Dem Mayor Revives Pre-2008 Mortgage Playbook That Helped Fuel Housing Crisis

Democratic Philadelphia Mayor Cherelle Parker said Tuesday that the city hopes to launch a publicly backed mortgage program before the end of 2026, offering low down payments and expanded access to borrowers with weaker credit histories in a move that echoes elements of mortgage lending before the 2008 financial crisis.

The proposed One Philly Mortgage program would provide first-time homebuyers with 30-year fixed-rate loans, down payments of no more than 3% and no private mortgage insurance, according to Axios. The initiative shares certain characteristics with pre-financial crisis efforts to expand homeownership among borrowers with limited savings or imperfect credit, although its fixed-rate structure and modern lending requirements distinguish it from riskier mortgage products that contributed to the housing collapse.

“Imagine getting a mortgage, a 30-year commitment, with no PMI,” Parker told Axios reporter Emily Peck during an Axios Live event, adding that the program would be accessible to borrowers with “less-than-perfect credit.”

Philadelphia secured Citizens Bank as its first participating lender and is negotiating with additional financial institutions, according to Axios. The city plans to subsidize mortgage rates by approximately one percentage point below prevailing market levels, potentially saving qualifying borrowers thousands of dollars annually.

The Parker administration estimates that a borrower purchasing a $200,000 home could save approximately $3,400 annually under the proposed structure, Axios reported.

The initiative is part of Parker’s $2 billion Housing Opportunities Made Easy, or H.O.M.E., plan, which aims to build, preserve or restore 30,000 housing units across Philadelphia.

Under the proposed mortgage structure, the city would establish reserves to protect participating lenders against loan losses, removing the need for borrowers to purchase private mortgage insurance. Public funds would also support reduced interest rates, according to the city’s housing agency.

Private mortgage insurance is generally required on conventional loans when borrowers make down payments below 20% of a home’s purchase price. Although the insurance protects lenders against losses, the additional expense increases monthly housing costs for buyers with limited savings.

The program’s combination of smaller down payments and expanded access to mortgage credit recalls lending practices that became widespread in the years preceding the 2008 financial crisis. The Federal Reserve identified the expansion of mortgages to higher-risk borrowers, including those with weaker credit histories and limited down payments, as a contributing factor to the housing boom and subsequent collapse.