The opinions apply settled precedents such as Sullivan and Blockburger without questioning their validity, and routinely follow New York tort and contract rules as established authority. Sankin v. Abeshouse ↗ United States v. Josephberg ↗
Deference to government powerSkepticism of government power
The court rejected Bureau of Prisons policy that conflicted with statutory text in Adler and dismissed claims against state agencies only after finding no protected interest or private right of action, indicating measured skepticism rather than deference. JAV Auto Center, Inc. v. Behrens ↗ Adler v. Menifee ↗
Judicial activismJudicial restraint
Multiple decisions grant summary judgment or dismiss claims where no legal duty or protected interest is shown, and the Rosendale opinion explicitly cautions against federal courts acting as zoning boards of appeal. Ehrens v. Lutheran Church-Missou… ↗ Rosendale v. LeJeune ↗
In Sankin v. Abeshouse, the plaintiff brought a malicious prosecution claim in federal court after prevailing in part in a prior NASD arbitration initiated by Augustus Capital LLC against him for breach of contract; he had counterclaimed for defamation and expungement of his U-5 form but was denied attorneys' fees. The defendants, principals of Augustus, moved to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6). The court granted the motions and dismissed the complaint with prejudice, holding that the plaintiff failed to plead that the defendants personally initiated the arbitration, that the arbitration panel's denial of fees established probable cause for the underlying claims, and that no special damages beyond ordinary litigation costs were alleged as required under New York law for civil malicious prosecution.
The case involves plaintiff Allison Henry suing Westchester Foreign Autos and TMCC alleging that the dealership forged her signature on a 2005 car loan refinance contract with altered terms, and that defendants violated federal statutes including the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, Fair Credit Reporting Act, and Credit Repair Organizations Act, along with state claims for fraud and breach of contract. Defendants moved for summary judgment on grounds including that forgery could not be proven without expert testimony and that no adverse action occurred under the credit statutes. The court denied the motion, ruling that lay witnesses may authenticate signatures under the Federal Rules of Evidence and that genuine issues of material fact remain on whether defendants engaged in adverse action or regularly participated in credit decisions, precluding summary judgment.
This case involves a widow suing tobacco manufacturers Philip Morris and Brown & Williamson (as successor to American Tobacco) for the lung cancer death of her husband, who began smoking Lucky Strike and later Marlboro cigarettes as a teenager. The plaintiff alleged multiple state-law tort claims under New York law, including failure to warn and fraudulent concealment before September 1968 (against ATC only), design defect, and fraud in marketing Marlboro Lights. On the defendants' motions for summary judgment, the court addressed the remaining claims after voluntary dismissals and found that the plaintiff presented sufficient evidence to raise triable issues of fact on whether ATC had a duty to warn of smoking dangers and whether any failure to warn proximately caused the injuries, defeating summary judgment on those issues; the opinion also noted analysis of design defect and other claims under New York product liability standards.
The case involved an appeal from a bankruptcy court judgment determining the dischargeability of a remaining $74,000 obligation under a divorce decree that labeled payments as spousal maintenance but which the court found actually settled the equitable distribution of the value of the debtor's medical degree acquired during marriage. The bankruptcy court concluded the debt was not truly in the nature of alimony or support under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(5) and was dischargeable under § 523(a)(15)(B) because the debtor lacked ability to pay given his income and other obligations while discharge would benefit him more than it would harm his ex-wife. The district court affirmed after reviewing the record, including the ex-wife's household income, assets, and the debtor's efforts to pay amid his loss of medical license and employment difficulties, finding no clear error in the factual balancing. The opinion focused on the nature of the divorce settlement stipulation and the statutory exceptions to discharge for divorce-related debts.
This case involved a property owner suing the Town of Amenia and two officials for failing to enforce local zoning and land use regulations against neighbors, including a rod and gun club, claiming the inaction was retaliation for the plaintiff's public complaints and petitions in violation of the First Amendment, plus denial of equal protection under the Fourteenth Amendment. The plaintiff also asserted related state-law claims regarding nuisances, blue laws, and other matters, many of which overlapped with prior unsuccessful federal litigation. The district court adopted the magistrate judge's recommendation and granted summary judgment to the defendants, dismissing all claims. The core reasoning was that the plaintiff had no protected property interest in zoning enforcement, failed to raise a triable issue on motive or causation because he relied solely on his own inconsistent testimony, and federal courts should avoid acting as zoning boards of appeal by deferring to state courts on local land-use issues under principles of federalism.
This case involves a Title IX lawsuit brought by a student and her mother against a school district and officials, alleging that the district was deliberately indifferent to repeated reports of a teacher's sexual misconduct toward female students dating back to 1989, which enabled an assault on the plaintiff in 2004. The district defendants moved for summary judgment, arguing insufficient evidence of actual notice or deliberate indifference and seeking dismissal of related claims. The court denied summary judgment on the core Title IX claim and state-law negligence claims, finding genuine issues of material fact regarding the district's knowledge and response to prior complaints, and held that qualified immunity and punitive damages issues were fact-intensive and better resolved at trial. It granted the motion in part by dismissing the mother's derivative claim under Title IX and Section 1983, while reserving decision on supplemental jurisdiction over remaining state claims.