Judicial data via CourtListener (Free Law Project). Social links via Wikidata.
Born 1925 · Dallas, TX
Barrack v. Unum American Life Insurance
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2006-01-05 · cited 1×
In this ERISA case, the plaintiff sued the Excel Plan for wrongful denial of additional life insurance benefits following her husband's death, alleging he had increased his coverage during open enrollment. The court granted the defendant's motion to dismiss in part, specifically regarding the applicable standard of review (abuse of discretion) and limitations on evidence, but denied it as to other matters, allowing the benefits claim to proceed. The court denied the plaintiff's request to amend her complaint to add a breach of fiduciary duty claim, reasoning that such a claim is unavailable when the plaintiff already has a cause of action for denied benefits under ERISA section 1132(a)(1)(B). Various procedural motions were also resolved, including striking an untimely sur-reply.
labor & employmenthealthcareprocedure
Christiason v. Merit Texas Properties, L.L.C.
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2005-05-24 · cited 2×
The case involved a plaintiff suing his employer in state court for age and disability discrimination under Texas law. The defendant removed the action to federal court on the basis that the plaintiff's attached EEOC complaint referenced federal law violations, creating federal question jurisdiction. The court granted the plaintiff's motion to remand, ruling that the plaintiff is master of his complaint and did not assert any federal claims, so the EEOC attachment alone did not establish federal jurisdiction. Removal jurisdiction must be strictly construed with doubts resolved against removal, and the artful pleading doctrine did not apply. The motion to amend the complaint was denied as moot, and the case was remanded to state court.
labor & employmentcivil rightsprocedure
Roberson v. Game Stop, Inc.
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2005-02-08 · cited 5×
In Roberson v. Game Stop, Inc., the plaintiff, an African American employee in the Return to Vendor department, alleged that after taking FMLA leave in 2002 she was demoted and replaced by a white co-lead, later faced a pay cut along with the co-lead, and was ultimately terminated when her FMLA leave expired; she claimed racial discrimination under Title VII and 42 U.S.C. § 1981, FMLA violations, and retaliation under Title VII and the Texas Worker’s Compensation Act. The court granted the defendant’s motion for summary judgment on all claims. The core reasoning was that the plaintiff failed to establish a prima facie case of race discrimination because she did not show she was replaced by or treated less favorably than a less-qualified white employee, nor denied consideration for other available positions due to race; she also did not present evidence that the employer’s stated reasons were pretextual or that she was denied FMLA benefits or retaliated against for filing a workers’ compensation claim.
labor & employmentcivil rights
Bergen v. Continental Casualty Co.
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2005-02-07 · cited 4×
The case involved plaintiff Jan Bergen, a long-time employee at Continental Casualty Company, who sued after her 2003 termination, alleging discrimination on the basis of sex, age, and disability under federal and state law as well as retaliation for filing a workers' compensation claim and complaining about performance ratings. The district court considered the defendant's motion for summary judgment along with related procedural motions. The court granted summary judgment to the defendant, holding that the plaintiff failed to establish prima facie cases for her discrimination and retaliation claims or to show that the employer's stated reason of poor performance was pretextual. The undisputed facts showed repeated performance deficiencies and a legitimate file-audit process leading to termination, with no sufficient evidence of discriminatory or retaliatory motive under the applicable burden-shifting frameworks.
labor & employmentcivil rights
American Federation of Government Employees Local 1 v. Stone
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2004-11-02 · cited 5×
In this case, a federal TSA security screener and his union sued the government under the Little Tucker Act, alleging breach of contract and Fifth Amendment violations after the employee was not paid the salary stated in his conditional appointment letter. The court granted the defendant's motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and failure to state a claim. It held that federal employment arises from appointment rather than contract unless the governing statute or hiring documents explicitly create a contractual relationship, and the relevant TSA statutes and documents here did not. Because no contract existed, the Little Tucker Act provided no jurisdiction over the breach claim, and the constitutional claims likewise failed for lack of jurisdiction or a viable cause of action. The complaint was dismissed with prejudice.
