Judicial data via CourtListener (Free Law Project). Social links via Wikidata.
Born 1913 · Boston, MA
Timken Co. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1987-10-29 · cited 85×
In Timken Co. v. United States, an American manufacturer challenged the International Trade Administration's (ITA) initial revocation of a dumping finding on tapered roller bearings imported from Japan by NTN. After multiple remands, the ITA calculated dumping margins of 7.79 percent and rescinded the revocation, but the parties identified errors in the agency's use of 'best information available' for missing home market and cost data, model comparisons, and other calculations. The court held that another remand to the ITA was required to correct these methodological and computational issues, including proper selection of contemporaneous data and verification of information used for margins across the review period from 1978 to 1981.
business & regulatoryprocedure
Zenith Radio Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1986-08-08 · cited 3×
The case involved Zenith Radio Corp. challenging a 1980 settlement agreement by the U.S. government that resolved claims for antidumping duties on Japanese television sets imported between 1973 and 1979 for $77 million. Zenith obtained a preliminary injunction blocking the settlement and posted a $250,000 bond as security under court rules. After an appellate ruling that the trial court lacked jurisdiction, the injunction was dissolved, prompting the government to seek damages on the bond for alleged losses from the delay. The court denied the government's motion, holding that under Rule 65(c) damages on an injunction bond are not automatically awarded and that equitable factors, including the non-frivolous nature of Zenith's claims and a subsequent change in jurisdiction law, supported denying recovery.
business & regulatoryprocedure
Timken Co. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1986-02-20 · cited 112×
The case involved a challenge by The Timken Company, a U.S. manufacturer of tapered roller bearings, to the International Trade Administration's (ITA) decision to revoke a 1976 dumping finding against imports from NTN Toyo Bearing Company. The court remanded the matter to the ITA for further proceedings, requiring the collection of additional data on sales up to the date of the tentative determination, complete home market sales data, review of production costs, correction of errors in deductions for expenses like advertising and freight, and recalculation of dumping margins. The reasoning centered on the agency's failure to gather necessary information as required by law and regulations, including issues under the Trade Agreements Act of 1979, and the need to ensure accurate assessment before revocation.
business & regulatoryprocedure
American Spring Wire Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1984-07-11 · cited 121×
The case involved domestic producers of prestressed concrete steel wire strand challenging four final negative injury determinations by the U.S. International Trade Commission regarding imports from Spain, France, the United Kingdom, and Brazil. The ITC had found no material injury or threat of material injury to the U.S. industry, despite affirmative findings by the Department of Commerce that the imports were subsidized or sold at less than fair value. The court reviewed the ITC determinations under the substantial evidence standard and sustained them, concluding that the agency's analysis of economic factors such as industry output, sales, profits, and capacity utilization was rationally connected to its findings and supported by the record. The court noted that an affirmative injury determination requires both material injury and causation by the subject imports, and the absence of the former was dispositive.
business & regulatory
Zenith Radio Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1984-06-29 · cited 3×
This case concerns Zenith Radio Corporation's opposition to the U.S. government's motion for assessment of damages on a $250,000 bond tied to a dissolved preliminary injunction in an antidumping duty proceeding involving Japanese television imports, where Zenith sought discovery to support defenses including failure to mitigate. The government resisted by asserting executive, attorney-client, and work-product privileges over certain documents and interrogatory responses and cross-moved for a protective order. The court rejected the automatic waiver rule urged by Zenith and instead applied a balancing test that weighs the policies underlying the asserted privileges against the opposing party's need for the information. It granted the motions in part by ordering production of pre-July 29, 1983 documents and responses to related interrogatories under protective orders while denying discovery of post-decision work-product materials and upholding privileges for other items.
