Judge Wanted Courts’ Climate Guide To Avoid Getting Ahead Of The Science On Company-Specific Injuries, Emails Show
A judge reviewing the federal courts' science guide wanted its climate chapter to warn the research cannot yet tie specific harms to individual companies.
Simon August·Nov 17, 2026·6 min read
Sponsored
A judge reviewing the federal courts’ science guide wanted its climate chapter to warn that the research cannot yet tie specific harms to individual companies.
The unnamed judge wanted the chapter to say the science “does not support micro-level conclusions” tying a particular defendant to specific plaintiffs’ injuries, a Federal Judicial Center official wrote in a July 25, 2024, email. The Republican-led House Judiciary Committee released the emails with a Sept. 30 staff report, and its Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet holds a related hearing Thursday.
“The judge thought the science may get there some day, but it would disserve judges and litigants to suggest it’s there now,” Beth Wiggins, director of the center’s Research Division, wrote to the chapter’s authors.
Jessica Wentz, a non-resident senior fellow at Columbia Law School’s Sabin Center for Climate Change Law, replied July 26 that the question is “ultimately a case specific determination.”
“I think it would be incorrect to broadly assert that the science cannot currently support such claims at this time,” Wentz wrote. “To the contrary, existing scientific research could potentially support a factual finding that a defendant has contributed to specific climate change-related injuries (again, depending on the facts of the case).”
Wiggins had written that the manual’s oversight committee signed off on the draft for outside review. The center would ask those reviewers whether it “accurately describes the certainty/uncertainty associated with climate science” and “appropriately caveats its relevance to potential litigation,” she wrote. Wiggins suggested the authors take up the judge’s comment once the reviewers weighed in.
Wentz wrote in her reply that the authors could “wait to fully respond to this comment until we receive further input from external reviewers.”
The center puts out the Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence with the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine. One National Academies official called the manual “the primary reference source on scientific methodology for the federal judiciary” in an email on Dec. 29, 2022.
Sponsored
Sponsored
Wentz and Columbia Climate School professor Radley Horton wrote the chapter, which the center and the National Academies published Dec. 31, 2025, without the caveat the judge suggested. The chapter’s introduction says judges may face “genuine scientific questions and areas of uncertainty” when they decide whether a defendant contributed to a plaintiff’s injuries.
The chapter also says research tying company emissions to particular climate effects relies on “well-established attribution techniques and climate models.” Tracing impacts “to specific emitters and sources” tends to involve “more uncertainty,” it adds.
In a Feb. 26 blog post, Wentz and Horton said the chapter “acknowledged the scientific consensus on human-induced climate change while also recognizing areas of uncertainty in the research.” They wrote that it “underwent extensive peer review from external reviewers, including both scientists and judges.”
Daren Bakst, director of the Center for Energy and Environment at the Competitive Enterprise Institute, a regulatory reform group, said in a statement to the Daily Caller News Foundation that “trying to attribute an alleged injury to one company’s emissions is laughable.”
“There is no genuine way to connect the dots,” Bakst said.
Wentz, Horton, Sabin Center executive director Michael Burger and the Federal Judicial Center did not respond to requests for comment from the DCNF.
Judge Robin Rosenberg, the center’s director, wrote in a Feb. 6 letter that the agency “has omitted the climate science chapter” from the manual. Twenty-seven state attorneys general had asked for the chapter’s removal, the House Judiciary Committee’s Sept. 30 staff report said.
The National Academies pointed the DCNF to an Oct. 15 release saying the National Academy of Sciences selected the law firm Wiley Rein to help run an independent review of how the chapter was developed. The independent panel “will not evaluate the substance of the chapter or assess the validity of climate science,” the release says.
The emails also show the committee overseeing the manual decided “that it would be inadvisable” for Burger to write the chapter. Wiggins wrote March 6, 2023, that Burger had raised the potential conflict himself over “his representation of several state and local governments in lawsuits against fossil fuel companies.”
Burger is also “Of Counsel” at Sher Edling, “a law firm that has filed numerous lawsuits against oil and gas companies,” the committee report said.
Burger wrote to Wentz and Horton on March 7, 2023, that he had “no problem stepping aside” and would “be happy to contribute behind the scenes.”
Wentz sent Horton a revised draft on April 26, 2023. She wrote that it “includes Mike’s edits (and my responses),” meaning Burger.
The published chapter’s acknowledgments thank Burger, among others, for “insights and helpful feedback.”
One comment initialed “MB” sits next to a passage that was marked for deletion, about lawsuits claiming companies misled the public on the harms of fossil fuels.
“Again, just seeking to minimize the emphasis on these cases,” the comment reads.
Another “MB” comment said the Supreme Court had declined to take up such cases. That meant they would go forward in state court, the comment added, and it now seemed highly unlikely federal judges would address causation in them.
The comment left the decision to Wentz: “Up to you to decide how to proceed with that information.”
Wentz wrote back that she wanted to keep the cases in. One claim was in federal court, she wrote, and the committee had noted that state judges may also read the manual.
“But I’ve tried to de-emphasize this type of litigation in the Chapter,” she wrote.
The subcommittee hearing, titled “A Climate of Bias: How Environmental Activists Influence the Judiciary,” is scheduled for 10 a.m. Thursday in the Rayburn House Office Building.
All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact [email protected].