labor & employmentfederal powerprocedure
Bourgault v. Yudof
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2004-05-04 · cited 8×
The case concerns Matt Bourgault, a traveling Christian evangelist, who was denied permission to preach and distribute pamphlets on the University of Texas at Arlington campus because he was an off-campus speaker not affiliated with the university or sponsored by a registered student organization. University policies, including Board of Regents' Rules 6.1, 6.2, and 6.71, and the UTA Off-Campus Speakers policy, restricted such activities by non-students and prohibited religious evangelism or witnessing. Bourgault sought a preliminary injunction to bar enforcement of these rules on First Amendment grounds. The court denied the motion, finding that Bourgault failed to demonstrate a substantial likelihood of success on the merits or the other required factors for injunctive relief under Fifth Circuit precedent.
free speechreligious libertycivil rights
Doe v. KPMG, L.L.P.
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2004-04-12 · cited 5×
In Doe v. KPMG, L.L.P., two taxpayers who had engaged the accounting firm KPMG for tax consulting and return preparation on investments in limited liability companies sought a permanent injunction barring KPMG from disclosing their identities to the IRS pursuant to administrative summonses concerning certain tax shelter transactions identified in IRS Notice 2000-44, relying on the confidentiality privilege for communications with federally authorized tax practitioners under I.R.C. § 7525. The district court denied the plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment, granted KPMG’s cross-motion and the United States’ motion to dismiss (treated as a summary judgment motion), and held that the § 7525 privilege did not protect the taxpayers’ identities from disclosure. The court reasoned that the privilege applies only to communications and that revealing the clients’ names would not disclose any protected communications beyond the non-confidential fact of their participation in the tax shelter, which had been reported on their tax returns.
taxesfederal powerbusiness & regulatory
Southwest Airlines Co. v. Farechase, Inc.
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2004-03-19 · cited 13×
Southwest Airlines sued FareChase and Outtask, alleging that Outtask's use of FareChase software to automatically scrape proprietary fare, route, and schedule data from Southwest.com was unauthorized and caused harm. The claims included violations of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, misappropriation, breach of the website's use agreement, tortious interference, trespass, unjust enrichment, and harmful access by computer. Outtask moved to dismiss six claims under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6), arguing insufficient allegations of damage, lack of a valid contract, and other deficiencies. The court denied the motion in full, holding that Southwest had pleaded specific facts sufficient to support each claim, including unauthorized access resulting in loss or damage and the enforceability of the use agreement at the pleading stage.
business & regulatoryproceduretorts & liability
Dallas Independent School District v. Calvary Hill Cemetery
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2004-02-04 · cited 3×
This case is an eminent domain proceeding in which the Dallas Independent School District sought to condemn about 25 acres of undeveloped land owned by Calvary Hill Cemetery for construction of a public school. After special commissioners awarded compensation, the cemetery filed state and federal counterclaims in state court, including federal claims under 42 U.S.C. §§ 1983-1988 alleging a conspiracy to delay a special-use permit that would have designated the land for cemetery use and blocked the condemnation. The City and council members removed the case to federal court on the basis of those federal counterclaims. The court held that it lacked subject-matter jurisdiction and ordered remand to state court. It reasoned that the federal takings claim was not ripe because the cemetery had not exhausted state compensation procedures and that the related federal civil-rights claim therefore could not support removal under the separate-and-independent-claim doctrine.
propertycivil rightsprocedurefederal power
MARESH EX REL. MARESH v. Thompson
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2003-11-03 · cited 3×
The case involved a plaintiff, acting on behalf of Maresh, who sued the Secretary of Health and Human Services to recover approximately $24,901 paid to Medicare as reimbursement under the Medicare Secondary Payer Act following a personal injury settlement, alleging a violation of Fifth Amendment due process rights. The court granted the defendant's motion to dismiss, ruling that it lacked subject matter jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1331. The core reasoning was that the Medicare Act, via 42 U.S.C. § 405(h), bars federal question jurisdiction for claims arising under the Act, which this reimbursement dispute clearly did, and that the plaintiff was required to exhaust administrative remedies before seeking judicial review, even when challenging the constitutionality of agency actions rather than the statute itself.