procedurebusiness & regulatory
Freeport Minerals Co. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1984-06-14 · cited 3×
The case involved a challenge by Freeport Minerals Company, a domestic producer of elemental sulphur, to the International Trade Administration's (ITA) 1982 revocation of an antidumping finding against two Canadian producers, Shell Canada Resources Limited and Canadian Superior Oil, Ltd., under section 751 of the Trade Agreements Act of 1979. Freeport argued that the ITA's review was flawed because it failed to collect sales data up to a time reasonably close to the revocation, did not properly find no sales at less than fair value with no likelihood of resumption, improperly shifted the burden of proof, and mishandled dumping comparisons for a 1973 long-term sales contract. The government defended the ITA's tentative and final revocation determinations, which were based on findings of no sales at less than fair value for periods ending in 1979 along with agreements for reinstatement if needed. The court denied Freeport's motion for review and granted the government's cross-motion, holding that the administrative record supported the ITA's conclusions under the applicable regulations and statutes.
business & regulatory
Gilmore Steel Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1984-04-23 · cited 39×
In Gilmore Steel Corp. v. United States, the plaintiff challenged the Department of Commerce's rescission of a notice initiating an antidumping investigation and its dismissal of the company's petition alleging less-than-fair-value sales of steel plate from Belgium and West Germany. The court interpreted the statutory requirement that a petition be filed "on behalf of an industry" to mean that the petitioner must act in a representative capacity, which could encompass either a national or regional industry under the Tariff Act. It held that the ITA had authority to dismiss the petition after the 20-day sufficiency review period for the national industry claim but erred in dismissing the alternative regional industry claim, and it found any ex parte communications harmless. The court therefore affirmed the ITA's determination in part, reversed it in part, and remanded for further proceedings.
business & regulatory
Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1984-04-10 · cited 34×
This case involves the proper tariff classification of cab chassis imported by Toyota from Japan between 1980 and 1981. The U.S. Customs Service classified these imports as unfinished automobile trucks under TSUS item 692.02, subjecting them to a 26% ad valorem duty. Toyota argued for classification as automobile truck chassis under item 692.20 at 4% or as other motor vehicles under item 692.10 at 2.8%. The court upheld Customs' classification, reasoning that the cab chassis were substantially complete vehicles that, in the vast majority of cases, were finished into pickup trucks, making them unfinished trucks under the applicable tariff rules and interpretive principles from prior case law.
business & regulatory
Diversified Products Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1984-02-29 · cited 7×
The case concerned a challenge by Diversified Products Corp. to the timing of refunds for overpaid estimated antidumping duties on bicycle speedometers imported from Japan. After an initial administrative review by the International Trade Administration (ITA) under section 751 of the Tariff Act, the dumping margin was recalculated downward from 25.98% to 20.04%, but Customs retained the difference pending liquidation of the entries. The court held that Diversified was not entitled to an immediate refund of the 5.94% difference and must wait until the next annual section 751 review and subsequent liquidation. The core reasoning rested on the plain language of 19 U.S.C. §§ 1673f(b), 1675, and 1520(a), which tie refunds or additional collections to the determination and assessment of actual duties at liquidation rather than to interim recalculations of estimated duties.
business & regulatoryprocedure
Schott Optical Glass, Inc. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1984-02-02 · cited 9×
The case concerned the proper tariff classification under the Tariff Schedules of the United States of seven types of imported filter glass, which the government had classified as other optical glass under item 540.67. Plaintiff Schott Optical Glass argued that six types should instead fall under item 542.92 as colored or special glass and one under item 542.42 as ordinary glass. Relying on its prior decision in Schott I, which defined optical glass as very high quality glass used for optical instruments and capable of performing an optical function, the court held that the importations were correctly classified by the government. The court applied stare decisis and rejected the plaintiff's renewed arguments that the prior definition of optical glass was too broad or erroneous, noting those contentions had already been considered and dismissed in Schott I.
business & regulatory
American Spring Wire Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1984-01-19 · cited 27×
This case involves American steel wire strand producers challenging the U.S. International Trade Commission's negative injury determinations regarding subsidized or dumped imports from Brazil, France, Spain, and the United Kingdom. The plaintiffs sought a preliminary injunction to halt the liquidation of import entries while their challenge was pending. The court denied the motion, finding that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate immediate and irreparable injury, as they provided no supporting evidence and their reliance on a prior case was misplaced due to differences in the statutory context. The court reasoned that unlike section 751 reviews, liquidation here would not moot judicial review of the final determinations.
