
The case involved the sentencing of Anthony Oliveira, who pled guilty to being a felon in possession of a firearm under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1). The court addressed whether Oliveira qualified for a mandatory minimum sentence under the Armed Career Criminal Act based on prior convictions including larceny from a person and assault and battery, whether uncharged gun and drug transactions should be considered as relevant conduct under the Sentencing Guidelines, and the impact of imperfect entrapment by a government informant. The court determined that the ACCA did not apply because Massachusetts larceny from a person is a stealth crime without the requisite violence or risk of injury to qualify as a predicate offense. It further held that the uncharged conduct must be evaluated under the preponderance standard but would be assessed in light of the informant's role in encouraging the transactions, resulting in a sentence of 100 months' imprisonment.
gunscriminal law
Chao v. Ballista
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2011-03-25 · cited 18×
In Chao v. Ballista, an inmate brought a 42 U.S.C. § 1983 action against a prison guard and supervisory officials, claiming the guard violated her Eighth Amendment rights through a year-long sexual relationship during her incarceration and that the officials failed to protect her from this harm. The defendants moved for summary judgment, contending there was no objectively serious harm because the encounters were consensual and that they were not deliberately indifferent to any risk. The court denied the motions, holding that the power imbalance between inmates and guards raises factual questions about consent and coercion that cannot be resolved on summary judgment, and that whether the relationship caused constitutionally cognizable harm or whether each defendant was sufficiently aware of the risk are matters for trial.
civil rightsprocedure
Hermosilla v. Hermosilla
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2011-03-21 · cited 5×
The case concerns whether a debt from an unliquidated personal injury claim arising from a domestic assault by Alex Hermosilla against his former spouse Cristina is exempt from discharge in Alex's Chapter 7 bankruptcy under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(6). The Bankruptcy Court held that the claim was nondischargeable, and Alex appealed, raising arguments about jurisdiction, the statute of limitations, waiver via divorce stipulation, res judicata, and disputed facts precluding summary judgment. The District Court dismissed the appeal as procedurally barred for failure to comply with the timely filing requirements of Bankruptcy Rule 8009, granted sanctions for the frivolous appeal, and addressed the merits in connection with the sanctions motion, rejecting Alex's substantive claims including tolling under the Bankruptcy Code.
family lawtorts & liabilityprocedurecriminal law
Rosa v. Astrue
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2011-03-08 · cited 2×
Maria Rosa appealed the denial of her Social Security disability benefits by an ALJ, claiming the ALJ improperly disregarded opinions from her treating physicians and that the credibility assessment lacked substantial evidence, resulting in a flawed residual functional capacity determination. The court found that the ALJ violated 20 C.F.R. § 404.1527 by failing to give appropriate weight to the treating physicians' opinions, which skewed the evaluation of the record. Consequently, the court reversed the ALJ's decision denying benefits and remanded the case for further proceedings consistent with the opinion.
federal powerhealthcare
Resendes v. Astrue
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2011-02-17 · cited 13×
The case involved plaintiff Lesbelia Resendes appealing the Social Security Administration's denial of her application for Disability Insurance benefits, claiming errors in the ALJ's determination that her mental impairments were not severe and in the assessment of her residual functional capacity. The court agreed with these arguments, finding that the ALJ's conclusions lacked support from the medical record, particularly regarding the relevant time period before her date last insured, and did not adequately address her credibility or the impact of her headaches. As a result, the court granted the plaintiff's motion to reverse the decision, denied the defendant's motion to affirm, and remanded the case for further proceedings to properly evaluate her claim.
labor & employment
Trenwick America Reinsurance Corp. v. Irc, Inc.
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2011-02-16 · cited 8×
The case centered on whether IRC Re had entered into a retrocessional reinsurance contract with Trenwick covering a portion of the risk under the Reliance Compcare 2000 workers' compensation insurance program administered by related Swasey-controlled entities, and whether defendants breached that contract or engaged in fraud or unfair practices by denying its existence. The court found that an enforceable contract existed, as shown by overwhelming evidence including admissions, conduct, and documents, and that IRC Re and Swasey had breached it by refusing to pay their share of liabilities. It applied the "follow the fortunes" doctrine from reinsurance custom, ruled that the statute of frauds was satisfied and arbitration rights waived, held certain defendants liable under Massachusetts Chapter 93A for bad-faith denial of the contract, and pierced the corporate veil to impose liability on Swasey individually, while finding insufficient evidence to support fraud or negligent misrepresentation claims against all defendants.
business & regulatorytorts & liability
VIP MORTGAGE CORPORATION v. Bank of America
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2011-02-11 · cited 2×
VIP Mortgage sued TD Bank (successor to Hudson United Bank) after its former branch manager, Mark Rhodes, opened a sole proprietorship account in the name of VIP Mortgage without proper documentation and deposited over $377,000 in checks payable to VIP into that account between 2005 and 2006. VIP brought claims for common-law and UCC negligence, conversion, civil conspiracy, and CUTPA violations, alleging the bank failed to investigate or notify VIP despite an internal security report flagging Rhodes for similar fraud. On cross-motions for summary judgment, the court granted the bank's motion in part and denied it in part, while denying VIP's motion entirely; it held that the bank owed no duty to non-customer VIP under common-law negligence or conversion theories, that UCC claims were governed by Conn. Gen. Stat. § 42a-3-405 with comparative-fault principles, and that the bank's conduct did not rise to a CUTPA violation. The court noted VIP retained a partial remedy under the UCC for the bank's failure to exercise ordinary care.
business & regulatorytorts & liabilityprocedurecriminal law
Diaz v. JITEN HOTEL MANAGEMENT, INC.
