Judicial data via CourtListener (Free Law Project). Social links via Wikidata.
Born 1928 · Corning, NY
Computer Associates International, Inc. v. Altai, Inc.
District Court, E.D. New York · 1993-08-20 · cited 8×
In this case, Computer Associates sued Altai for copyright infringement and trade-secret misappropriation involving computer programs OSCAR 3.4 and 3.5. After appeals resolved the copyright claims and remanded the trade-secret claims, the district court addressed whether those claims were barred by the statute of limitations. The court held that Texas law governs the trade-secret claims and applies a two-year limitations period for torts that begins when the cause of action accrues upon the wrongful act causing injury. Because the claim was filed more than two years after accrual, even though within two years of discovery, the court dismissed it and denied the motion to reopen discovery as moot.
procedurebusiness & regulatory
Computer Associates International, Inc. v. Altai, Inc.
District Court, E.D. New York · 1991-08-09 · cited 36×
This case involved Computer Associates International, Inc. suing Altai, Inc. for copyright infringement and trade secret misappropriation, alleging that Altai copied substantial portions of CA's ADAPTER program into its OSCAR component used in scheduling software. The court determined that Altai's OSCAR 3.4 infringed CA's copyright but that the rewritten OSCAR 3.5 did not, while also addressing claims of trade secret misappropriation which were found to be preempted by copyright law in part. Damages were awarded to CA in the amount of $364,444 plus interest based on Altai's profits from the infringing version, after evaluating evidence of access, substantial similarity, and preemption issues. The decision rested on findings of fact regarding the development of the programs and expert testimony on their similarities.
propertybusiness & regulatory
Grubb v. Broadcast Music, Inc.
District Court, E.D. New York · 1987-10-21 · cited 3×
In Grubb v. Broadcast Music, Inc., plaintiff Diana Grubb sued her employer BMI and several executives alleging sex and race discrimination under Title VII, the Equal Pay Act, Section 1981, Section 1983, the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments, and related statutes, based on three incidents between 1983 and 1985 in which she was denied promotions, supervisory positions, and salary increases that went to male colleagues. The court dismissed all Title VII claims as untimely because Grubb filed her EEOC charge more than 300 days after the alleged acts. It dismissed the Section 1983 and Fourteenth Amendment claims because BMI is a private employer, and the Section 1981 and Thirteenth Amendment claims (limited to race discrimination) on summary judgment because Grubb never applied for the positions at issue and was less qualified than the selected candidates. The court also granted summary judgment on the Equal Pay Act claim, finding that Grubb's clerical role was not substantially equal to the supervisory position held by the comparator employee.
civil rightslabor & employment
Coser v. Moore
District Court, E.D. New York · 1983-08-03 · cited 8×
Thirty-four current and former female employees of Stony Brook brought a Title VII class action alleging a university-wide pattern and practice of sex discrimination in recruiting, hiring, placement, promotion, tenure, and compensation. The court certified a class under Rule 23(b)(2) limited to that pattern-or-practice claim and conducted a bifurcated trial on it. After reviewing extensive statistical evidence and witness testimony, the court found that plaintiffs had not proved the existence of such a university-wide pattern or practice of unlawful discrimination during the period Title VII applied to the university. The court therefore dismissed the class claims while preserving the individual plaintiffs' claims for separate resolution.
civil rightslabor & employment
Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. v. Liebowitz
District Court, E.D. New York · 1983-07-11 · cited 21×
The case involved Aetna Casualty and Surety Company suing insurance broker Liebowitz under the civil RICO statute for converting premiums paid by applicants for automobile insurance through New York's assigned risk pool, along with related state-law claims for breach of contract and conversion. After Aetna obtained a preliminary injunction and the parties reached a settlement that included a consent judgment for damages and a permanent injunction barring Liebowitz from the insurance business, Liebowitz defaulted on payment, prompting Aetna to seek attorney's fees and costs under 18 U.S.C. § 1964(c). The court denied the fee request, holding that the statute's language—modeled on Clayton Act § 4—authorizes fees only when a plaintiff recovers treble damages after a final judgment on the merits, not for obtaining preliminary injunctive relief under traditional equitable standards or entering a consent judgment without such a damages recovery. The decision rested on the text of § 1964(c), its contrast with Clayton Act § 16's "substantially prevails" standard, legislative history, and analogous antitrust precedents.
