Supreme Court Indicates Its Time For Biggest Shakeup To Federal Bureaucracy In Nearly A Century
The era of “independent agencies” might soon be over. The Supreme Court seemed inclined on Monday to allow the president to fire members of “independent” multi-member coalitions, which the Trump administration argues…


The era of “independent agencies” might soon be over.
The Supreme Court seemed inclined on Monday to allow the president to fire members of “independent” multi-member coalitions, which the Trump administration argues are really a “headless fourth branch” of government that operates without political accountability or democratic control.
The case, Trump v. Slaughter, centers on a simple question: can President Donald Trump fire Federal Trade Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter? Standing in the way of his decision is a 90-year-old precedent, Humphrey’s Executor v. United States, which limits the president’s ability to remove members of multi-member commissions like the FTC without cause.
The conservative justices have greenlit several of Trump’s attempts to remove other agency officials since he took office in January, including members of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) and Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC).
Court watchers interpreted these emergency docket decisions as an indication the justices were ready to do away with Humphrey’s Executor entirely. Strong signals during oral arguments from the majority seemed to confirm this is the likely outcome.
Chief Justice John Roberts called the precedent a “dried husk of whatever people used to think it was” because the FTC looks far different today than it did in 1935.



