Ninth Circuit revives NFL antitrust verdict on Sunday Ticket deals

On Oct. 30, 2026, Judges Holly Thomas, Anthony Johnstone and Joan Lefkow of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco reinstated a Los Angeles jury's 2024 finding that the NFL violated antitrust law through Sunday Ticket out-of-market deals, while ordering a new trial on damages only. The June 2024 jury had awarded $4.7 billion—$4.6 billion to about 2.4 million residential subscribers and roughly $97 million to some 48,000 businesses—for DirecTV purchases in the 2011–2022 seasons. Judge Philip Gutierrez later voided that result after excluding experts Daniel Rascher and Douglas Zona, describing Rascher's model as developed based on speculation and ipse dixit opinion. The panel held Gutierrez abused his discretion. It wrote that the district court abused its discretion by excluding the subscriber's expert testimony, that yardsticks rely on comparable real-world markets to predict a but-for world, and that Rascher's conclusion was a reliable application of that method. On damages, the panel found the award based on speculation or guesswork and clearly not supported by the evidence, so it cannot stand. An NFL spokesperson said the league's model remains by far the most fan-friendly in sports and entertainment; the league said it was disappointed and may seek further review. Either side may seek further review; the new damages figure is unresolved.






