Lanterns reveals John Stewart's father was Guardians' first choice before Hal Jordan

Lanterns positions itself as a grounded detective mystery, stripping space opera for a True Detective–style investigation that follows Hal Jordan and John Stewart as they hunt a hidden Manhunter and unravel origin stories. Episode 3 reveals that John Sr. was first approached by the Guardians to be Green Lantern, with Hal ultimately chosen after a Guardian visit convinces the family of John Jr.'s potential. The series has sparked controversy among fans and critics over Hal’s portrayal, with some arguing it diverges from the classic hero and even notable writers like Grant Morrison criticizing the depiction. The backstory from the comics — including Hal's fall into Parallax after Coast City’s destruction and the Emerald Twilight arc — is discussed as a lens for the show’s tone and character dynamics. Visuals favor a practical, battle-worn Hal Jordan suit, signaling a shift away from glossy superhero outfits toward tactile, street-level realism. DC Studios has framed Lanterns as a cornerstone of the new DC Universe, bringing together creators Mundy, Lindelof, and Tom King to establish a grounded, detective-led approach to Hal and John's evolving relationship.