criminal lawbusiness & regulatoryprocedure
In Re Agent Orange Product Liability Litigation
District Court, E.D. New York · 1983-06-22 · cited 25×
This multidistrict litigation involves Vietnam veterans and their families suing nine chemical companies for personal injuries allegedly caused by exposure to dioxin-contaminated Agent Orange herbicide supplied to the U.S. military. The court addressed pretrial motions for summary judgment based on the government contract defense, which requires proving that the government set the product specifications, the defendants met those specs, and the government knew at least as much as the defendants about the associated health hazards. After reviewing discovery materials and comparing the parties' relative knowledge of dioxin risks, the court granted summary judgment to four defendants (Hercules, Thompson, Riverdale, and Hoffman-Taff) whose evidence showed the defense elements were satisfied without triable issues, while denying the motions of three others (Dow, T.H., and Uniroyal) due to remaining factual disputes; the claims against the two non-moving defendants proceeded to trial on the defense alongside liability issues.
torts & liabilityenvironmentfederal power
Williamson v. Secretary of the United States Department of Housing & Urban Development
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-11-03 · cited 4×
This case concerned a challenge by named plaintiffs and a class to HUD's policies under the Section 203 mortgage insurance program on when the agency would accept conveyance of occupied foreclosed properties from mortgagees. After a trial, the district court dismissed the individual plaintiffs' claims for failure of proof and later dismissed the class claims as moot following HUD's amendment of the relevant regulations in 1980. Plaintiffs moved to amend the judgment to seek attorneys' fees and costs under the Equal Access to Justice Act, contending that their lawsuit had acted as a catalyst for the regulatory changes and thus made them prevailing parties. The court denied the motion, holding that any connection between the litigation and the amendments was too attenuated to qualify the plaintiffs as prevailing parties under the Act.
federal powerpropertyprocedure
MacDonald v. Schweiker
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-11-01 · cited 26×
The case involved a plaintiff denied Social Security disability insurance benefits for the period before March 23, 1979, who challenged the Appeals Council's refusal to review an ALJ decision after the plaintiff had contacted the ALJ's office about appealing and later retained counsel to seek reopening with new evidence. The court had previously denied a motion to dismiss and remanded the matter to the Appeals Council for review on the merits, finding that the ALJ had effectively reopened the original decision by taking new testimony and making new findings. On plaintiff's motion for attorneys' fees and costs under the Equal Access to Justice Act, the court awarded $1,875 in fees for 25 hours plus $66 in costs, holding that plaintiff qualified as a prevailing party, that the Act applied to cases pending on its October 1, 1981 effective date (including pre-effective-date services), and that no special factor justified a rate above the $75 statutory maximum.
procedurehealthcare
Environmental Defense Fund, Inc. v. Watt
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-10-22 · cited 35×
The case involved environmental organizations suing federal officials, including the Secretary of the Interior, over the issuance of permits allowing chemical insecticide spraying and related activities on the Seatuck and Wertheim National Wildlife Refuges, alleging violations of NEPA, the National Wildlife Refuge System Administration Act, and related regulations. The parties reached a settlement under which defendants agreed to conditions on any future pesticide use, including consideration of alternatives and compliance with environmental laws, resulting in dismissal of the action without prejudice. Plaintiffs then sought attorneys' fees and expenses under the Equal Access to Justice Act, and the court granted the motion after finding that plaintiffs qualified as prevailing parties and that the government's position was not substantially justified.
environment
Grill v. United States
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-08-25 · cited 1×
In Grill v. United States, two plaintiffs sued the federal government claiming that swine flu vaccines they received under the national immunization program caused them to develop optic neuritis and resulting vision loss. After a bench trial limited to the issue of causation, the court ruled for the defendant and dismissed both complaints. The court found that the plaintiffs had shown only a temporal link between the vaccinations and their symptoms, which was insufficient to prove causation, and credited defense experts who identified alternative causes such as vascular problems or a tumor while noting no increased incidence of optic neuritis among vaccine recipients. Plaintiffs' experts were deemed less persuasive due to inconsistencies and lack of supporting evidence from medical literature or clinical data.
