Judicial data via CourtListener (Free Law Project). Social links via Wikidata.
Born 1942 · St. Paul, MN
Larsen v. Delta Air Lines, Inc.
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1988-07-29 · cited 9×
This case was a wrongful death action under Texas law brought by the widow and parents of William Larsen, a passenger killed in the 1985 crash of Delta Air Lines Flight 191. After Delta stipulated to liability and the case was transferred through multidistrict litigation, the court held a bench trial limited to damages. The court awarded the plaintiffs compensatory damages for pecuniary losses based on the decedent's earnings and benefits, plus amounts for loss of companionship, society, and mental anguish, calculated from evidence of the family's relationships and the decedent's age, education, and career; it denied recovery for pre-impact suffering as too speculative and granted prejudgment interest on past pecuniary losses.
torts & liabilityprocedure
Wood v. Exxon Corp.
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1987-11-23 · cited 3×
This case involved a former employee suing his employer for age and race discrimination under federal laws including the Age Discrimination in Employment Act and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. The plaintiff claimed he was denied promotions and terminated due to his age and race, while the defendant maintained that its decisions were based solely on performance. After reviewing the evidence, the court found that the plaintiff had been offered promotional opportunities which he declined, received multiple warnings and counseling about declining sales performance, and was placed on corrective action plans before being terminated for failing to meet quotas. The court concluded that the plaintiff failed to prove that the employer's stated reasons were pretextual or that race or age played any role in the decisions. Accordingly, the court entered judgment in favor of the defendant.
civil rightslabor & employment
Vella v. McCammon
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1987-09-21 · cited 9×
In this case, plaintiff Dan P. Vella had been held in civil contempt for failing to answer interrogatories and in criminal contempt for filing a new lawsuit in violation of a prior court order barring further filings until assessed sums were paid. Vella moved to proceed in forma pauperis on appeal and sought a certificate of probable cause. The district court denied both motions, finding that the appeal lacked good faith because the underlying violations were undisputed and Vella's additional arguments, such as lack of jurisdiction due to a flag with yellow fringes, were frivolous and without arguable basis in law or fact.
criminal lawprocedure
League of United Latin American Citizens v. Pasadena Independent School District
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1987-07-31 · cited 3×
This case involved a dispute between the League of United Latin American Citizens and the Pasadena Independent School District regarding the district's termination of employees who were undocumented aliens eligible for legalization under the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 but had provided false social security numbers. The court had previously issued a preliminary injunction requiring reinstatement and prohibiting such terminations based on the Act's antidiscrimination provisions. In response to the defendant's motion opposing a permanent injunction, the court deferred its ruling pending the plaintiffs' exhaustion of administrative remedies under the Act, while keeping the preliminary injunction in effect due to ongoing uncertainties in the administrative process established by the Immigration and Nationality Act.
immigrationlabor & employmentcivil rights
League of United Latin American Citizens v. Pasadena Independent School District
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1987-06-10 · cited 6×
The case involved undocumented workers employed as custodians by the Pasadena Independent School District who were fired in February 1987 for listing invalid social security numbers on their job applications, even though they had been hired before the November 1986 enactment of the Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) and remained eligible for legalization under its grandfather clause. The plaintiffs, represented by LULAC, sued under IRCA’s anti-discrimination provisions, alleging that the terminations constituted unfair immigration-related employment practices with a disparate impact on Hispanics. The court granted a preliminary injunction after finding that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on the merits, that the school district’s automatic-termination policy for application falsification was not justified by business necessity when less drastic alternatives existed, and that the employees posed no safety or performance risk.
immigrationcivil rightslabor & employment
Valley Line Co. v. Musgrove Towing Service, Inc.
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1987-02-13 · cited 3×
This case was a lawsuit by barge owner Valley Line Company against Musgrove Towing Service for money damages after three barges were damaged while moored at the defendant's fleeting facility during Hurricane Alicia in August 1983. The plaintiff alleged negligence in the defendant's preparations and mooring methods. The court ruled for the defendant and dismissed the case with prejudice, finding that the damage was caused by an act of God in the form of an unanticipated severe tidal surge, that the defendant had taken reasonable precautions with no contributory negligence, and that similar damage occurred at other facilities in the area. The decision applied bailment principles but held that the rebuttable presumption of negligence was overcome by evidence of due care.
torts & liabilitybusiness & regulatory
Kingfisher Shipping Co., Ltd. v. M/V KLARENDON
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-12-23 · cited 2×
This admiralty case arose from a 1985 allision in the Houston Ship Channel in which the M/V KLARENDON struck the stationary M/V CAPE HOPE while undocking without tug assistance. After the original parties settled, the vessel pursued a third-party claim against the compulsory pilot, Charles A. Schuessler, alleging negligence in the undocking maneuver. Following a bench trial, the court found that the pilot bore no liability because the vessel’s captain retained ultimate command, was present on the bridge throughout, and should have intervened to halt the risky maneuver or require a tug once its failure became apparent. The court therefore dismissed the third-party action against the pilot.
torts & liabilityprocedure
Smith v. Eastern Airlines, Inc.