business & regulatoryprocedure
Stewart-Warner Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1983-12-16 · cited 2×
This case concerns a challenge by American manufacturer Stewart-Warner to the U.S. Customs Service's classification of imported double-gear hub drive speedometers, primarily used on stationary exercise cycles, as 'other' speedometers under TSUS item 711.98 rather than as bicycle speedometers under item 711.93. The court held that the merchandise must be reclassified under the bicycle speedometers provision, which carries a higher duty rate. The decision rested on the legislative history of the 1965 Tariff Schedules Technical Amendments Act, which added the specific bicycle speedometer provision to close a duty loophole for bicycle-type speedometers and encompassed devices suitable for bicycles even if chiefly used elsewhere. The court found it unnecessary to resolve whether the provision was a use or eo nomine classification given Congress's clear intent.
business & regulatory
Al Tech Speciality Steel Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1983-11-21 · cited 29×
This case involved American specialty steel producers challenging the Department of Commerce's International Trade Administration (ITA) final results from an administrative review under section 751 of the Tariff Act, which examined a 1973 anti-dumping order on stainless steel wire rods from France and found only a de minimis 0.3% dumping margin. The plaintiffs contested the ITA's decisions not to initiate a cost-of-production investigation under section 773(b) and not to verify data submitted by the foreign producers. The court held that the evidence presented by plaintiffs failed to meet the legal threshold of reasonable grounds to suspect below-cost home market sales, applying standards drawn from Terry v. Ohio and related cases emphasizing particularized suspicion based on the totality of circumstances. However, the court ruled that the ITA was required to verify the submitted information during the review process, leading to a partial grant of the plaintiffs' motion, partial grant of the government's cross-motion, and remand to the ITA solely for verification.
business & regulatoryprocedure
Al Tech Specialty Steel Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1983-11-21 · cited 3×
In Al Tech Specialty Steel Corp. v. United States, plaintiffs moved for a preliminary injunction to prevent the liquidation of entries of stainless steel wire rods subject to a 1973 antidumping order, while they challenged the Department of Commerce's section 751 administrative review of that order. The court had already ruled for plaintiffs on one procedural claim regarding the need to verify information submitted by intervenors but could not yet evaluate their ultimate success on the substantive aspects of the review. Finding that liquidation would cause irreparable harm by permanently barring effective judicial review of those entries, as in Zenith Radio Corp. v. United States, the court issued an injunction under the All Writs Act to maintain jurisdiction and the status quo pending further proceedings.
business & regulatoryprocedure
Diversified Products Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1983-09-27 · cited 116×
This case involves a challenge by importer Diversified Products Corp. to the International Trade Administration's (ITA) final results of a section 751 administrative review of a 1972 antidumping finding on bicycle speedometers from Japan, focusing on whether double-gear hub drive speedometers fall within the scope of that finding. The court considered subsidiary claims that transitional rules of the Trade Agreements Act of 1979 barred the review, that the ITA lacked authority to clarify scope, and that Customs Service classifications were binding. The court denied Diversified's motion for judgment on the administrative record and granted the government's cross-motion for affirmance with a partial remand, holding that the ITA properly included the merchandise based on the original Tariff Commission injury investigation records, which defined bicycle speedometers to encompass instruments for bicycles and exercise machines. It reasoned that section 106 of the 1979 Act authorized the review, the ITA has inherent power to interpret the scope of prior findings, and Customs classifications do not control antidumping scope determinations.