torts & liabilityhealthcare
In Re "Agent Orange" Product Liability Litigation
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-08-11 · cited 10×
This pretrial order in the Agent Orange product liability litigation addressed several motions involving defendants who manufactured or supplied the herbicide used in Vietnam. The court denied a motion to disqualify a law firm from representing multiple defendants, finding no conflict that would impair any party's defense or indemnification rights. It granted dismissal to four defendants who had not manufactured or supplied Agent Orange, conditioned on their agreement to allow future claims without statute of limitations defenses. The court denied voluntary dismissal to Hoffman-Taff (Missouri), a small manufacturer claiming its product never reached Vietnam, and denied Uniroyal's request to implead seven component suppliers, citing risks of complicating ongoing Phase I discovery on the government contract defense.
torts & liabilityprocedure
Heimila v. United States
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-08-04 · cited 3×
The case involved a Federal Tort Claims Act suit by Helen and Erik Heimila alleging negligence by the United States Postal Service that caused Mrs. Heimila's injury at the Ronkonkoma Post Office on September 6, 1979. The plaintiffs submitted an administrative claim, received a May 22, 1980 letter offering settlement or alternatively treating the letter as a final denial, and filed their federal lawsuit on August 3, 1981. The court dismissed the complaint, holding that the action was barred by the statute of limitations in 28 U.S.C. § 2401(b), which requires suit to be filed within six months after the mailing of notice of final denial by the agency. The court reasoned that the FTCA's waiver of sovereign immunity must be strictly construed, that the May 22 letter provided clear notice of the denial option, and that filing more than six months after that letter violated the limitations period even though the suit was brought within two years of the injury.
torts & liabilityprocedurefederal power
McKenna v. County of Nassau
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-04-28 · cited 7×
Kevin McKenna sued Nassau County under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 after being assaulted by other inmates while held overnight in an overcrowded tier at the Nassau County Correctional Center following a traffic stop and bench warrant for an unpaid fine. The jury returned special verdicts finding that McKenna was assaulted as he described, that the county's policy and practice for housing new young inmates was a proximate cause of his injuries, and that deliberate indifference by the county was also a proximate cause. The court denied the county's post-verdict motions for judgment notwithstanding the verdict and a new trial, holding that the evidence supported the jury's determinations on municipal liability under Monell standards. With damages stipulated at $25,000, the court entered judgment for McKenna and dismissed the claim against the warden.
civil rightscriminal law
Ryan v. Cleland
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-04-26 · cited 25×
Plaintiffs, veterans exposed to dioxin through Agent Orange during service in Southeast Asia, sued the Veterans Administration and its officials, alleging systemic failures to warn of health risks, provide adequate medical care, and avoid misleading or over-medicating veterans, and sought only declaratory, injunctive, and mandamus relief. Defendants moved to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction, and the court granted the motion after reviewing the original and proposed amended complaints. The court held that none of the asserted bases—including federal question jurisdiction, various constitutional clauses, diversity, section 1983, and other statutes—conferred power to adjudicate the broad claims against VA policies. The opinion noted some factual overlap with the related Agent Orange multidistrict litigation but concluded that absence of a valid jurisdictional foundation required dismissal regardless.
civil rightsfederal powerhealthcare
Berlin v. United States
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-03-31 · cited 4×
This case involved a dispute over whether a sheriff's execution sale of property, conducted to satisfy a junior judgment lien, extinguished a senior federal tax lien held by the IRS. The plaintiff, who purchased the property at the sale and later faced a levy from the IRS, sought to enjoin enforcement of the tax lien, claiming it had been discharged. The court granted the government's motion to dismiss, holding that the tax lien remained valid. The reasoning was based on 26 U.S.C. § 7425(b), which provides that divestment of a federal tax lien in a nonjudicial sale is governed by local law only under certain conditions, but federal tax liens take priority and are not affected by New York state's CPLR procedures for judgment liens, as confirmed by IRS regulations and prior case law.