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-12-23 · cited 3×
In Smith v. Eastern Airlines, Inc., plaintiff Mary Smith, a 5-foot-11-inch woman, sued under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 after Eastern rejected her 1974 application for a flight attendant position solely because she exceeded the airline's gender-specific height limits (5 feet 2 inches to 5 feet 9 inches for women, versus 5 feet 7 inches to 6 feet 2 inches for men). The court found that Smith established a prima facie case of disparate treatment because similarly tall men could apply while she could not, and she was otherwise qualified. However, Eastern rebutted the presumption of discrimination by showing the differing height ranges were derived from government statistics to achieve a proportionate number of average-height male and female hires, and the court concluded these reasons were not a pretext for sex discrimination. Judgment was entered for the defendant.
civil rightslabor & employment
Stubbs v. Metropolitan Life Insurance
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-10-23 · cited 1×
This case concerned whether a widow's survivor benefits under an employer-sponsored pension plan, which terminated upon her remarriage, should be reinstated after the remarriage was annulled. The plaintiff received a lump-sum payment and monthly annuities following her first husband's death but lost the annuities after remarrying; the defendant insurer refused to restore them post-annulment. The court granted the plaintiff's motion for summary judgment, finding no disputed facts and holding that Texas law treats an annulled marriage as void ab initio, restoring the plaintiff to her prior status and pension rights, in line with authority from other jurisdictions.
family lawlabor & employment
Houston International Televideo, Inc. v. Technicolor, Inc.
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-08-29 · cited 3×
This case involved a dispute over film library rights and related contracts between Houston International Televideo (HIT), Video East (VE), and defendants including Video Communications, Inc. (VCI) and Vidtronics. VCI moved under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a) to transfer the case to the Northern District of Oklahoma based on forum selection clauses in the parties' agreements designating Tulsa County, Oklahoma as the proper venue. The court granted the motion, applying the strong presumption from M/S Bremen v. Zapata Offshore Co. in favor of enforcing contractual forum selection clauses. Plaintiffs failed to show the clause was unreasonable, resulted from fraud or overreaching, or violated public policy, and arguments about jurisdictional barriers or Oklahoma corporate laws were rejected as insufficient to overcome the presumption or the focus on defendants' amenability to suit.
procedurebusiness & regulatory
Leroy v. City of Houston
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-08-01 · cited 3×
This case involved motions for attorneys' fees in three related lawsuits challenging the City of Houston's at-large system for electing city council members and annexations conducted without required preclearance under Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act. The court granted the motions, awarding fees to the plaintiffs' attorneys under 42 U.S.C. §§ 1988 and 1973l(e). It determined that the plaintiffs were prevailing parties because their litigation and advocacy efforts before the Department of Justice served as essential catalysts for the city's adoption of a mixed election system using both at-large and single-member districts, after the initial cases had been resolved adversely or declared moot.
electionscivil rightsprocedure
Henderson Broadcasting Corp. v. Houston Sports Ass'n
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-07-24 · cited 4×
The case involved a radio station, KYST, suing the Houston Astros' owner (HSA) and a competing station (KENR) after HSA terminated KYST's contract to broadcast Astros games and awarded exclusive flagship rights to KENR. KYST alleged violations of the Sherman Act Sections 1 and 2 for unlawful restraint of trade and monopolization, along with state antitrust claims, breach of contract by HSA, and tortious interference by KENR. The court granted partial summary judgment to the defendants on the per se antitrust violation claims, finding such analysis inapplicable to the non-price conduct at issue, but denied summary judgment on the remaining antitrust, contract, and tort claims. It reasoned that material factual disputes existed regarding the termination's causes and effects, precluding judgment as a matter of law on those issues.
business & regulatoryproceduretorts & liability
Matter of Extradition of Russell
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-07-10 · cited 10×
The case involved a U.S. citizen, Robert Henry Russell, who was detained in Texas after Colombia requested his provisional arrest under the 1982 U.S.-Colombia extradition treaty for alleged violations of Colombian fraud statutes. Russell petitioned for a writ of habeas corpus, arguing that the magistrate lacked jurisdiction to deny bail, that continued detention violated the Fourth and Fifth Amendments and the treaty due to insufficient probable cause and lack of urgency, and that Article 8 of the treaty preempted provisional detention under Article 11. The district court first confirmed its jurisdiction to review the magistrate's pre-extradition rulings on bail and detention, distinguishing prior cases that deferred review. It then upheld the magistrate's decisions, finding that the detention was supported by probable cause from Colombian evidence and complied with treaty and constitutional requirements. The court therefore denied the habeas petition in full.
criminal lawfederal powerprocedure
SDJ, Inc. v. City of Houston
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-06-03 · cited 29×
The case concerned twenty-three owners of topless bars in Houston who challenged the constitutionality of City Ordinance 86-323, which regulated the location, exterior features, and signage of sexually oriented businesses previously exempt under state law, following a 1985 amendment to the enabling statute. After a trial combining requests for preliminary and permanent injunctive relief, the court ruled that specific provisions—Sections 28-123(a)(1)(i), (a)(6), and 28-125(b)(8)—were invalid and permanently enjoined their enforcement. The remaining portions of the ordinance were upheld and enforceable, as the ordinance included a severability clause making those sections non-essential to its overall operation. The challenges centered on both facial constitutional grounds and whether the ordinance exceeded the authority granted by the state enabling statute.