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2011-01-20 · cited 9×
In Diaz v. Jiten Hotel Management, Inc., the plaintiff, a longtime head housekeeper, sued her employer under the federal Age Discrimination in Employment Act and Massachusetts law, alleging a hostile work environment, disparate treatment, and intentional infliction of emotional distress based on repeated ageist comments by her manager, denial of performance reviews and raises after twenty-two years, and her termination. The defendant moved for summary judgment, contending that the claims were time-barred because the manager transferred more than 300 days before the EEOC and MCAD complaints and that his remarks were stray comments that did not establish discriminatory animus or affect the broader workplace. The court denied the motion, holding that discrimination involves inferences from context, relationships, and cumulative evidence that are ill-suited to summary resolution, that the manager's comments helped create an atmosphere of bias whose effects continued after his departure, and that the stray-remarks doctrine does not warrant dismissing the claims as a matter of law.
civil rightslabor & employment
United States v. Whigham
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2010-12-03 · cited 6×
This case involved the sentencing of Kenneth Whigham, who was charged with distributing a total of 4.75 grams of crack cocaine on three occasions near a public housing project in Boston, with relevant conduct bringing the total to 10.25 grams; he was a low-level street dealer with mental deficits and no other means of support. The U.S. Sentencing Guidelines called for a range of 188-235 months due to factors including career offender status and crack cocaine quantity calculations, but the government recommended 114 months while the defendant sought time served of nearly four years. The court imposed a sentence of 60 months imprisonment followed by six years of supervised release. The reasoning centered on the advisory nature of the Guidelines after United States v. Booker, the need to consider the defendant's individual background and role in the offense under 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a), comparisons to sentences in similar cases from the same investigation, and the Guidelines' overemphasis on quantity and other factors that produced excessive ranges for minor participants.
criminal law
United States v. Hebshie
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2010-11-15 · cited 11×
In United States v. Hebshie, petitioner James Hebshie was convicted of arson and mail fraud after a 2001 fire at a commercial building where he operated a convenience store; he sought to vacate the conviction under 28 U.S.C. § 2255 on grounds of ineffective assistance of trial counsel. The court granted the motion after finding that counsel's performance was constitutionally deficient for failing to request Daubert hearings on the government's cause-and-origin expert, accelerant-detection canine handler, and laboratory technician, as well as failing to adequately challenge their testimony on burn patterns, thermal imaging, and accelerant detection. This deficiency prejudiced Hebshie because there was a reasonable probability that the evidence would have been excluded or limited, undermining confidence in the verdict given the weaknesses in the arson proof and the government's reliance on it to establish that the fire was intentionally set. The decision rests on application of Strickland v. Washington standards for ineffective assistance alongside Daubert requirements for scientific and technical expert testimony.
criminal lawprocedure
Sony BMG Music Entertainment v. Tenenbaum
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2010-07-09 · cited 5×
This case involved a copyright infringement lawsuit brought by major recording companies against Joel Tenenbaum for using file-sharing software to download and distribute thirty copyrighted songs. After a jury found the infringements willful and awarded $675,000 in statutory damages, Tenenbaum moved for a new trial or remittitur, raising common-law and constitutional challenges to the award. The court concluded that it had to address the Due Process Clause claim because the plaintiffs indicated they would reject any remitted amount, forcing a retrial that would revisit the same issues. Applying standards from punitive damages jurisprudence including the BMW guideposts, the court held that the award violated due process as it was grossly excessive in relation to the minimal harm to plaintiffs and any benefit to the defendant.
civil rightsprocedureproperty
LOMBARD MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES, INC. v. Johannessen
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2010-07-02 · cited 21×
Lombard Medical Technologies sued its former employees Nils Johannessen and Thomas Sassler, seeking a preliminary injunction to bar them from working for competitor TriVascular in violation of their non-competition agreements signed at the start of employment. The employees had worked as Investigational Site Specialists handling confidential clinical trial data, marketing plans, and medical center relationships for Lombard's Aorfix stent graft product before resigning to take similar clinical trial roles at TriVascular. The court granted the motion in part, finding a likelihood of success on the breach of contract claim because the agreements were valid and enforceable for six months in the restricted region. It also determined that irreparable harm was likely due to the inevitable disclosure of Lombard's trade secrets and competitive information given the similarity of the positions and products. The balance of hardships and public interest in enforcing contracts further supported limited injunctive relief against the two employees.
labor & employmentbusiness & regulatory
Advanced Ion Beam Technology, Inc. v. Varian Semiconductor Equipment Associates, Inc.
