The court applied the strong presumption from M/S Bremen v. Zapata Offshore Co. to enforce a contractual forum-selection clause without hesitation. Houston International Televideo,… ↗
Deference to government powerSkepticism of government power
This case was a wrongful death action under Texas law brought by the widow and parents of William Larsen, a passenger killed in the 1985 crash of Delta Air Lines Flight 191. After Delta stipulated to liability and the case was transferred through multidistrict litigation, the court held a bench trial limited to damages. The court awarded the plaintiffs compensatory damages for pecuniary losses based on the decedent's earnings and benefits, plus amounts for loss of companionship, society, and mental anguish, calculated from evidence of the family's relationships and the decedent's age, education, and career; it denied recovery for pre-impact suffering as too speculative and granted prejudgment interest on past pecuniary losses.
This case involved a former employee suing his employer for age and race discrimination under federal laws including the Age Discrimination in Employment Act and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. The plaintiff claimed he was denied promotions and terminated due to his age and race, while the defendant maintained that its decisions were based solely on performance. After reviewing the evidence, the court found that the plaintiff had been offered promotional opportunities which he declined, received multiple warnings and counseling about declining sales performance, and was placed on corrective action plans before being terminated for failing to meet quotas. The court concluded that the plaintiff failed to prove that the employer's stated reasons were pretextual or that race or age played any role in the decisions. Accordingly, the court entered judgment in favor of the defendant.
In this case, plaintiff Dan P. Vella had been held in civil contempt for failing to answer interrogatories and in criminal contempt for filing a new lawsuit in violation of a prior court order barring further filings until assessed sums were paid. Vella moved to proceed in forma pauperis on appeal and sought a certificate of probable cause. The district court denied both motions, finding that the appeal lacked good faith because the underlying violations were undisputed and Vella's additional arguments, such as lack of jurisdiction due to a flag with yellow fringes, were frivolous and without arguable basis in law or fact.
This case involved a dispute between the League of United Latin American Citizens and the Pasadena Independent School District regarding the district's termination of employees who were undocumented aliens eligible for legalization under the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 but had provided false social security numbers. The court had previously issued a preliminary injunction requiring reinstatement and prohibiting such terminations based on the Act's antidiscrimination provisions. In response to the defendant's motion opposing a permanent injunction, the court deferred its ruling pending the plaintiffs' exhaustion of administrative remedies under the Act, while keeping the preliminary injunction in effect due to ongoing uncertainties in the administrative process established by the Immigration and Nationality Act.
The case involved undocumented workers employed as custodians by the Pasadena Independent School District who were fired in February 1987 for listing invalid social security numbers on their job applications, even though they had been hired before the November 1986 enactment of the Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) and remained eligible for legalization under its grandfather clause. The plaintiffs, represented by LULAC, sued under IRCA’s anti-discrimination provisions, alleging that the terminations constituted unfair immigration-related employment practices with a disparate impact on Hispanics. The court granted a preliminary injunction after finding that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on the merits, that the school district’s automatic-termination policy for application falsification was not justified by business necessity when less drastic alternatives existed, and that the employees posed no safety or performance risk.
This case was a lawsuit by barge owner Valley Line Company against Musgrove Towing Service for money damages after three barges were damaged while moored at the defendant's fleeting facility during Hurricane Alicia in August 1983. The plaintiff alleged negligence in the defendant's preparations and mooring methods. The court ruled for the defendant and dismissed the case with prejudice, finding that the damage was caused by an act of God in the form of an unanticipated severe tidal surge, that the defendant had taken reasonable precautions with no contributory negligence, and that similar damage occurred at other facilities in the area. The decision applied bailment principles but held that the rebuttable presumption of negligence was overcome by evidence of due care.