Pentagon Tells Court It Lacks Staff To Clear About 400 Wind Projects
The Pentagon says it does not have enough people to clear hundreds of wind projects waiting on its security review.
Simon August·Nov 21, 2026·7 min read
Sponsored
The Pentagon says it does not have enough people to clear hundreds of wind projects waiting on its security review.
About 400 projects are in the queue and only eight federal civilian employees can sign off on them, Dale Marks, the assistant secretary of war for energy, installations and environment, said in a Nov. 3 court declaration. The department has since “countersigned mitigation agreements for certain projects,” the wind groups suing it wrote Nov. 16.
“None of these teams are sized to manage the dramatic influx of applications received in recent years,” Marks wrote.
The groups wrote that more such agreements “may be executed shortly.”
They wanted another month to answer the department, pointing to its “ongoing review” and saying the time would “permit Plaintiffs to review DoD’s next status report.”
U.S. District Judge Karin Immergut of Oregon, an appointee of President Donald Trump, agreed Nov. 16 and pushed their deadline to Dec. 17.
Contractors cannot legally sign those agreements, according to Marks. Only two federal employees at the department’s Siting Clearinghouse, two at the Air Force and four at the North American Aerospace Defense Command can.
The clearinghouse also has four contractors and the Air Force has three, he wrote. The aerospace command’s four staffers handle the reviews as “but one of their professional duties.”
That command has seen “a dramatic increase of threat activity in its area of responsibility, notably involving unmanned aerial systems,” Marks wrote.
Sponsored
Sponsored
The department “is fully committed to progressing through its review of Clearinghouse projects and to meeting this Court’s expectations,” he added.
The department signed 13 mitigation agreements in an average year, but recently the figure has hovered around 30, Marks wrote. Staffing levels “remain largely unchanged,” he added.
From 2012 to 2025, the department took an average of 491 days to get from first notice of a project to a fully signed mitigation agreement, Marks wrote.
He also wrote that since 2024, “the Clearinghouse had a protracted vacancy of one of its two civilian employee billets, which was not filled until just a few months ago.”
Steve Milloy, a senior policy fellow at the Energy and Environment Legal Institute, said in a statement to the Daily Caller News Foundation that the military’s security concerns should come before developers’ schedules.
“The Pentagon should take as long as is needed under the law. National security comes first,” Milloy said. “Delays to wind developers should not be a consideration at all. The Green New Scam is not a national priority.”
The Department of War told the DCNF in a statement that it “does not comment on pending or ongoing litigation.” The American Clean Power Association and the wind groups’ lawyers did not respond.
As of Nov. 3, the projects closest to approval were about 33 whose developers had already signed mitigation agreements, Marks wrote. He wrote that the department “intends to act with dispatch” on them.
The department has now reviewed every one of them under a new analytical method, he added.
“The results indicated that all projects in this category pose risks to national security that require mitigation measures,” Marks wrote.
Because many required fixes were already in the signed deals, the department is assessing whether, “for only this category, it may be appropriate to countersign the original” agreements, he added.
About 110 projects were still in talks with military teams in early October, and the department has “exceeded the 90-day regulatory timeline” for any without an extension, he wrote.
Then there are 52 projects that the department’s early screening found “do not generate radar interference” affecting the military. Marks wrote that he has “directed the Clearinghouse staff to continue closing these projects,” which moves them along to the Federal Aviation Administration.
All but six of those reviews “have exceeded the statutory 75-day review period,” he wrote. In the month before his declaration, the department sent seven similar projects to the aviation agency.
Even a military objection would not be final. A finding of unacceptable risk “is no more than a non-binding recommendation to the FAA,” government lawyers wrote Nov. 3.
The Pentagon started slowing its wind reviews in August 2025 and halted them May 7, 2026, Immergut wrote in her Aug. 6 opinion. A department memo pointed to “the advancement of adversarial capabilities and the evolving global threat-picture,” she noted.
In a July declaration, Marks argued that spinning turbine blades can create false radar signals.
A drone or missile with a small radar signature that passes through a “blinded” sector “could be entirely filtered from radar view,” he wrote then.
Wind trade groups and environmental nonprofits filed the suit in May, according to her opinion. Immergut suspended the freeze nationwide and ordered the department to report back every 30 days.
“Congress did not give DoD free rein to review energy projects in whatever way DoD deems fit,” she wrote.
Pentagon spokesperson Bob Ditchey told Heatmap News in October that the department “has cleared both projects to proceed to the next phase of federal evaluation,” referring to wind farms in South Dakota and Maine. The outlet reported that both appeared to be upgrades of operating wind farms.
The Trump administration offered to let about 30 stalled wind projects move ahead as part of a bipartisan Senate permitting deal, Bloomberg News reported Oct. 22, citing a person familiar with the talks.
The Senate voted 73-25 on Nov. 9 to take up that bill, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. Trump told reporters that day he backs it but “will not approve wind turbines because wind turbines are a major loser.”
The chamber passed the bill 62-33 on Nov. 19 after adopting a substitute version from Republican West Virginia Sen. Shelley Moore Capito 69-27 on Nov. 18, roll call records show.
Democratic Rhode Island Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, who helped negotiate the bill, wrote on X after the Nov. 9 vote that its “ultimate success” depends on the administration “getting wind turbines up and spinning.”
Tom Vinson, a vice president at the American Clean Power Association, backed the wind groups’ push for deadlines in an Oct. 20 filing that drew partly on what the association’s members told him.
“Despite the Court’s clear orders, DoD has not resumed review,” he wrote.
One Oregon developer signed its mitigation agreement in July 2025 and had waited 15 months for the department to sign it, Vinson wrote. Planned investment in the project totals about $300 million, according to his filing.
Vinson also objected to the department’s new template for those agreements, which he wrote runs 119 pages.
“What a developer receives is, in effect, a revocable consent. In my experience, lenders and investors do not finance a project whose mitigation agreement, and with it the basis for DoD’s non-objection to the project, can be withdrawn in that way,” he wrote.
For many projects, negotiating the new terms “could take a year or longer,” Vinson added.
The template is not aimed at wind, according to Marks. Its first use was in an Air Force negotiation over a transmission line, and a version went to the Army for solar projects.
“In short, the model MA is not unique to wind, nor intended to encumber wind development projects,” Marks wrote.
Government lawyers wrote Nov. 3 that the department “has returned to reviewing applications, as the Court’s injunction required.” They cited a deal the department and one developer signed Oct. 28 after 45 duty days, or about 65 days in all, of talks.
The agreement “suggests the dire predictions forecast in the Vinson declaration are unlikely to come to pass,” Marks wrote.
The department’s response to the wind groups is due Dec. 24.
All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact [email protected].