healthcareprocedurefederal power
Tasby v. Moses
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2003-06-05 · cited 3×
This case is a long-running school desegregation lawsuit filed in 1970 by African American students against the Dallas Independent School District (DISD) to challenge racially segregated schools and obtain a comprehensive desegregation plan. After granting unitary status in 1994 subject to a monitoring period, the court held an evidentiary hearing in 2003 on DISD's motion to dismiss the case and end federal oversight. The court granted the motion to dismiss, concluding that DISD had satisfied the relevant legal standards for unitary status under Supreme Court precedent such as Green v. County School Board. The decision rested on stipulated compliance in many areas, non-contested improvements, and resolution of contested issues including learning centers, bilingual programs, early childhood education, magnet schools, and the achievement gap between minority and Anglo students.
civil rights
Witterholt v. United States
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2003-04-28
The case involved a pro se plaintiff who alleged that an Immigration and Naturalization Service officer attacked him during a meeting after he called the officer a liar while the officer read from the plaintiff's INS file, and the plaintiff sought damages for resulting medical expenses. The court granted the United States' motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction under Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 12(b)(1). The core reasoning was that the Federal Tort Claims Act waives sovereign immunity for certain tort claims only if the plaintiff first exhausts administrative remedies by presenting the claim to the appropriate federal agency, which the plaintiff neither alleged nor did according to agency records.
immigrationfederal powerproceduretorts & liability
Carlson v. Trans Union, LLC
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2003-04-17 · cited 6×
In this case, plaintiff Carlson sued defendant CSC Credit Services, a consumer reporting agency, alleging that CSC provided inaccurate information on his credit report and failed to correct it after being notified of a dispute, leading to repeated denials of credit and mortgages. Carlson brought claims under multiple sections of the Fair Credit Reporting Act as well as a state-law negligence claim. CSC moved to dismiss the negligence claim under Rule 12(b)(6), arguing that the claim was preempted by FCRA § 1681h(e), which requires a showing of malice or willful intent to injure for certain state tort claims against credit agencies. The court held that § 1681h(e) applies to the claim but concluded that requiring proof of both negligence and malice or intent creates an inherent contradiction, as Texas law does not recognize a cause of action for intentional negligence. Accordingly, the court granted the motion and dismissed the negligence claim.
business & regulatoryproceduretorts & liability
Carlson v. Trans Union, LLC
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2003-04-16 · cited 22×
In Carlson v. Trans Union, LLC, the plaintiff sued Verizon Wireless and credit reporting agencies, alleging false trade lines from Verizon appeared on his credit report despite no account existing, resulting in denied credit applications and collection demands. Verizon moved to dismiss the claims under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) §1681s-2(b) as well as state-law negligence and defamation claims. The court denied dismissal of the FCRA claim, concluding that a private cause of action exists under that provision and that the complaint met pleading requirements by alleging notification of the dispute to the furnisher. It granted dismissal of the negligence claim as preempted by federal law under §1681h(e) but denied dismissal of the defamation claim except for any publications occurring before December 12, 2001, which were barred by the one-year Texas statute of limitations.
business & regulatoryproceduretorts & liability
Martinez Alvarez v. Casita Maria, Inc.
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2003-04-07 · cited 1×
The case involved a plaintiff who was in the United States illegally and sought immigration counseling from the defendants, who advised him on forms to submit to the INS but did not recommend Form I-212. After the INS became aware of his presence, the plaintiff was arrested, pleaded guilty to illegal reentry under 8 U.S.C. § 1326, and was imprisoned; he then sued the defendants for negligence, misfeasance, and legal malpractice under Texas law, alleging that proper counseling would have prevented his conviction and resulting damages. The court granted the defendants' motion to dismiss, ruling that Texas precedent from Peeler v. Hughes & Luce bars malpractice and negligence claims based on a criminal conviction unless that conviction has been overturned, because the plaintiff's illegal conduct rather than any advice was the cause in fact of his injuries and public policy prevents shifting the consequences of a crime to third parties.
