Judge Wanted Courts’ Climate Guide To Avoid Getting Ahead Of The Science On Company-Specific Injuries, Emails Show
A judge reviewing the federal courts' science guide wanted its climate chapter to warn the research cannot yet tie specific harms to individual companies.
Simon August · Nov 17, 2026 · 5 min read

A judge reviewing the federal courts’ science guide wanted its climate chapter to warn that the research cannot yet tie specific harms to individual companies.
The unnamed judge wanted the chapter to say the science “does not support micro-level conclusions” tying a particular defendant to specific plaintiffs’ injuries, a Federal Judicial Center official wrote in a July 25, 2024, email. The Republican-led House Judiciary Committee released the emails with a Sept. 30 staff report, and its Subcommittee on Courts, Intellectual Property, Artificial Intelligence, and the Internet holds a related hearing Thursday.
“The judge thought the science may get there some day, but it would disserve judges and litigants to suggest it’s there now,” Beth Wiggins, director of the center’s Research Division, wrote to the chapter’s authors.
Jessica Wentz, a non-resident senior fellow at Columbia Law School’s Sabin Center for Climate Change Law, replied July 26 that the question is “ultimately a case specific determination.”
“I think it would be incorrect to broadly assert that the science cannot currently support such claims at this time,” Wentz wrote. “To the contrary, existing scientific research could potentially support a factual finding that a defendant has contributed to specific climate change-related injuries (again, depending on the facts of the case).”
Wiggins had written that the manual’s oversight committee signed off on the draft for outside review. The center would ask those reviewers whether it “accurately describes the certainty/uncertainty associated with climate science” and “appropriately caveats its relevance to potential litigation,” she wrote. Wiggins suggested the authors take up the judge’s comment once the reviewers weighed in.
Wentz wrote in her reply that the authors could “wait to fully respond to this comment until we receive further input from external reviewers.”
The center puts out the Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence with the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine. One National Academies official called the manual “the primary reference source on scientific methodology for the federal judiciary” in an email on Dec. 29, 2022.
Wentz and Columbia Climate School professor Radley Horton wrote the chapter, which the center and the National Academies published Dec. 31, 2025, without the caveat the judge suggested. The chapter’s introduction says judges may face “genuine scientific questions and areas of uncertainty” when they decide whether a defendant contributed to a plaintiff’s injuries.




