Foreign Wars And So-Called Groyper Revolt: Inside Libertarian Think Tank’s ‘America First’ Event
Francis Kapper · Nov 18, 2026 · 6 min read

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Foreign policy analysts gathered in Washington on Tuesday with Republican Ohio Rep. Warren Davidson to examine whether President Donald Trump’s “America First” movement has abandoned its founding principles following a disastrous midterm election and months of war with Iran.
America’s most prominent libertarian think tank, the Cato Institute, hosted its “Reclaiming America First” event Nov. 17, bringing together foreign policy scholars to examine the Republican Party’s electoral defeat and Washington’s growing military commitments abroad. The discussions focused on whether Trump’s interventionist policies have undermined his promise to end America’s prolonged foreign wars.
“If Republicans had delivered on what they said they would do in the 2024 election, this fragile coalition that unites the GOP, that holds America First, that holds the neoconservatives, that holds conservative-leaning libertarians, and frankly, some just pragmatic people, that make up a lot of America’s middle class that want results,” Davidson said during the opening remarks of the event. “If that had happened, then I think we would be talking about a different post-election analysis. And it didn’t happen. And I think the most common denominator is a lot of people felt unheard. They felt unheard on the Iran war. They felt unheard on the economy.”
Democrats regained control of both chambers of Congress in the Nov. 3 midterms, flipping nine Republican-held Senate seats and securing a 56-44 majority in the upper chamber. Democrats also gained 42 House seats as of Tuesday, according to the Associated Press.
The event featured two panel discussions examining the political consequences of the Iran war and the future of American foreign policy. Participants included representatives from the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, the Quincy Institute, Stand Together and the Institute for Peace and Diplomacy, according to Cato.
“The war in Iran in particular was on voters’ minds. It was, I would say, a probably top three issue, depends how you slice and dice what’s an issue and what’s not, but it was a major issue in this campaign,” Stephen Wertheim, senior fellow in the American Statecraft Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, said during the panel. “And I think actually this election stands out as being one about which you can say that … It was a war they did not want; they did not vote for Donald Trump to do. They thought it was the kind of thing he would not do, and it represented a kind of betrayal.”
The debate follows months of growing public dissatisfaction with the Iran war, which began in February and has contributed to higher energy prices and broader economic uncertainty.
Approximately 74% of voters said the Iran war was either a crucial or major factor in their congressional vote, according to the ABC News Voter Poll. Thirty-four percent called the conflict crucial, while another 40% described it as a major factor.
The Voter Poll by SSRS was designed to survey more than 75,000 voters nationally between Oct. 19 and Nov. 3 through online, telephone and in-person interviews, with an expected national margin of sampling error of plus or minus 0.6 percentage points, according to the poll’s methodology.




