Judicial data via CourtListener (Free Law Project). Social links via Wikidata.
Decision levers
AI-measured from their own opinions — each lever cites its cases
PurposivismTextualism
Opinions apply statutory text literally, as in denying recovery absent physical injury under Virginia tort law in the FTCA case and requiring documented market rates under Title VII fee provisions. Sypert v. United States ↗ Palmer v. Shultz ↗ Palmer v. Shultz ↗
Willing to revisit precedentStrong stare decisis
Opinions adhere closely to D.C. Circuit rulings such as Laffey when recalculating fees and follow remand instructions without questioning their validity in the Title VII class action. Palmer v. Shultz ↗ Palmer v. Shultz ↗ Palmer v. Shultz ↗
Deference to government powerSkepticism of government power
This case concerns the recalculation of attorneys' fees and expenses under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 in Palmer v. Shultz, following remand from the D.C. Circuit. The court addressed the appropriate hourly rate for the lodestar, finding that the plaintiffs' firm's customary rates are presumptively reasonable but subject to upward adjustment if shown to be abnormally low compared to the broad range of prevailing community rates for similar complex federal litigation. Plaintiffs submitted affidavits and comparison data from numerous D.C. firms demonstrating their rates fell below market brackets, leading the court to approve adjusted rates for specific attorneys based on the lowest documented market rates for their experience levels in relevant years. The decision adheres to precedents like Laffey v. Northwest Airlines, Inc., without resolving enhancements for representation quality or nonpayment risk.
This case is a class action brought by female Foreign Service Officers and applicants against the Department of State alleging sex discrimination in employment practices under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The claims covered hiring (settled earlier), assignments, promotions, evaluations, awards, and cone assignments at hire. After an initial district court ruling for the defendant, the D.C. Circuit reversed on seven challenged practices and remanded; on remand, this court found no discrimination proven in promotions from class 5 to class 4 but found discrimination established in the other six areas based on statistical disparities and analysis of personnel policies. Judgment was entered for the defendant on the promotion claim and for the plaintiffs on the remaining claims, with remedies to be determined later.
The case concerned The Washington Post's FOIA request to the Department of State for 'records of schedule' logs created daily by staff in former Secretary Alexander Haig's office, which documented his official meetings, calls, and activities. The central issue was whether these documents constituted 'agency records' under FOIA, as opposed to personal records exempt from disclosure. The court applied the framework from Bureau of National Affairs v. United States Department of Justice, examining factors including the documents' creation by agency staff for official purposes, the agency's control over them, and the absence of personal use by the Secretary himself. It determined that the records qualified as agency records because they were generated and maintained to chronicle agency-related events, even though Haig was unaware of them and did not request their creation.
In Palmer v. Shultz, a class of female Foreign Service Officers and applicants sued the Department of State under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, alleging sex discrimination in various employment practices including cone assignments, job assignments, promotions, performance evaluations, awards, and class at hire, though hiring claims were settled via consent decrees. After a bifurcated trial on liability issues, the district court found that the plaintiffs failed to establish by a preponderance of the evidence any sexual discrimination by the State Department in the remaining claims. The court's findings of fact, based on witness testimony, exhibits, and statistical analyses, indicated no disparate treatment or impact in areas such as cone assignments at entry, promotions, or performance evaluations, leading to judgment for the defendant and dismissal of the case.
This case involved an Army physician who was subjected to multiple involuntary psychiatric evaluations and hospitalizations in 1981 after performance issues in clinical assignments, resulting in adverse Officer Evaluation Reports, removal from a promotion list, and denial of special pay; he was later discharged. Plaintiff sued the Department of Defense and Army officials seeking declaratory and injunctive relief, claiming the hospitalizations violated Army regulations and the Fifth Amendment's Due Process Clause and tainted subsequent administrative actions. After an earlier remand, the Army Board for Correction of Military Records reviewed the matter with input from the Judge Advocate General and Surgeon General, concluding the actions complied with regulations and were justified by military necessity to assess fitness for duty. The court granted the defendants' renewed motion for summary judgment, holding that the Board's findings were supported by law and evidence and were not arbitrary or capricious, noting that constitutional standards in the military context differ from civilian ones and do not require pre-hospitalization hearings.
Plaintiff Evanna Powell, who failed the District of Columbia bar examination, sued members of the Committee on Admissions alleging that the exam's construction and grading violated her Fifth Amendment rights to equal protection and due process, as well as 42 U.S.C. § 1983. The court considered defendants' motion to dismiss on grounds of immunity and a request to substitute the Committee as defendant for equitable claims. The court held that individual Committee members enjoy absolute immunity from money damages claims for most actions because their functions in administering the bar exam are quasi-judicial and integrally related to the judicial process, but found qualified immunity applicable to specific allegations regarding the use of examination numbers to predetermine scores; it substituted the Committee as the proper defendant for equitable relief and denied an extension of a protective order on discovery.