taxespropertyfederal power
Neale v. Dillon
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-03-25 · cited 32×
In Neale v. Dillon, a former assistant district attorney sued her employer, the Nassau County District Attorney, under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act claiming sex discrimination in employment. The plaintiff alleged she was denied equal pay and a promotion to deputy bureau chief despite performing those duties, was transferred to a non-supervisory appeals position after indicating she might sue, and was constructively discharged. After a bench trial, the court dismissed all claims, finding the plaintiff failed to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the decisions on pay, promotion, transfer, or her working conditions were motivated by her sex rather than legitimate business reasons such as office needs and performance considerations. The court noted that transfers were routine and the transfer involved no pay reduction, while acknowledging some unprofessional office conduct but concluding it did not amount to actionable discrimination.
civil rightslabor & employment
State of Connecticut v. Long Island Lighting Co.
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-03-24 · cited 2×
The case involved a citizen suit by Connecticut against Lilco under the Clean Air Act's citizen suit provision, alleging that Lilco violated New York's EPA-approved state implementation plan by burning fuel oil with 2.8% sulfur content at its Northport and Port Jefferson facilities during the 16-month gap between the expiration of one EPA-approved variance and the approval of its extension. Connecticut sought injunctive relief to enforce the underlying 1% sulfur limit, along with orders directing EPA and DEC to enforce the SIP. The court denied Connecticut's motion for summary judgment, granted the defendants' motion to dismiss the complaint, and allowed intervention by additional plaintiffs. The core reasoning was that although Lilco was technically in violation during the gap period, EPA had twice determined through rulemaking that the higher sulfur fuel did not endanger Connecticut's air quality, and plaintiffs had other available remedies such as petitions under the Act and review in the Court of Appeals.
environmentfederal powerbusiness & regulatory
United States v. Myers
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-03-24 · cited 7×
This case involved post-trial motions by defendants convicted in an FBI Abscam sting operation targeting political corruption, who sought a new trial under FRCrP 33 or reopening of due process hearings based on newly discovered evidence from the wife of informant Melvin Weinberg. The evidence consisted of her statements suggesting Weinberg may have lied about receiving gifts from a defendant, that agents knew of it, and other issues like tape reliability and agent conduct, though she later committed suicide. The court denied the motions for new trials, to reopen hearings, and to suppress tapes, reasoning that the evidence mainly went to impeaching a prosecution witness's credibility (which is ordinarily insufficient), was unrelated to issues in some defendants' trials, would not probably produce an acquittal, and did not undermine the fairness of the proceedings.
criminal lawprocedure
Wells v. United States Administrator of Veterans Affairs
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-03-16 · cited 1×
In Wells v. United States Administrator of Veterans Affairs, former homeowners who defaulted on VA-guaranteed mortgages sued to prevent the VA from evicting them after foreclosure and transfer of title to the VA, seeking to remain as paying tenants and claiming a protectable property interest in continued occupancy that would require due process before eviction. The court consolidated the cases, granted intervention to one plaintiff but denied it to another, and ultimately granted the VA's motion for summary judgment dismissing all claims. It held that the plaintiffs lacked any such property interest because the veterans' benefits statute narrowly authorizes loan guarantees to promote home ownership by veterans rather than ongoing tenancy arrangements, distinguishing the case from FHA precedents. The court further reasoned that the VA's discretionary choice not to act as a landlord was unreviewable under the Administrative Procedure Act and that refusing to rent foreclosed properties did not constitute a major federal action requiring an environmental impact statement.
propertyfederal powerprocedureenvironment
Simonetti v. United States
District Court, E.D. New York · 1982-03-02 · cited 1×
In Simonetti v. United States, plaintiffs sued to recover for neurological injuries they claimed resulted from a swine flu vaccine given to Carlos Simonetti in October 1976 under the federal immunization program. After a separate bench trial on causation, the court found that the plaintiff's symptoms did not begin until mid-March 1977—more than four and a half months after the shot—based on medical records, treating physicians' notes, and the plaintiff's pattern of prior complaints. The court therefore concluded that the vaccine did not cause the claimed condition and dismissed the complaint for lack of proven causation.
torts & liabilityhealthcare