Judicial data via CourtListener (Free Law Project). Social links via Wikidata.
Affiliations
Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit — appointed by William Jefferson Clinton
District Court, S.D. New York — appointed by Jimmy Carter
Decision levers
AI-measured from their own opinions — each lever cites its cases
PurposivismTextualism
Repeated emphasis on plain language and plain meaning of statutes such as Navigation Law § 89-b and the ADEA exception leads to interpretations strictly tied to textual wording without resort to broader purpose. Ball v. Interoceanica Corp. ↗ Equal Employment Opportunity Com… ↗
Willing to revisit precedentStrong stare decisis
Careful application of United States v. Barrow to correct a district court's misstep while preserving the precedent's core rule demonstrates respect for binding authority rather than any impulse to revisit it. United States v. Oluwanisola ↗
The case involved Olawale Lateef Oluwanisola's appeal from his conviction after a jury trial on charges of conspiring to import heroin, conspiring to possess heroin with intent to distribute, and possessing heroin with intent to distribute, in violation of federal narcotics statutes. The Second Circuit vacated the conviction and remanded for further proceedings. The court held that the district court misapplied United States v. Barrow when ruling on whether trial evidence would open the door to the defendant's proffer statements, thereby improperly limiting defense counsel's cross-examination and impairing the defendant's Sixth Amendment right to effective assistance. The court separately concluded that the trial evidence was legally sufficient to support the convictions regarding the quantity of heroin involved.
This case involves a dispute over whether vessels traveling through the western portion of Long Island Sound must use pilots licensed by New York or can also use those licensed by Connecticut. New York pilots sued vessel owners for fees after their services were refused in favor of Connecticut pilots, following a 1991 amendment to New York Navigation Law § 89-b. The court held that the amended statute requires New York-licensed pilots for the Western Sound, based on its plain language that drops the allowance for pilots from states with concurrent jurisdiction in that specific area. It further concluded that this requirement does not violate federal law under 46 U.S.C. § 8501, as the Western Sound is not considered boundary waters subject to shared pilotage.
This interpleader action was brought by Continental Coffee Products Co. under 28 U.S.C. § 1335 after a shipment of coffee from Bozzo Commerce de Cafe, when multiple secured creditors asserted claims to the sale proceeds before payment was made. Continental deposited the full amount due with the court to obtain a determination of the proper distribution among the claimants. The court evaluates the competing security interests under the New York Uniform Commercial Code, examining whether they attached through a signed security agreement describing the collateral, value given, and the debtor's rights in the goods or accounts receivable, and whether they were perfected under applicable choice-of-law rules. It applies these standards to specific contracts and defendants' motions for summary judgment to decide priority among the claims.
The EEOC sued New York State under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act to challenge a 1990 amendment to state civil service law that extended an age-29 hiring cutoff for police officers to the new category of park patrol officers, thereby excluding applicants over age 40. The court examined the ADEA's narrow exception in 29 U.S.C. § 623(j), which preserves only those age limits for firefighters or law enforcement officers that were already in effect under state law on March 3, 1983. Because park patrol positions were not covered by any such age restriction in 1983, the court held that the 1990 expansion fell outside the statutory safe harbor and violated the ADEA. It relied on the plain language of the exception and persuasive precedent from Roche v. Chicago and Gately v. Massachusetts, which rejected similar attempts to broaden the class of employees subject to pre-1983 age rules. The case was submitted on a written record for a determination of liability.
The case involved a permanent resident alien serving a state prison sentence who challenged an INS order to show cause and arrest warrant issued after his controlled substance conviction, seeking declaratory and injunctive relief to withdraw the documents and an order compelling the start of deportation proceedings for a custody or bond determination. The court granted the INS's motion to dismiss, holding that the plaintiff failed to show any abuse of discretion in issuing the order and warrant, that the INS bore no responsibility for the detainer's impact on his state work-release eligibility, and that the cited regulation did not entitle him to compel proceedings or a custody hearing. The core reasoning was that deportation defenses must be raised at the hearing itself, the adverse prison consequences stemmed from state decisions rather than INS action, proceedings had already begun, and the plaintiff fell outside the class protected by the regulation because he was not arrested without a warrant and remained in state custody.
Toshiba International Corp. sued ocean carrier Sea-Land Service and rail carrier Burlington Northern Railroad for approximately $272,000 in damage to a turbine generator sustained during inland transport in Chicago after ocean shipment from Japan. The court decided that the $500 per package liability limitation in Sea-Land's bill of lading applied to both defendants and capped their exposure. The core reasoning was that the bill of lading's valuation clause, Himalaya clause, and other terms contractually extended COGSA's $500 limitation to the full journey and to third-party inland carriers, and that Toshiba had declined the opportunity to declare a higher value or pay ad valorem rates.