immigrationcriminal lawproceduretorts & liability
United States v. Saleem
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2002-12-05
This case concerns motions to suppress evidence filed by two brothers, Sleiman Saleem and Rashid Salim, who were charged with visa fraud after government agents from the INS, State Department, and FBI conducted early-morning "knock and talk" visits at their homes on July 3, 2002. The court found that Sleiman voluntarily consented to a search of his residence and later presented his passport and immigration documents at a government office, and that his subsequent statements were not subject to suppression. In contrast, the court determined that Rashid was in custody during the encounter and at INS headquarters without receiving valid Miranda warnings, particularly given the absence of an Arabic translator or written rights form despite evident language difficulties, leading to suppression of his oral and written statements. The ruling applied Fourth Amendment consent standards and Fifth Amendment Miranda requirements based on the totality of circumstances and the government's burden of proof.
criminal lawcivil rightsprocedure
John Hunter, Inc. v. Great Impressions Apparel, Inc.
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2002-06-24 · cited 3×
This case involves sales representatives who sued a sportswear manufacturer in state court for unpaid commissions under an alleged oral contract, claiming damages exceeding the federal jurisdictional minimum. The defendant removed the case to federal court on diversity grounds more than thirty days after receiving the plaintiffs' discovery requests that quantified damages over $75,000. The court granted the plaintiffs' motion to remand, holding that the initial pleading did not clearly establish the amount in controversy under Fifth Circuit precedent, but the requests for admissions qualified as "other paper" under 28 U.S.C. § 1446(b) and triggered the removal clock on January 2, 2002. The removal on March 28, 2002, was therefore untimely. The court aggregated the plaintiffs' damages claims arising from the same contract and included potential attorneys' fees to confirm the amount exceeded the threshold.
procedure
Greil v. Geico
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2002-01-16 · cited 4×
The case involved plaintiff Roxanne Greil suing her insurer Geico after a 1997 car accident, claiming under her underinsured motorist policy following a settlement with the at-fault driver for policy limits. Geico investigated the claim, accounting for Greil's involvement in two later accidents, valued it at $67,500, offered a $40,000 settlement after offsets, and repeatedly proposed discussions or mediation, which Greil rejected while demanding a written breakdown without a release. After settling the contract and one statutory claim, the court granted Geico summary judgment on the remaining claims for breach of the duty of good faith, Insurance Code violations, and DTPA violations, finding no evidence that Geico's evaluation or communications were unreasonable or insufficient under Texas law.
business & regulatorytorts & liability
Furstonberg v. Mintz
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2001-10-30
The case involved medical malpractice claims by the Furstonbergs against their doctors and healthcare providers, including allegations of negligent diagnosis of emphysema, improper reporting of smoking history, failure to release medical records, and related claims against insurance and hospital defendants under the Texas Health Care Liability Act along with vicarious liability and gross negligence theories. The defendants removed the case from Texas state court, arguing preemption by ERISA due to involvement of plan benefits administration. The court granted the plaintiffs' motion to remand the case to state court, reasoning that the claims focused on the quality of medical care provided rather than the quantity or denial of ERISA benefits, so they were not subject to complete preemption under ERISA section 502 and any conflict preemption did not support federal removal jurisdiction.
healthcarefederal powerproceduretorts & liability
Breakiron v. Neal
District Court, N.D. Texas · 2001-05-08 · cited 14×
In Breakiron v. Neal, an inmate at the Hunt County Jail filed a civil rights complaint under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 against Jail Supervisor Curtis Neal, Transport Officer Mary Bruner, and Medical Officer Lynn Brannon. The plaintiff alleged that a metal door closed on him due to improper maintenance, causing physical injuries, and that the defendants delayed medical treatment for ninety minutes, dispensed medication without a license, and charged for care. The court conducted a frivolity screening under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1915(e)(2)(B) and 1915A and dismissed the complaint. The core reasoning was that the claims sounded in negligence, which is not actionable under § 1983; there was no deliberate indifference to serious medical needs under the Eighth Amendment; and prisoners have no constitutional right to free healthcare or medication dispensed solely by licensed practitioners.
civil rightscriminal lawprocedure