business & regulatoryprocedure
American Spring Wire Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1983-08-24 · cited 4×
This case involved U.S. wire manufacturers challenging the legality of a suspension agreement between the Department of Commerce and Brazil that halted a countervailing duty investigation into subsidized imports of prestressed concrete steel wire strand. After the International Trade Commission issued a final negative injury determination, the agreement became void by operation of law under the Tariff Act. The court dismissed the complaint as moot, holding that no live Article III case or controversy remained because any decision on the agreement's validity would be purely advisory and could not impact the parties' current rights. Plaintiffs' claims that the issues were capable of repetition yet evading review were rejected, as suspension agreements are generally long-lasting and subject to judicial review when in effect.
business & regulatoryprocedure
Timken Co. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1983-08-01 · cited 40×
Timken Company moved for rehearing and a preliminary injunction to prevent liquidation of entries of tapered roller bearings pending judicial review of an administrative determination on import duties. The court had previously denied a similar request, but reconsidered after the Federal Circuit's Zenith Radio decision clarified that liquidation constitutes irreparable injury. Addressing procedural arguments, the court held that the motion was timely and not barred by res judicata because it concerned an interlocutory order rather than a final judgment. It then found that Timken met the four Stile criteria, including a substantial likelihood of success on the merits and irreparable harm absent injunctive relief, and granted the preliminary injunction.
business & regulatoryprocedure
American Spring Wire Corp. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1983-06-10 · cited 6×
This case involved a motion by plaintiffs in a countervailing duty proceeding before the Court of International Trade seeking discovery of confidential verification data compiled by the Department of Commerce during its investigation of prestressed concrete steel wire strand imported from South Africa. The court examined the documents in camera and balanced the plaintiffs' need for the information to challenge the agency's subsidy findings against the public interest in safeguarding confidential business data to preserve the government's future ability to obtain such information and to protect foreign manufacturers' competitive positions. It granted the motion in part, ordering disclosure of most requested documents (such as questionnaire responses, verification reports, calculations, and certain invoices and price lists) under a protective order, but denied access to specific customer-related invoices at pages 1655-1658 of the administrative record. The decision applied the framework of 19 U.S.C. § 1516a(b)(2)(B), which authorizes the court to release confidential material under appropriate conditions, and considered precedents weighing relevance, necessity, and potential harm.
business & regulatoryprocedure
Carlisle Tire and Rubber Co. v. United States
United States Court of International Trade · 1983-05-18 · cited 26×
The case concerned whether generally available Korean tax deductions allowing accelerated depreciation of manufacturing equipment constituted a bounty or grant under section 303 of the Tariff Act of 1930, thereby requiring countervailing duties on imported bicycle tires and tubes. Plaintiff Carlisle Tire challenged the ITA's redetermination that two such domestic programs did not trigger duties because the benefits were available to all Korean businesses, while also disputing calculations for export-related reserve funds. The court concluded that the accelerated depreciation benefits under Articles 51-1-1 and 51-1-4 were not countervailable since they were non-preferential and generally available rather than targeted to specific industries. For the export reserve programs, the record lacked sufficient facts on the importer's tax practices to evaluate the ITA's methodology. Accordingly, the plaintiff's supplementary motion for summary judgment was denied and the ITA's cross-motion was granted in part and denied in part.
business & regulatorytaxes
United States v. Murray
United States Court of International Trade · 1983-03-21 · cited 8×
The United States sued defendants Murray, Hopkins, and Ryan under section 592 of the Tariff Act of 1930 to recover the value of imported animal glue, alleging 83 entries with false statements on value and country of origin; Murray had been convicted and Hopkins acquitted in related criminal proceedings under 18 U.S.C. §§ 371 and 542. Defendants moved to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction, defective process, failure to state a claim (including double jeopardy and res judicata), and improper service. The court denied the motion, holding that 28 U.S.C. § 1582 grants exclusive jurisdiction over all section 592 actions regardless of whether they are in rem or in personam and pre- or post-1978 amendments; the summons complied with Court of International Trade rules that do not require a clerk's signature or seal; and civil penalties under section 592 are not barred by prior criminal acquittals or convictions because they are distinct from criminal punishment.
criminal lawbusiness & regulatoryprocedure