The Schott Optical Glass decision applies stare decisis to adhere to a prior definition of optical glass without revisiting it. Schott Optical Glass, Inc. v. Un… ↗
Deference to government powerSkepticism of government power
In Timken Co. v. United States, an American manufacturer challenged the International Trade Administration's (ITA) initial revocation of a dumping finding on tapered roller bearings imported from Japan by NTN. After multiple remands, the ITA calculated dumping margins of 7.79 percent and rescinded the revocation, but the parties identified errors in the agency's use of 'best information available' for missing home market and cost data, model comparisons, and other calculations. The court held that another remand to the ITA was required to correct these methodological and computational issues, including proper selection of contemporaneous data and verification of information used for margins across the review period from 1978 to 1981.
The case involved Zenith Radio Corp. challenging a 1980 settlement agreement by the U.S. government that resolved claims for antidumping duties on Japanese television sets imported between 1973 and 1979 for $77 million. Zenith obtained a preliminary injunction blocking the settlement and posted a $250,000 bond as security under court rules. After an appellate ruling that the trial court lacked jurisdiction, the injunction was dissolved, prompting the government to seek damages on the bond for alleged losses from the delay. The court denied the government's motion, holding that under Rule 65(c) damages on an injunction bond are not automatically awarded and that equitable factors, including the non-frivolous nature of Zenith's claims and a subsequent change in jurisdiction law, supported denying recovery.
The case involved a challenge by The Timken Company, a U.S. manufacturer of tapered roller bearings, to the International Trade Administration's (ITA) decision to revoke a 1976 dumping finding against imports from NTN Toyo Bearing Company. The court remanded the matter to the ITA for further proceedings, requiring the collection of additional data on sales up to the date of the tentative determination, complete home market sales data, review of production costs, correction of errors in deductions for expenses like advertising and freight, and recalculation of dumping margins. The reasoning centered on the agency's failure to gather necessary information as required by law and regulations, including issues under the Trade Agreements Act of 1979, and the need to ensure accurate assessment before revocation.
The case involved domestic producers of prestressed concrete steel wire strand challenging four final negative injury determinations by the U.S. International Trade Commission regarding imports from Spain, France, the United Kingdom, and Brazil. The ITC had found no material injury or threat of material injury to the U.S. industry, despite affirmative findings by the Department of Commerce that the imports were subsidized or sold at less than fair value. The court reviewed the ITC determinations under the substantial evidence standard and sustained them, concluding that the agency's analysis of economic factors such as industry output, sales, profits, and capacity utilization was rationally connected to its findings and supported by the record. The court noted that an affirmative injury determination requires both material injury and causation by the subject imports, and the absence of the former was dispositive.
This case concerns Zenith Radio Corporation's opposition to the U.S. government's motion for assessment of damages on a $250,000 bond tied to a dissolved preliminary injunction in an antidumping duty proceeding involving Japanese television imports, where Zenith sought discovery to support defenses including failure to mitigate. The government resisted by asserting executive, attorney-client, and work-product privileges over certain documents and interrogatory responses and cross-moved for a protective order. The court rejected the automatic waiver rule urged by Zenith and instead applied a balancing test that weighs the policies underlying the asserted privileges against the opposing party's need for the information. It granted the motions in part by ordering production of pre-July 29, 1983 documents and responses to related interrogatories under protective orders while denying discovery of post-decision work-product materials and upholding privileges for other items.
The case involved a challenge by Freeport Minerals Company, a domestic producer of elemental sulphur, to the International Trade Administration's (ITA) 1982 revocation of an antidumping finding against two Canadian producers, Shell Canada Resources Limited and Canadian Superior Oil, Ltd., under section 751 of the Trade Agreements Act of 1979. Freeport argued that the ITA's review was flawed because it failed to collect sales data up to a time reasonably close to the revocation, did not properly find no sales at less than fair value with no likelihood of resumption, improperly shifted the burden of proof, and mishandled dumping comparisons for a 1973 long-term sales contract. The government defended the ITA's tentative and final revocation determinations, which were based on findings of no sales at less than fair value for periods ending in 1979 along with agreements for reinstatement if needed. The court denied Freeport's motion for review and granted the government's cross-motion, holding that the administrative record supported the ITA's conclusions under the applicable regulations and statutes.