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2010-07-02 · cited 2×
In this case, Advanced Ion Beam Technology (AIBT) sued Varian Semiconductor Equipment Associates and related parties under the Sherman Act, alleging that Varian attempted to monopolize the ion implantation equipment market by filing a baseless patent infringement suit based on U.S. Patent No. 7,301,156, which AIBT claimed Varian knew was invalid and unenforceable due to fraud on the PTO. The magistrate judge's report and recommendation addressed Varian's motion to dismiss AIBT's antitrust claims for monopolization, attempted monopolization, and conspiracy to monopolize, which were based on Walker Process and sham litigation theories. The court recommended granting the motion in part by dismissing with prejudice the claims based on certain alleged misrepresentations to the PTO (regarding Patent No. 3,541,328 and a Panofsky article) and the conspiracy claim, for failure to adequately plead fraud or antitrust injury. It recommended denying the motion as to the remaining fraud allegations involving non-disclosure of a White publication, the Ionex Quad Magnet, a sales offer, and inventorship issues, finding those sufficient to state a claim. The core reasoning focused on the particularity requirements for pleading fraud on the PTO and whether the allegations supported antitrust standing and injury.
business & regulatoryprocedure
Coscia v. Town of Pembroke, Mass.
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2010-06-04 · cited 2×
The case concerned the estate of Jason Coscia, who was arrested after a car accident, made multiple suicide threats while in police custody in Pembroke, Massachusetts, and was released without medical evaluation despite officers' recognition of a very high suicide risk; he died by suicide the next morning. The estate sued individual officers, supervisors, and the town under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging deliberate indifference to Coscia's serious medical needs in violation of due process, along with failures in training and supervision. The court denied the defendants' motion for judgment on the pleadings, holding that the claims were plausible even though the suicide occurred outside custody because the key issue is whether the officers' alleged deliberate indifference caused the death. The court reasoned that qualified immunity did not apply at this stage and that the pleadings sufficiently supported claims against supervisors and the municipality.
civil rightscriminal law
Doe Ex Rel. Doe v. Hampden-Wilbraham Regional School District
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2010-05-25 · cited 4×
This case involved parents appealing a 2008 Bureau of Special Education Appeals decision that found the Hampden-Wilbraham Regional School District had provided adequate special education services to their child Joseph under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act from 2005 to 2008. The plaintiffs argued that the hearing officer overlooked key legal arguments and evidence, and they sought to overturn the agency ruling in federal district court. The court applied an intermediate standard of review, giving due weight to the administrative findings while assessing whether the district had offered a free appropriate public education through individualized education programs. After examining the record, the court concluded that the plaintiffs had not met their burden to demonstrate that the agency's decision was unsupported or erroneous. It therefore ruled in favor of the school district and the Bureau of Special Education Appeals, upholding the original determination that the IEPs were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
civil rights
United States v. Watt
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2010-04-27 · cited 5×
This case involves the sentencing of Stephen Watt, who pled guilty to conspiracy under 18 U.S.C. § 371 for adapting a sniffer program used in what was described as the largest identity theft conspiracy in U.S. history, enabling the theft of over 40 million credit and debit card numbers from retailers like TJX, resulting in $171.5 million in losses. The court sentenced Watt, a first-time offender, to 24 months of custody, three years of supervised release, and restitution of $171.5 million, rejecting both probation and the five-year maximum requested by the parties. The Guidelines range would have been life imprisonment absent the statutory maximum, but the court found them unhelpful and instead balanced the offense's extraordinary scope and sophistication against Watt's lack of financial gain, thrill-seeking motive, supportive family, and compliance with release conditions. The reasoning emphasized the need to avoid unwarranted sentencing disparities and to account for the massive harm to victims while recognizing Watt's limited role in the broader conspiracy.
criminal law
Herbert v. Dickhaut
District Court, D. Massachusetts · 2010-03-19 · cited 4×
This case involves Roger Herbert's federal habeas corpus petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2254 challenging his 1991 Massachusetts convictions for armed robbery and felony murder. The sole issue addressed is the timeliness of the petition under AEDPA's one-year statute of limitations in 28 U.S.C. § 2244(d), which turns on whether Herbert's 1996 motion for a new trial tolled the clock. The court held the petition timely and denied the motion to dismiss, applying Massachusetts' prisoner mailbox rule to deem the motion filed on the date it was mailed from prison in December 1996 rather than when received or docketed. It further found that subsequent state post-conviction proceedings remained pending for tolling purposes until December 2005, resulting in fewer than 263 non-tolled days overall.
criminal lawprocedurefederal power