Michigan Sues Alleging Mackinac Ferry Monopoly

Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel has sued the Hoffmann Family of Companies and affiliated businesses, alleging they illegally monopolized passenger ferry service to Mackinac Island. The state says Hoffmann acquired a controlling stake in Shepler’s in 2022 and bought the Mackinac Island Ferry Company in 2024, bringing the island’s two main ferry operators under common control and giving the company control of passenger docks and about 80% of long-term parking near mainland terminals. The complaint alleges Hoffmann raised fares and fees, reduced service and threatened to suspend operations during disputes with local officials. Nessel is seeking court-ordered changes to restore competition, potentially including the sale of some holdings, as well as restitution, damages, civil penalties and repayment of alleged unlawful profits. The case is separate from ongoing litigation over the city’s authority to regulate ferry fares and parking; the allegations have not been proven in court.