free speechbusiness & regulatory
United States v. Jackson
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-05-21 · cited 3×
In United States v. Jackson, the defendant moved to suppress six firearms seized under an arrest warrant, five firearms from a warrantless search of his mother's apartment, and his subsequent confession in a case involving alleged unlawful possession of firearms. The court held that the arrest warrant was valid because the informant's sworn statement provided a substantial basis for probable cause that the defendant had received stolen goods, rendering the firearm found on his person admissible, but ruled the warrantless search unlawful as it did not fall under any exception such as consent or exigent circumstances. Although the defendant's confession was found to be voluntary, the court suppressed it as fruit of the illegal search; the defendant had standing to challenge the apartment search due to his rental arrangement and expectation of privacy in the room.
criminal lawgunsprocedure
Ashley v. Hays
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-05-19 · cited 3×
The case involved a former employee who sued pension plan administrators under ERISA after the plan terminated, seeking a lump-sum distribution of benefits rather than an annuity. The court granted the defendants' motion for summary judgment, holding that the administrators' denial of the lump-sum request did not breach their fiduciary duties. Review was limited to whether the decision was arbitrary or capricious, and the court found it was not because ERISA favors annuity payments with narrow exceptions that did not apply, the plan reserved discretion to the administrators over alternative forms of distribution, and the plaintiff's bare allegations of prior representations failed to raise a genuine factual issue under the summary judgment standard.
labor & employmentbusiness & regulatory
United States v. Continental Airlines Corp. (In Re Continental Airlines Corp.)
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-04-22 · cited 2×
This case involved an appeal by the United States from a bankruptcy court order in Continental Airlines' Chapter 11 proceedings concerning the distribution of pre-petition trust fund taxes claimed by the IRS. The district court affirmed the bankruptcy court's August 1985 order, which denied the government's motion for entry of judgment or relief from a November 1984 order that had ruled no trust funds existed and the escrowed proceeds belonged to the estate. The court held that the November order was an appealable judgment despite lacking a separate document, as the bankruptcy judge had indicated intent to enter a final ruling. It further concluded that Rule 60(b)(6) relief was unavailable because the United States failed to exercise due diligence in monitoring the docket for the order's entry, despite having notice that a written decision would follow an October hearing, and lack of notice alone does not extend appeal deadlines under the bankruptcy rules.
business & regulatorytaxesprocedure
United States v. Smith
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1986-03-31 · cited 3×
In United States v. Smith, two defendants charged in a four-count indictment asserted that they had negotiated valid plea bargain agreements with the U.S. Attorney’s Office to plead guilty to one count in exchange for dismissal of the remaining counts. The government moved to withdraw from the agreements, claiming the defendants had failed to act on the offers within a reasonable time and that no meeting of the minds had occurred with one defendant. The court held that the agreements were valid and enforceable, ordering the government to abide by them, because the parties had reached an understanding on the terms, the defendants had accepted the offers, and the government had neither a written policy nor any prior notice setting a deadline for acceptance.
criminal lawprocedure
Rogers v. Airline Pilots Ass'n, International
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1985-09-18 · cited 7×
In this case, two pilots who are members of the Air Line Pilots Association sued the union and Continental Air Lines for breach of the duty of fair representation during an arbitration proceeding concerning seniority list integration after an airline merger, and to enforce an arbitration award. The defendant union moved to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(1), arguing that the Civil Aeronautics Board (now DOT) had exclusive jurisdiction over airline mergers and seniority issues, that plaintiffs had failed to exhaust administrative remedies, and that primary jurisdiction rested with the agency. The court denied the motion, holding that district courts have subject matter jurisdiction over duty of fair representation claims under the Federal Aviation Act, as these are judicially created actions analogous to those under the National Labor Relations Act that are not subject to exclusive agency jurisdiction. It further ruled that the Federal Aviation Act does not require exhaustion of CAB/DOT remedies before filing such claims and that the primary jurisdiction doctrine does not divest the courts of authority here, citing supporting precedent from the Fifth and Ninth Circuits.
labor & employmentfederal power
Mitchell Energy Corp. v. Martin
District Court, S.D. Texas · 1985-01-29 · cited 9×
In Mitchell Energy Corp. v. Martin, the plaintiff brought claims under the federal RICO statute and for common law fraud against the defendants, who moved to dismiss the complaint under Rule 12(b). The court denied the motion, holding that a prior criminal conviction on the predicate acts is not required to maintain a civil RICO action and that the statute does not impose a separate "racketeering injury" requirement beyond the harm from the predicate offenses. The court relied on Fifth Circuit precedent favoring a broad reading of RICO without adding limitations not stated in the statute's text, such as a nexus to organized crime, and rejected due process arguments for lack of supporting authority. The fraud pleading challenge was also dismissed as previously resolved.
criminal lawprocedure