Scientists Claim There Is Not a ‘Simple’ Answer to Define ‘Woman’
Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson is receiving criticism for declining to provide a definition for the word “woman” during her Supreme Court confirmation hearing, but scientists argue her answer is “commendable,” according to…

Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson is receiving criticism for declining to provide a definition for the word “woman” during her Supreme Court confirmation hearing, but scientists argue her answer is “commendable,” according to an article in USA Today.
An article published by USA Today on Thursday states, “Scientists, gender law scholars and philosophers of biology said Jackson’s response was commendable, though perhaps misleading. It’s useful, they say, that Jackson suggested science could help answer Blackburn’s question, but they note that a competent biologist would not be able to offer a definitive answer either.”
“Scientists agree there is no sufficient way to clearly define what makes someone a woman, and with billions of women on the planet, there is much variation,” it added.
Rebecca Jordan-Young, a scientist and gender studies scholar at Barnard College, told the paper, “I don’t want to see this question punted to biology as if science can offer a simple, definitive answer.”
“The rest of her answer was more interesting and important. She said ‘as a judge, what I do is I address disputes. If there’s a dispute about a definition, people make arguments, and I look at the law, and I decide.’ In other words, she said context matters – which is true in both biology and society. I think that’s a pretty good answer for a judge,” she continued.
Jordan-Young added, “There isn’t one single ‘biological’ answer to the definition of a woman. There’s not even a singular biological answer to the question of ‘what is a female.”
The story went on:
“There are at least six different biological markers of ‘sex’ in the body: genitals, chromosomes, gonads, internal reproductive structures, hormone ratios and secondary sex characteristics. None of the six is strictly dichotomous.”



